McKeesport’s players had already come on the field to celebrate. First-year coach Matt Miller was frosty from the water cooler shower. Then came the cold, hard facts.

Penalty. Hold on. Game on — again.

Only minutes later came the bone-chilling reality for the McKeesport Tigers. West Allegheny was champions.

In what will go down as one of the best, craziest — and controversial — finishes in the history of WPIAL championships, West Allegheny edged McKeesport, 38-37, in overtime to win the WPIAL 5A championship Friday night at Heinz Field.

Advertise with us

A game that dripped with drama in the final few minutes ended when West Allegheny quarterback Nick Ross ran for the winning two-point conversion in overtime after the Indians had scored to make it 37-36. While West Allegheny’s players chased down Ross and mobbed him, a few McKeesport players fell to the ground. The Tigers were crushed. They seemingly had their hands around the championship trophy.

“When you think you won it and you have that feeling of satisfaction, and then to have it ripped away?” said a distraught Miller outside of a silent McKeesport locker room. “We felt like we finished it three times, but they kept getting more chances.”

West Allegheny coach Bob Palko won his eighth WPIAL title, the most of any coach. But this championship was unlike any other.

“So many things happened in this game, I don’t even know if I can grasp everything” said Palko.

West Allegheny defeats McKeesport in the WPIAL 5A Championship

On the final play of regulation, with McKeesport holding a 30-27 lead, West Allegheny’s D.J. Opsatnik tried a 50-yard field goal that fell short. But officials called a 15-yard, roughing-the-kicker penalty on Jayvaun Shears, to give Opsatnik another chance. West Allegheny’s kicker had made the second-most field goals in WPIAL history (32) and he converted the second chance, nailing a 34-yarder that sent the game into overtime and made workers shovel off the ice near the McKeesport sideline that came from the water cooler shower.

Advertise with us

As for the penalty, Opsatnik said, “He definitely took out my leg. I looked at the ref and saw him throw a flag. I just stayed calm and did what I had to do to prepare for another kick.”

McKeesport had won last week’s semifinal game with a “Hail Mary” pass on the final play of the game. This time, divine intervention switched sides.

West Allegheny offensive lineman Kieran Firment said, “After that kick, I turned around saw the flag and said, ‘It’s not over yet.’ I thought someone above must be looking out for us.”

Shears tried to block the kick and landed near Opsatnik’s feet.

“He nicked him, but it didn’t have any effect on the kick whatsoever,” said Miller.

Advertise with us

It was the second controversial call that went against McKeesport and had a big effect on the game. Minutes earlier, West Allegheny faced a fourth-and-three at the McKeesport 6 when Ross’ pass was intercepted in the end zone by McKeesport’s Carlinos Acie. But on the other side of the field, McKeesport was called for defensive holding. The penalty moved the ball to the 3 and Will Weber scored two plays later on a 1-yard run that put West Allegheny ahead, 30-24.

“I’m a little angry,” said Miller. “Too many game-changing calls. West Allegheny had one penalty called against them. They’re good, but come on.”

In high school overtimes, both teams get a possession from the 10-yard line. If the game is still tied, the process is repeated. McKeesport got the ball first and Ray Zellars scored on a fourth-down, 1-yard run. Caleb Schork kicked the extra point. West Allegheny got the ball, and the Indians’ coaching staff had already decided what would happen if they scored.

“I didn’t think we could stop them and I was pretty confident in our two-point game,” said Palko. “The kids worked too hard to get back in it to not go for it.”

West Allegheny got its overtime touchdown when Will Weber scored on a 2-yard run. But Opsatnik never came off the sideline.

Advertise with us

“The adversity that we had to overcome tonight I think is what makes this special,” said Palko.

McKeesport led, 22-14 after three quarters. West Allegheny came back, thanks in part to recovering two onside kicks. A 23-yard touchdown pass from Ross to Mateo Vandamia and Weber’s 2-yard run put the Indians ahead with 2:35 left. But McKeesport quickly drove 56 yards in six plays for a score, behind the running of 5-foot-10, 235-pound tank Ray Zellars, who finished with 111 yards on 21 carries. Acie added 96 yards on nine carries and quarterback Shears added 89 yards.

But the run that won the game came from Ross in overtime, on a play that West Allegheny uses only for two-point conversions. The Indians had tried it only once before this year and it didn’t work. An offside penalty on McKeesport moved West Allegheny a yard-and-a-half closer to the end zone before Ross dropped to pass, rolled to his right and took off into the end zone. Ross was 26 of 39 for 259 yards.

“It’s a pass play, but if no one is open, I have to run,” said Ross. “No one was open, I saw a lane, so I just ran it.”

And this time the game was over. For real.

Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh