Five of the top football players from Ambridge High School have transferred to other schools in the past two months, and the WPIAL has ruled four of them eligible to play.
The WPIAL board of directors had five separate hearings with the players today to determine if their transfers were for athletic intent, which is against WPIAL and PIAA rules. After the hearings, the board deliberated privately for about a half-hour before ruling that receiver-defensive back Isaiah McNair is ineligible to play football at Quaker Valley this upcoming season because he transferred at least partly for athletic intent.
The WPIAL ruled the other four players eligible for this season. Junior RB-DB Davion Jones and his cousin, FB-LB Tariq Jones, are eligible to play at Aliquippa. Junior QB Austin French can play at Beaver Falls and sophomore lineman John Prentice at Cardinal Wuerl North Catholic.
The case is one of the most bizarre in WPIAL history. WPIAL executive director Tim O’Malley said the league had never seen so many transfers from one team in such a short period of time.
Ambridge had contested all the transfers, claiming they were for athletic intent. They claimed the transfers were because of turmoil in the Ambridge program with Dan Bradley resigning as coach and Terry George being hired. At the hearings, George told the WPIAL the transfers were made because the players were worried the team would struggle next year because only one lineman was returning (Prentice). Four of the five who transferred are skill-position players, including the starting quarterback, the top running backs and the top receiver.
But O’Malley said the board of directors felt there wasn’t enough evidence from Ambridge to prove athletic intent.
“There has to be objective substantiated evidence. That’s what the transfer rule is based on,” O’Malley said. “It can’t be an opinion. It can’t be ‘we think.’ The difference with the McNair situation is there was some evidence. By no means was it a unanimous vote [on McNair], but the majority opinion was that there was something substantiated that was motivated by an athletic purpose.”
McNair, Tariq Jones, Davion Jones and French all moved with a parent into their new school districts. Administrators from all the schools said at the hearings that residence was proven. The players’ parents gave various reasons for the move. But all of the parents and players claimed football wasn’t the reason for the move.
Prentice’s family did not move because he transferred to a parochial school. All of the hearings were open to the media, except the Prentice hearing because North Catholic asked for it to be closed.
O’Malley was asked about how coincidental it was that the leases for residences of a few of the players all expired in March.
“They put their hands up and said they were telling the truth, so what are you going to do,” said O’Malley. “If you connect the dots, the court of public opinion might be … But from an evidentiary standpoint, nothing was established that would give an indication that the board should vote that [athletic intent was involved].”
A few of the players were standouts at Ambridge. Tariq Jones was a first-team all-Greater Allegheny Conference linebacker while Davion Jones rushed for more than 700 yards.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.