The possibility of 6A high school football in Pennsylvania is close to reality.
The PIAA strategic planning committee met Wednesday in Mechanicsburg and recommended that the PIAA board of directors vote in October to pass a proposal that will expand classifications in football from four to six, beginning next year. The PIAA football steering committee also met Wednesday and voted to recommend six classifications to the PIAA.
A switch to six classes would be a landmark move for Pennsylvania football. Since the state (PIAA) playoffs were started in 1988, there have only been four classifications. The WPIAL has played with four classifications since 1980, with the exception of five classes for two years in the early 1980s.
The PIAA strategic planning committee is made up of district representatives around the state. Those reps also are members of the PIAA board of directors that will have to pass the proposal at an Oct. 19 meeting. The PIAA board had approved the 6A idea two previous times, but directed the planning committee to meet one last time to come up with a final recommendation for the board.
Usually, the PIAA board approves the planning committee’s recommendations, but not always. The planning committee voted, 9-6, for six classes. The football steering committee voted, 9-3.
“I think the vote says there is a lot of sentiment out there by the membership that they want to see expansion of classifications,” said PIAA executive director Bob Lombardi, who also said he believes the 6A proposal will pass the vote in October.
Lombardi said the PIAA’s reason for expanding to six classes is to “equal the playing field” for some schools that have to play other schools with twice their enrollment or more. Pennsylvania is fifth in the country in terms of football-playing schools with 584. But 33 states have five classifications or more.
“I think a lot of our membership feels there is a competitive imbalance with the way classes are now and with the schools we have,” Lombardi said.
How would the WPIAL be affected by six classifications? Well, going by the most recent enrollment figures used by the PIAA, 13 WPIAL schools would be in 6A, 18 in 5A, 21 in AAAA, 22 in AAA, 24 in AA and 25 in A. Those figures could change some when schools give new enrollment figures to the PIAA by Oct. 1. Those figures will be used for the new classifications that would come out in December.
The 6A schools in the WPIAL, based on the most recent enrollment figures, would be North Allegheny, Seneca Valley, Altoona, Butler, Hempfield, Central Catholic, Penn Hills, Mt. Lebanon, Norwin, Canon-McMillan, Shaler, Connellsville and Bethel Park.
The WPIAL has been against the 6A idea. One of the reasons is that the WPIAL would no longer be able to play all of its title games in one day at Heinz Field. But WPIAL executive director Tim O’Malley said there are other reasons.
“We feel it would be more negative than positive for our schools. Are we expanding just to expand without sufficient reason?” O’Malley said. “We have been able to geographically align our conferences in the classifications. In spreading to six classes, are we going to be able to maintain that approach or are we going to lose some long-standing, geographic-friendly rivalries like North Hills and North Allegheny?”
The WPIAL also has been against the 6A idea if the PIAA didn’t expand classes in other sports. But there was development on that front Wednesday when the PIAA strategic planning committee voted to recommend to the PIAA board to examine expansion to six classes in boys and girls basketball, baseball and softball.
The PIAA expansion in sports other than football would have to pass three more votes, but the PIAA could suspend protocol and also pass the idea in October.
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1975 and Twitter @mwhiteburgh.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.