South Fayette was in real trouble early in the second quarter of its PIAA AA semifinal against Hickory.

Not only were the defending state champion Lions trailing, 7-0, but Hornets running back Charles Carr had found gaping holes off the left side and had them ready to score again inside the South Fayette 2.

That was when the tide turned and South Fayette secured a return trip to Hersheypark Stadium and a date with Dunmore for the PIAA title.

Senior linebacker Matt O’Rourke shot through the gap and came up with a huge fumble recovery. The Lions then went 97 yards in five plays, capped by Brett Brumbaugh’s state-record-setting 54-yard touchdown pass to Dan Trimbur to propel South Fayette (15-0) to a 44-14 victory against Hickory at Slippery Rock University’s Mihalik-Thompson Stadium.

Advertise with us

“Our defensive line just took out their line and I was just able to hop over their quarterback,” O’Rourke said. “I don’t know if the quarterback fumbled the snap or what, but for our offense to turn around and go [97] yards, we just got our momentum and we just built everything off that.”

On the touchdown pass, Brumbaugh broke the state record of 10,948 career passing yards set by Port Allegany’s Matt Bodamer. Brumbaugh, a senior, finished 6 of 16 for 140 yards and a touchdown and has 10,984 yards in his career.

“It’s a great feeling and it’s very humbling, but I owe all of my success to my coaches and my teammates,” Brumbaugh said. “But getting the win is so much sweeter.”

Though Brumbaugh had a somewhat pedestrian outing by his lofty standards, Hunter Hayes and the ground game more than picked up the offensive slack. The senior running back bulled his way through the Hickory defense, finishing with 33 carries for 261 yards and two touchdowns.

“I did not expect 33 [carries], but I’ll just take the ball as much as they give it to me,” Hayes said. “I’m thankful that I got that many carries, but however much they need me, that’s what I’ll do.”

Advertise with us

But in the early going it wasn’t Hayes that took over the running game; it was Carr. The sophomore gashed the South Fayette defense for a 72-yard gain on his second carry and his 1-yard plunge gave Hickory a 7-0 lead with 7:02 remaining in the first quarter.

Carr finished with 35 carries for 176 yards and one touchdown, but it was the play near the goal line with 9:08 left in the half that proved to be the turning point.

Leading, 7-0, with a third-and-goal from inside the South Fayette 2, Carr and quarterback Luke Brennan missed the exchange on the handoff and the ball ended up on the turf.

O’Rourke ducked around Brennan and dived on the loose football to stave off what could have been a crushing score.

“I think not being able to stop the run and not picking up the blitz [was the turning point], but that [fumble] did hurt,” Hickory coach Bill Brest said. “Did we recover from it? I don’t think so.”

Advertise with us

Instead of trailing by 14, South Fayette scored on its next two possessions to take a 14-7 lead into the intermission. In all, the Lions reeled off 28 consecutive points and took a commanding 21-point lead, which took Hickory completely out of its run-first offense and put the onus on Brennan.

Under that kind of pressure, Brennan, a freshman, finished 2 of 9 for 84 yards, one touchdown and four interceptions — two of which were returned for touchdowns — in the second half.

“They were playing two safeties and we knew we could establish a run game, but the key was the goal-line stand and for us to get that stop,” South Fayette coach Joe Rossi said. “That was a game-changer. Then to go 97, those guys understand how to win and those are the kinds of plays you need right there.”