It was the Pitt recruiting version of a double take on Penn State.

Over the course of Monday, Pitt beat Penn State for two WPIAL football recruits. One finally made his college decision and chose Pitt. Another backtracked from a previous decision and decided he wanted to play for Pitt after all. Chalk it up as two big catches for Pitt.

Central Catholic senior Damar Hamlin, ranked as one of the top defensive backs in the country, announced on KDKA-TV Monday night that he will play for Pitt. Just before Hamlin announced his choice, Clairton receiver Aaron Mathews wrote on his Twitter account that he had backed out of a verbal commitment to Penn State and decided to play at Pitt.

Hamlin chose Pitt over Penn State and Ohio State and insisted he didn’t decide until about an hour before his announcement. He was having so much trouble making a choice among the three that the ordeal brought him to tears earlier in the day.

Advertise with us

“I actually cried because I didn’t know what to do,” Hamlin said.

But when he announced, there was joy at Pitt as coach Pat Narduzzi landed the No. 7 safety in the country, according to Rivals.com. Hamlin might play cornerback at Pitt.

As for Mathews, he committed to Penn State in late December a few weeks after the Nittany Lions offered him a scholarship.

Pitt also had offered Mathews a scholarship, but Mathews (6 feet 4, 192 pounds) said Pitt recruited him as a defensive back. Then, a few days ago, Pitt came back to Mathews and said it would take him as a receiver after a spot came open when Juwan Winfree and Pitt parted ways. Winfree played at Coffeyville Community College in Kansas.

“I always wanted to play receiver at Pitt,” Mathews said. “A receiver spot opened, and I took it.”

Advertise with us

Hamlin (6-2, 189) made his announcement without knowing Mathews had flipped to Pitt. When Hamlin was told about Mathews, he said, “That’s crazy. It’s a good day in the city.”

Hamlin is a big catch for Pitt. He had dozens of scholarship offers from schools across the country. He said he woke up Monday morning and still didn’t know whether to choose Pitt, Penn State or Ohio State.

He will sign a binding letter of intent Wednesday.

“I finally just got a feeling [about Pitt],” Hamlin said. “I was weighing all my options and thinking everything through. I want to be successful on and off the field. Just doing it in my city would make it all that much more special.”

Hamlin had 83 tackles and two interceptions in 2015 and helped Central Catholic win WPIAL and PIAA Class AAAA championships. Last week, Pitt coach Pat Narduzzi, Ohio State coach Urban Meyer and Penn State coach James Franklin were at Central Catholic over two days.

Advertise with us

“I’m not sure of anyone whose talent transfers over to college as well as him,” Central Catholic coach Terry Totten said. “He’s a long, athletic cornerback and those are prime gets, evidenced by all the fuss going on with his recruiting. Then, if you find an athletic kid whose long, tall and can tackle like him, he becomes all the more special.”

Winfree announced Sunday night on Twitter that he had de-committed from the Panthers. He was rated as a four-star prospect on Rivals.com.

He originally enrolled at Maryland out of high school and caught 11 passes for 158 yards and two touchdowns as a freshman in 2014. After two suspensions for off-field issues, though, Winfree left the Terrapins and enrolled in junior college.

Before Mathews’ arrival and after Winfree’s departure, Pitt was left with four-star prospect Ruben Flowers and three-star Maurice French (who could play defense) as its only receiver commitments for 2016. That's a position of need for the Panthers heading into next year without Tyler Boyd, who entered the NFL draft.

Sam Werner contributed to this report. Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and on Twitter @mwhiteburgh. Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and on Twitter @SWernerPG.