With the exception of a chosen few, dry spells are to be expected for most any high school football program.
Whether it's from the graduation of a successful class, a transition from one coach to another or something else entirely, almost no team can stay on top forever. Or at least they typically don't.
Unsuccessful runs are virtually inevitable, but the key variable is how long they last. For some, it's only a few games, like an adjustment period to get things figured out before moving forward.
For a school such as Shaler Area, though, it's something else entirely.
A 29-point defeat to Seneca Valley last week marked not only the end of an 0-9 season for the Titans, but also their 31st consecutive loss. It's a streak that dates back to Oct. 8, 2011 -- when current seniors were just freshmen -- and has grown into the longest winless drought in WPIAL football.
The most recent season offered little hope that a win would be coming soon.
In its nine games, Shaler lost by an average of 38.6 points. It scored only 60 points the entire season -- averaging 6.7 per game, third worst in the 124-team WPIAL -- and never scored more than 14 points in a game this season.
Their points-per-game average was nearly half what it was last season, when the Titans scored 13.2 points per game. At 45.3 points allowed per game, their defense improved slightly, if only because of the low bar that was set last season.
For quite some time, it didn't appear things would ever get to this difficult point.
Though the Titans have never made it to the WPIAL championship game -- old Shaler Township High did get to the Class A (now AA) title game in 1947, long before the merger with Etna and Millvale when the school became Shaler Area -- they were a competitive program that didn't view the playoffs as an unattainable, far-off destination.
In fact, their last victory gave them a 5-1 record in a 2011 season that ultimately ended in the first round of the WPIAL playoffs. Even with the struggles, there are explanations for those shortcomings and reasons for why they could end in the near future.
Of the 69 players on the Shaler roster this season, 35 were either freshmen or sophomores, and starting quarterback Nick Fugh was a junior. That's an exceptionally young team at most any level, particularly in the challenging Class AAAA Northern Eight Conference, which features the likes of Central Catholic, Pine-Richland, North Allegheny and North Hills.
Additionally, coach Jon LeDonne, who was unavailable for comment, was in his first season. Another year of growth and experience from coaches and players alike certainly won't make a winless team world-beaters, but it could make it more competitive.
And for where the Titans are right now, that wouldn't be a bad place to be.
Three stars
T.J. Holl: It was a nightmare 2014 season for Seneca Valley -- which went 2-7 after being ranked as a preseason top five team in Class AAAA -- but the Raiders' senior quarterback finished things off in style, throwing for 303 yards and three touchdowns (along with running for another score) in a 41-12 victory against Shaler.
Adam Sharlow: The Cardinal Wuerl North Catholic quarterback only threw 10 passes in a 49-16 drubbing of Shenango, but he was efficient with those attempts, completing nine of them for 170 yards and two touchdowns.
North Allegheny: After a brutal four-game stretch to open 2014, the Tigers finished the regular season with six consecutive victories to lock up third place in the Northern Eight Conference. It's hard to think of such a decorated program as a WPIAL championship sleeper, but it just may be the closest thing to it in Class AAAA.
Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.