It was a month or so ago that Don Holl’s mother showed him an old picture of Holl wearing a T-shirt that had “Gateway Football” on it with the team’s schedule. Holl was 9 years old in the 1975 photo, and you could consider the picture odd because Holl lived in Erie at the time.
“When I was a kid, Monroeville Mall was an attractive destination for people in Pittsburgh,” said Holl. “If you would go to Steeler games, you’d go to Monroeville Mall. My mom bought me that Gateway shirt from Monroeville Mall because Gateway football was big.”
Now picture this: Forty-one years later, Holl will start wearing Gateway High School football garb again. He is the Gators’ new coach.
Talk about karma.
“Maybe this was just supposed to be,” Holl said last week after being named coach.
Holl will take over a once-proud Gateway program that has been on the unstable side in recent years. He will be the Gators’ fourth coach in the past five seasons. Terry Smith built the Gators into a strong program in his 11 seasons as coach before resigning after the 2012 season. Donnie Militzer coached the Gators in 2013 before the school district opened his job. Tom Nola left Clairton after a great run with the Bears to become Gateway’s coach in 2014. He retired after this past season.
So, here comes Holl, with a resume of some success as a head coach at Erie Cathedral Prep and Seneca Valley. Holl, 50, played at Navy and also has been a college assistant at Gannon University. He resigned as Seneca Valley’s coach after the 2014 season and spent this past season as offensive coordinator at New Castle.
At Seneca Valley, Holl had a 37-25 record in six seasons and had teams that went 10-2 in 2012 and 9-2 in 2013. In four seasons at Erie Cathedral Prep, he was 36-14.
“I would’ve been happy to go back to New Castle,” said Holl. “But this [Gateway] job opened and it was very attractive to me.”
Gateway was once one of the strongest programs in Western Pennsylvania when Pete Antimarino coached the Gators from 1958-89. The stadium is named after him. Gateway had some down years after Antimarino left, but returned to prominence under Smith.
Gateway had always played in the largest WPIAL classification, but played the past two years in Class AAA (second largest). The Gators did not make the WPIAL playoffs last season.
“You learn to get an admiration for things like tradition and history,” said Holl. “Pete Antimarino, Western Pennsylvania football, the things Terry Smith did, the athletes, the legacies … there’s not a lot of Gateways out there.”
Holl will continue to live in the Seneca Valley district. He is a social studies teacher at Seneca Valley High School and his two youngest children attend Seneca Valley.
“I’ve always liked Gateway from a distance,” Holl said. “In fact, I’ve always known about them. My senior year [at Erie Prep] we actually came down and played at Gateway and I actually had a couple touchdowns in that game.”
Holl’s teams have been known for offense and for his final few years at Seneca Valley, he used to coach from the press box and call plays. He does not think he will coach from the press box at Gateway, at least not the first year.
“I think Gateway can and always should be in the conversation of top teams,” Holl said. “For as long as Pete Antimarino had it going, it’s one of those all-time kind of jobs in Western Pennsylvania.”
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1975 and Twitter @mwhiteburgh





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.