Every high school football player who goes through the Division I recruiting experience can come away with a different story.

Some embrace and enjoy the process; others loathe it and can't wait to get it over with.

For reasons completely out of his control, Shaler Area's J.P. Holtz has had one of the more unpredictable and tumultuous recruiting sagas. After all, it's not every day a student-athlete watches the school to which he made a verbal commitment end up embroiled in a child sex abuse scandal and then has its legendary NCAA all-time winningest coach die from complications of lung cancer in a matter of a couple months.

Making Holtz's situation potentially more combustible, the school he switched his commitment to fancies itself a bitter rival of the one he switched from.

Advertise with us

Still, through it all, Holtz embraced the process.

"I enjoyed it while it lasted," said Holtz, a 6-foot-4, 240-pound tight end rated a three or four-star prospect, depending upon the recruiting service one might consult.

"Of course, I'm excited to get it over with just so I can move on to the next chapter of my life, go to get my education and play some football. But you have to enjoy it."

Holtz made his commitment to Pitt official Wednesday morning on national signing day.

Holtz originally had committed to Penn State. But he changed his mind and opened up his recruiting -- not coincidentally, after the university and football program became embroiled in the highly publicized Jerry Sandusky scandal in November.

Advertise with us

Less than three months after being fired in the fallout, coach Joe Paterno died Jan. 22 at 85.

Three days later, Holtz made his verbal commitment to Pitt public on KDKA-TV. While the timing so soon after Paterno's death was unintentional and unfortunate, Holtz had gone on record in the summer talking about his admiration and respect for Paterno.

Holtz gave other reasons for choosing the Panthers, too.

"I loved the new coaches, and I just love Pitt," Holtz said. "It just feels like a big family. And with all the other recruits, it definitely is a really good recruiting class. I get along with the team. It just feels right. I fit in well there.

"I met with [new coach Paul Chryst and his staff] a lot and built good relationships with them ... [Plus] my family can watch me ... at every single home game, and if I want to go home on a weekend and spend time with the family, I can because it's only 10 or 15 minutes away."

Advertise with us

In this age of message boards and social networking, some higher-profile football recruits begin to feel pressure and can get stung by criticism that can come -- particularly from fans of a school to which a player might back out of a commitment.

Holtz has an easygoing nature, though, that allows him to take a different perspective on that.

"I just really laugh," he said. "It's funny that a bunch of people who really don't know what they're talking about would say something about it. I just laugh; I just enjoy it because I think it's funny."

At least one of Holtz's future Pitt teammates must have heard some criticism of Holtz, judging by the way he came to his defense on Twitter last week. For his part, Holtz said he really hasn't had anyone say anything negative to him.

"Most people just have had good stuff to say," he said. "Not really anything that bad."

Advertise with us

Holtz is friends with Fox Chapel lineman Adam Bisnowaty, who has been committed to Pitt since early autumn. Holtz said he talked about the recruiting process with Bisnowaty frequently. But although Bisnowaty and many of the Pitt recruits who are friends with Holtz have subtly "sold" the school to him, any discussions they had were more supportive and none applied pressure.

"I just knew Pitt was the place I wanted to go to for a while," Holtz said.

Other athletes from the North Xtra area who signed with Division I football programs Wednesday included Shady Side Academy's Reggie Mitchell and Highlands' Jake Witucki. Mitchell, a 5-9, 155-pound defensive back, committed to Wisconsin. Witucki, a 6-5, 280-pound offensive lineman, was to sign with Kent State.