Two playoff games in a year and things literally couldn’t get any closer between West Allegheny and McKeesport. In November 2016, an extra point separated the two in a WPIAL title game.

Fifty weeks later, it was extra, extra, read all about it again. This time, it was McKeesport pointing to the win.

McKeesport edged host West Allegheny, 22-21, Friday night in a WPIAL Class 5A quarterfinal. The difference in the game was an extra-point kick missed by West Allegheny after scoring early in the fourth quarter to pull within one.

“Great game,” McKeesport coach Matt Miller said. “Two old-school type teams with everyone running the ball and playing smashmouth football, and we were able to pull it out.”

Advertise with us

McKeesport’s players celebrated afterward. A year ago, they were in agony when they lost to West Allegheny, 38-37, in overtime at Heinz Field when West Allegheny converted a 2-point conversion. But for McKeesport, revenge wasn’t a motivating factor, at least according to Miller.

“Playoffs are big enough. You don’t need anything else,” Miller said. “There were no hard feelings or any animosity toward [West Allegheny ] at all. ... The players were just like, ‘Well, this is who we play.’ It wasn’t revenge.”

McKeesport 22, West Allegheny 21

For West Allegheny (7-3), it was a tough loss to end the season — and quite possibly the career of Bob Palko, the coach who built West Allegheny into one of the top programs in the state in his 23 seasons. He is a man who has won more WPIAL titles (eight) than any coach in league history, but Palko is very seriously considering resigning. He almost did after last season and he acknowledged he might this year, but a final decision hasn’t been made.

Palko was gracious in defeat, but it was an emotional time in the center of the field after the game. Palko hugged players. He held back tears a few times, talking about the grit and toughness of his team and the pride that he has for his players. It was almost as if he knew this was probably his last game. His wife, Sally, stood nearby. As Palko walked off the field to the locker room about 20 minutes after the game, he strolled through a line of fans, some who simply yelled, “Palk.” Maybe they knew this could be it for a man who became a veritable legend, a coach with a record of 207-70.

“I’m retiring from working in the education field. That much I know,” Palko said. “I’ll have to think about what I will do with coaching. But no matter what I do doesn’t mean I’m retiring from life.”

Advertise with us

On the other side, Miller is in the semifinals for the second time in his two years as coach. And the Tigers (8-2) beat West Allegheny in typical McKeesport fashion — running and with big plays. McKeesport completed only 1 of 3 passes, but running backs Layton Jordan, Carlinos Acie and quarterback John Harper each had between 83 and 103 yards rushing and combined for an 8.5 yards-per-carry average. The three came in averaging 9.9 yards-per-carry average.

Harper finished with 103 yards on 13 carries, Acie 93 on 6 attempts and Jordan 83 on 14. Harper scored on a 51-yard run, Acie on a 36-yarder and Jordan on a 9-yarder.

McKeesport led at halftime, 14-7, but West Allegheny’s Will Weber scored on an 80-yard run on the second play of the third quarter and Noah Ledford ran for the 2-point conversion to put the Indians ahead, 15-14. Weber had a terrific game taking direct snaps in the wildcat formation and rushing for 165 yards on 28 attempts.

But after Weber’s score, Jordan capped a 72-ayrd drive with a 9-yard touchdown run and Jordan also ran for the 2-point conversion that turned out to be the difference in the game with 7:27 left in the third quarter. It was “the sheet” that made Miller go for 2.

“We have a little sheet that says go for 2 when you’re up five,” Miller said. “I had a coach tell me that before we started that drive. I don’t know who made the sheet, but it’s like the bible everywhere. It sits in the bottom of a desk and we pull it out when the season starts. It worked.”

Advertise with us

Weber, who also had a 1-yard touchdown run earlier in the game, threw a 13-yard touchdown pass to Mateo Vandamia with 9:16 remaining to make it 22-21. Palko wasn’t ready to go for 2 yet, but Kolbe Stout missed the extra-point kick. He also missed a 25-yard field goal earlier in the game.

“We’re undersized up front on defense,” Miller said. “We had difficulty stopping their ball control. Luckily, we were able to tighten it up a couple times near the end zone.”

Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh.