Peyton Manning’s departure from the Indianapolis Colts could have debilitated the franchise for years. It did not. A similar fate could have befallen the Green Bay Packers with the exodus of Brett Favre. Again, it did not.

The common denominator? Both franchises had a contingency plan in place. For the Colts, it was Andrew Luck. For the Packers, Aaron Rodgers. Neither skipped a beat.

South Fayette hopes to mirror those fortunes now that quarterback Brett Brumbaugh is at Duquesne University.

“We’re working through it right now,” coach Joe Rossi said during a break in training camp.

Advertise with us

Brumbaugh’s aerial excellence carried the Lions to back-to-back WPIAL and PIAA Class AA titles and a still-active 32-game winning streak, 10th best in the nation. His 11,804 career passing yards — the equivalent of 6.3 miles — is a state record. His predecessor was older brother Christian, who previously held the WPIAL all-time passing mark and guided South Fayette to the 2010 WPIAL title.

So, what’s the contingency plan for Class AA’s reigning preeminent program?

“We’re hoping one of our two quarterbacks separates and takes the job,” said Rossi, who had a Brumbaugh as his quarterback in seven of his first eight seasons at South Fayette. “This is new for us, no question. But good programs find a way to move on and be successful.”

The candidates vying to succeed Brumbaugh are junior Mikey Speca (5-11, 170) and sophomore Drew Saxton (6-1, 170). Speca offers a run-pass blend, while Saxton is more of a pocket passer, similar to Brumbaugh. Saxton received limited action last season in mop-up duty; Speca started four games at corner and filled in at wide receiver.

Rossi is not asking either to duplicate Brumbaugh’s brilliance — “We don’t talk about that with them,” he said — but to comprehend Rossi’s timing-oriented offense. Rossi likes to flood the field with four and five receivers at a time, and it is imperative that his quarterbacks make the proper reads. He said both are capable passers, which means the final choice could come down to the quarterback with the best decision-making skills.

Advertise with us

“They don't have to go out and win games for us,” said Rossi, whose team averaged 44 points last season. “They just have to be able to go through their progressions, find the open man. Brett got to the point where he could win games for us. With these guys, it’s about not making mistakes and distributing the ball to the right people.”

Despite being a sophomore, Saxton believes he has a great understanding of Rossi’s system after leading the junior varsity to an undefeated season in 2014. He was required to learn the varsity playbook and received play calls from the sideline, while running the no-huddle offense. A quarterback since the age of 8, Saxton has been a starter at every level of youth football.

Asked if he can lead South Fayette to another championship, the youngster exuded confidence.

“Yes, I believe that I can,” he said. “It’s going to be hard, but knowing that we have weapons on the outside, a great running back and a great line, I believe that it’s doable.”

As for Speca, he, too, is a lifelong quarterback. He has been a starter at every youth level since second grade and also led the junior varsity to an undefeated record as a freshman. He and Saxton often competed against each other on opposing teams before high school. Speca was summoned to play corner and wideout last season to utilize his athleticism.

Advertise with us

He was asked if he could lead a three-peat.

“I feel like I can, and I feel like I bring a different aspect to the position,” said Speca, who has been timed at 4.5 seconds in the 40-yard dash. “I can run and I can throw it and I think that adds even more to our offense.”

In the past two offseasons, Rossi visited Boston College and Northwestern to learn some adaptations to his spread offense, including using the read-option. In it, the quarterback is required to quickly decide whether to run, hand off or throw downfield. Speca said it suits his style.

“I’m ready to run it, if coach picks me,” he said.

Despite losing Pennsylvania’s all-time leading passer, Rossi is confident his offense will continue to flourish. Why? For one, his system has stood the test of time — and he’s not afraid to tweak it. Also, all five offensive linemen return. Ditto for star running back Hunter Hayes, the No. 2 rusher in the WPIAL with 2,103 yards (7.6 per carry). He ran for 263 yards in the state semifinal and 264 in the final. Rossi also believes his receiving corps can be among the best in the WPIAL.

Advertise with us

Nick Ponikvar is back after hauling in 53 passes for 1,055 yards (19.9 per catch). There is also Dan Timber (six touchdown receptions in the final six games), Camron Garland, Rhyan Culberson, Noah Plack and Hayes coming out of the backfield. Rossi described the wideouts as “lanky, basketball-player types with the ability to make big plays.”

“With everybody back on the offensive line, our quarterback won’t be running for his life — all he has to do is make the right reads,” Rossi said. “Brett had all day to throw the football, so it was about making the right decisions. We have the weapons for our quarterback to throw to. He just has to get it to them.”