History says this is an unusual year for WPIAL football championships. The "Haven't We Met Before?" theme has never been so prevalent.
All four championship games will be played today at Heinz Field and two of the four games are rematches of title games a year ago -- South Fayette vs. Aliquippa in Class AA and West Allegheny vs. Central Valley in Class AAA.
The WPIAL staged its first championship game 99 years ago. In 1937, the WPIAL started having championship games in at least two classifications. Since then, there has never been a year when two of the title games were championship rematches. Also, the Central Catholic vs. Pine-Richland Class AAAA final is a rematch of a game played earlier this season.
On top of that, history also says the South Fayette vs. Aliquippa game is a rematch for the ages. Of the 11 previous championship rematches, only once have the two teams taken perfect records (undefeated and untied) into the title game two years in a row. It was in 1967 and '68 when Burrell and Freeport played. Coincidentally, Burrell won both years by identical 6-0 scores.
"That's some pretty good research," South Fayette coach Joe Rossi said of the rematch factoids. "We tell our guys never to take anything for granted. To get there again takes luck, being healthy and just proper play. We've been fortunate to get there back to back. ... It is unusual for the chips to fall in line for the same two teams."
Aliquippa coach Mike Zmijanac said: "I'm actually a little surprised there haven't been more [championship] rematches, just because there are some really good teams out there and some really good programs. But things happen, like injuries and graduation of players."
Read More
What also is unusual is that Aliquippa has been to the title game seven consecutive years, a feat unmatched by any other team in WPIAL history. And get this: Aliquippa is playing in a WPIAL title game for the 20th time in 35 seasons.
"I can't even imagine getting there seven years in a row," Rossi said.
Aliquippa has been involved in a championship rematch once before -- in 1983 and '84 against Mount Pleasant. Mount Pleasant won in 1983, 16-14. But Aliquippa came back a year later and defeated Mount Pleasant, 20-15, when Rapheal "Pudgy" Abercrombie rushed for 238 yards on 39 carries.
Aliquippa had lost in the Class AAA final three times in the previous four seasons. Zmijanac was a defensive coordinator then under coach Don Yannessa.
"I told Don in 1984 that if we lose this one, I'm quitting," Zmijanac said with a laugh. "Emotionally, I couldn't deal with it."
One of the most anticipated championship rematches in WPIAL history was North Hills and Gateway in 1986. A year before, the two teams tied, 0-0, in the Class AAAA title game. A year later, their rematch was considered one of the greatest championship games in WPIAL lore.
North Hills had just moved up from No. 2 to USA Today's No. 1-ranked team in the country, after Emmitt Smith's Escambia High (Fla.) team lost. North Hills and Gateway brought perfect 12-0 records into the title game and North Hills had a chance to win the "mythical" national championship.
A crowd estimated at 20,000 poured into Three Rivers Stadium to watch Gateway knock off North Hills, 7-6.
Last year's South Fayette-Aliquippa game is considered one of the best WPIAL finals in the past few decades. Snow fell during much of the game, won by South Fayette, 34-28. Quarterback Brett Brumbaugh led the Lions on a winning drive in the fourth quarter.
Even after last year's game, everyone from fans to coaches thought these two teams might meet again in the final.
"Yeah, we looked at it," Rossi said. "Everyone thought Seton-LaSalle would have a chance because they brought a ton of kids back. You knew Aliquippa would have players. For us, we thought maybe if we get a little lucky, we could be there again."
With championship rematches, a natural question is whether one team has an edge? Does the loser one year have an edge with payback on its mind? The team that lost the first championship game is 3-6-1 in the rematch. Butler lost to Penn Hills in 1976 and tied in 1977.
Gateway and North Hills tied the first year they met in 1985.
"I don't think either team has an advantage," Zmijanac said. "There is a turnover in personnel. ... The biggest pressure is getting there. You know, someone said to me just recently, 'Don't you take some satisfaction even if you lose in the final?' I said, 'You see the Kansas City Royals after they lost in the World Series this year?' They weren't just happy to get there."
*****
Two of the WPIAL championships this year are rematches from last season -- South Fayette vs. Aliquippa (Class AA) and West Allegheny vs. Central Valley (AAA). The WPIAL had its first championship game 99 years ago. Since then, there have only been 11 championship rematches and this is the first year there are two. Here are the results of previous championship rematches.
1985 North Hills 0, Gateway 0
1986 Gateway 7, North Hills 6
1944 Donora 13, Ellwood City 0
1945 Donora 38, Ellwood City 0
1976 Penn Hills 23, Butler 14
1977 Butler 7, Penn Hills 7
1983 Mt. Pleasant 16, Aliquippa 14
1984 Aliquippa 20, Mt. Pleasant 15
1993 Blackhawk 28, McGuffey 12
1994 McGuffey 12, Blackhawk 6
1967 Burrell 6, Freeport 0
1968 Burrell 6, Freeport 0
1958 Braddock 21, Waynesburg 0
1959 Braddock 25, Waynesburg 7
2011 Clairton 42, Sto-Rox 6
2012 Clairton 58, Sto-Rox 21
2009 Clairton 14, Rochester 13
2010 Clairton 12, Rochester 0
1978 Quigley 14, Western Beaver 8
1979 Quigley 26, Western Beaver 6
1971 Char.-Houston 15, Midland 6
1972 Char.-Houston 10, Midland 6






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.