A total of 215 yards were gained between University Prep and Brashear in Thursday night’s City League semifinal game at Cupples Stadium. Unfortunately for the Wildcats, they needed one more to keep their season alive.

On fourth-and-6, the Bulls defense stood tall at their 23, stopping Shawn Rutherford chain links shy of a first down and Brashear held on for a 7-6 victory. The call came with some controversy as the chains were accidentally moved for a first down the previous play when it was fourth-and-1.

“Complete disbelief,” University Prep head coach Lou Berry said. “The way they handled the situation. They were confused. They were looking for a clip. I don’t know if they ever found it. To be honest, it looked like guess work to me.”

The Bulls, who only gained 62 yards in the game, relied on their defense and capitalized on a muffed punt late in the first half. Senior Therran Coleman connected with Tra Palmer for the 22-yard strike with 42 seconds left in the half. Dom Molinaro converted the extra point to give the Bulls a 7-6 lead. The defense held Rutherford to 4-of-22 passing and 38 yards. Rutherford didn’t complete a pass until the fourth quarter, starting the game 0 for 13.

Advertise with us

“We tried to mix in some of our athletes,” Brashear head coach Rick Murphy said. “We played some guys in places they didn’t usually play and try to pressure him as much as possible.”

Rutherford did manage to get the Wildcats on the board first with a 1-yard score in the first quarter. Unfortunately, the extra point was pulled left, which turned out to be the difference for the Wildcats.

“I’m actually speechless,” Berry said. “I don’t know if I’m being biased, but I thought we dominated the game, at least from the defensive side of the ball. We didn’t take advantage of our opportunities. Every time we made plays, there were untimely penalties. It was a real fluky night.”

The Bulls (6-3) defeated the Wildcats (5-4) for the second time this season and second consecutive season in the semifinals and will have the opportunity to defend their city league title next week.