He might not admit it -- not even to himself.
But somewhere deep in his heart, Jim Render knows he did everything to the best of his ability to have the Upper St. Clair football team he coaches prepared and motivated to win the WPIAL Class AAAA championship game this past Saturday at Heinz Field.
Render is the WPIAL's all-time winningest coach, and he has a pair of perfect seasons that ended with WPIAL and PIAA championships. A person doesn't achieve that kind of success without a little perfectionist in him, and the old-school Render dwells on the negatives of an overtime loss to North Allegheny much moreso than he does the positives of a WPIAL finalist season that might be among one of his best coaching jobs.
"I always blame myself first," Render mused Monday, some 48 hours after his injury-depleted team that was besieged by a handful of questionable officiating calls was ousted by No. 1 seed North Allegheny.
"There always must have been something else I could have done to help us. That's what I've been thinking about in my own private moments over the weekend -- what could I have done more?"
In the end, the Panthers (11-2) had too much to overcome. Among the serious injuries to key players this season, Upper St. Clair lost starting left tackle Andrew Poluzejko (knee), running back/defensive back Matt Paxton (hand) and quarterback/linebacker Dakota Conwell (ankle). Also, lineman Alex Park (back), a Northwestern recruit, was at less than 100 percent heading into the WPIAL title game.
Render also took note of more than a handful of officiating calls he did not agree with. Most notable among them was the call of a touchdown reception by North Allegheny's Brendan Coniker with 27 seconds remaining in the first half. Photos attest that Coniker did not get a foot in bounds.
"We just couldn't overcome all the things that happened," Render said. "It just hurts, it really hurts, the way the whole evening went down. They're a really good team, North Allegheny, but they don't need gifts."
The Panthers' only two losses this season were to the Tigers, who entered the season as the defending WPIAL and PIAA champion.
Upper St. Clair lost a pair of close games to NA (the regular-season defeat Sept. 16 at North Allegheny also, coincidentally, was by a 28-21 score), but the Panthers can boast several impressive wins.
Upper St. Clair beat the three playoff-bound opponents it played during the regular season by a combined score of 139-20 -- including a 42-6 victory against arch-rival Mt. Lebanon in the regular-season finale that gave the Panthers their first Great Southern Conference championship since their 2006 PIAA title season.
Upper St. Clair's most impressive win was a 28-14 beating of Central Catholic in the WPIAL semifinals. The Vikings were undefeated and had carried a national ranking -- and the Panthers were without Conwell for the first time. Conwell, a Pitt recruit, is the Panthers Mr. Everything, their leading passer, rusher and tackler.
Although Conwell returned for the WPIAL title game, he was limited to only a fraction of the number of plays he usually is in for, and it was obvious he was at less than 100 percent.
"In all fairness, everybody has injuries and loses players at times," Render said. "I'm just saying it's tough when your depth chart is not that deep to begin with.
"When you factor in all these things with the injuries and the calls, we just didn't have enough to finish the game.
"There's just a point where it becomes too much to overcome. But all that said, I'm extremely proud of our kids. [The title game loss] doesn't change how I feel about our players. They were battlers, and they did a great, great job. They did everything we asked them to do and more."
In acting as a spokesman for the Panthers' players, senior tight end Jack Schwaba, another Northwestern recruit, was like Render in that he wanted to search for what else he and his teammates could have done differently to change the title game result.
"People on the outside can think of [the season] ... that we had too much to overcome, and to an extent, OK," Schwaba said. "But I don't think of it, personally, that way.
"Our backups and second stringers stepped up for guys who [were injured] and played outstanding ... We have great depth at all our positions, that's what you have when you are a great football team, so we still could have won."
Schwaba is one of 28 seniors who have played their final game for Upper St. Clair. It was one of the Panthers' deepest and most talented classes under Render, who completed his 33rd season at the school and 43rd overall as a head coach.
"We had a great season, one Upper St. Clair hasn't seen in a while," Schwaba said. "That right there in itself is a great accomplishment.
"Winning the conference [title] was big. But the ultimate goal for this season was the state championship, and it hurts we didn't get there. But that's not going to take away what we did do this season."





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.