The possibility of Pennsylvania expanding to six classifications in football is one of the hottest high school sports topics in this state in a number of years.
While members of the WPIAL board of directors strongly oppose the expansion, and the majority of WPIAL schools also are against six classifications, a survey shows the idea does have support from some district schools.
The Post-Gazette surveyed every athletic director from the 123 schools that have a football team and asked their opinions on the PIAA's proposal to expand to six classifications in football (there are four classes now). The survey also asked if basketball, baseball and softball should expand to six classes, as well as other sports adding classifications. Finally, the survey asked if the WPIAL should drop out of the PIAA in football only.
Seventy ADs responded and the survey showed:
• Twenty-seven percent favor the idea of the PIAA going to six classifications, starting next season. Four ADs said they don't care one way or another.
• Several athletic directors said they couldn't answer the question of expansion in basketball and other sports because it would depend whether football expands. Sixteen ADs said they believe other sports should definitely add classifications.
Read More
• Thirteen ADs said the WPIAL should drop out of the PIAA for football if the six classifications idea passes. Two said the WPIAL should drop out of the PIAA in all sports.
"This subject is an attention-getter, for sure," said Quaker Valley athletic director Mike Mastroianni. "With the nature of Western Pennsylvania football, it has become a hot topic. I know there has been some talk about this for a while, but a lot of times things like that go away. But all of a sudden, this [six classifications] is right here in front of us."
Mastroianni favors going to six classes in football, but believes the extra classifications are not needed in other sports.
The subject of six classes in football hit the forefront last week when the PIAA strategic planning committee voted to recommend that the PIAA board of directors approve a proposal to add 5A and 6A classifications in football, starting next season. PIAA executive director Bob Lombardi said the idea has already passed two votes and needs only to be passed one more time at a PIAA board meeting Oct. 19.
The PIAA also will consider a proposal to add two classifications in basketball, baseball and softball and examine the possibility of adding classes in other sports.
Classifications in all PIAA sports are based on school enrollments. Every school in the state must give the PIAA its student enrollment in grades 9-11 by Oct. 1. The enrollments will be used to determine classifications and those classes will be released in December.
WPIAL executive director Tim O'Malley said the league is opposed to 6A football because it would have a negative effect on the league's schools. He says the PIAA has not given a good reason why classifications should be added. But Lombardi claims the move is wanted by schools to equal the playing field some, where some schools play against other schools that are sometimes twice their size.
But WPIAL officials, and a number of athletic directors, believe the six classification idea will take away some long-standing rivalries, as well as add costly travel time, when athletic budgets are shrinking.
"A lot of athletic directors are worried about geography," said Bill Cherpak, athletic director and football coach at Thomas Jefferson. "I understand where the PIAA and some teams might be coming from, but for the WPIAL, it's not the best thing. The WPIAL is so much different than any other part of the state and how we run things. For so many, their district championship doesn't mean anything to them."
Having six classifications would create some lengthy road trips for some WPIAL schools, but already Greensburg Salem, Gateway, Indiana and Altoona play in a conference with Mars, Hampton and Knoch. Some non-conference games this year that are scheduled by the WPIAL are Hopewell at McKeesport, Ambridge at Baldwin, Brownsville at Beaver, and McGuffey at Mohawk.
Chartiers-Houston athletic director Kurt Kesneck is for six classes.
"Some conferences might align better geographically," said Kesneck. "It would bring back some of our natural rivals, I think. Right now, we're in a conference with North Catholic, Avonworth and OLSH.
"I know there are lot of opinions and some people say there will be more travel. But some teams already are traveling more. But I do think you have to remain consistent. If you're going to expand in football, you need to expand in other sports."
Mastroianni said, "I think [six classes] fits in football, but I'm not so sure it does in other sports. My opinion is more based on the numbers and just the nature of football. With six classes, it might be a good opportunity for some -- not all -- of the smaller schools in a class to even the playing field."
Plum athletic director Bob Aplino also favors six classes.
"The change to six classes appears that it would create more enrollment parity," said Alpino. "However, the biggest challenge of expanding to six classes will be in revising the existing WPIAL playoff format."
Thirty-three states in the country have five classes or more in football.
"Sooner than later," Cherpak said, "there will be 20 classes so that everyone gets to win a championship and each kid gets a trophy and their name in the paper."
If the PIAA goes to six classifications in football next season, here is an idea of what WPIAL football might look like. Note that the following classifications are based on enrollment figures schools gave to the PIAA two years ago. Schools must give the PIAA new enrollment figures Oct 1. These classifications might change a little with new enrollment figures, and these classes are for football only. Classification breakdowns for basketball and other sports will be different.
CLASS 6A (13 SCHOOLS)
North Allegheny, Seneca Valley, Altoona, Butler, Hempfield, Central Catholic, Penn Hills, Mt. Lebanon, Norwin, Canon-McMillan, Shaler, Connellsville, Bethel Park.
CLASS 5A (19 SCHOOLS)
Pine-Richland, North Hills, Upper St. Clair, Peters Township, Baldwin, Fox Chapel, Penn-Trafford, Kiski Area, Plum, Latrobe, Woodland Hills, Moon, Franklin Regional, Gateway, McKeesport, Chartiers Valley, Armstrong, Albert Gallatin, Hampton.
CLASS AAAA (21 SCHOOLS)
Mars, West Allegheny, Knoch, Trinity, Laurel Highlands, Montour, Ringgold, Belle Vernon, West Mifflin, Thomas Jefferson, New Castle, Ambridge, Greensburg Salem, Uniontown, Hopewell, Indiana, Blackhawk, Central Valley, Elizabeth Forward, Yough, South Fayette.
CLASS AAA (21 SCHOOLS)
Mount Pleasant, Derry, McGuffey, Freeport, Highlands, Deer Lakes, Keystone Oaks, South Park, Quaker Valley, Beaver, Southmoreland, Burrell, Valley, Steel Valley, Brownsville, Waynesburg, Ellwood City, Mohawk, Shady Side Academy, East Allegheny, Summit Academy
CLASS AA (23 SCHOOLS)
West Shamokin, Charleroi, Beaver Falls, South Allegheny, Seton-LaSalle, New Brighton, Washington, Burgettstown, Freedom, Apollo-Ridge, Laurel, Avonworth, Riverside, Carlynton, Northgate, Beth-Center, South Side Beaver, Vincentian, Fort Cherry, Sto-Rox, Neshannock, Chartiers-Houston, Our Lady of the Sacred Heart.
CLASS A (25 SCHOOLS)
Shenango, Bentworth, Bishop Canevin, Aliquippa, Brentwood, Serra, Leechburg, Carmichaels, Riverview, Greensburg Central Catholic, Springdale, California, Frazier, West Greene, Jeannette, Jefferson-Morgan, Clairton, Rochester, Western Beaver, Monessen, Union, Wilkinsburg, Cardinal Wuerl North Catholic, Mapletown, Avella.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.