Take a look at the field of WPIAL football semifinalists, and the picture has never looked so perfect.
Eleven teams will take 11-0 records into tonight's semifinals in four classifications. Never before have the semifinals included so many undefeated teams.
In fact, no semifinal field has come close to matching this year's number of undefeated teams (69 percent of the teams are perfect). Although the WPIAL started playoff games in 1971, the league didn't have semifinal games in three classifications until 1977. Since 1980, there have been playoffs in four classifications.
In 31 seasons with four classifications, there has never been more than seven undefeated teams in the semifinals. That happened only three times (2010, '08 and '04).
In order to understand how unusually perfect this semifinal field of 16 teams is, consider that since 1980, there have been 21 seasons with five or fewer undefeated teams in the semifinals. Six times, only two undefeated teams made it to the semifinals.
Also, there are only eight other teams in Pennsylvania outside the WPIAL that have undefeated records heading into this 12th week of the season.
So, is all this perfection just a coincidence?
"I don't know, that's hard to answer," said WPIAL executive director Tim O'Malley.
But the recent past indicates perfection is a growing trend in the WPIAL. In six of the past seven seasons, there have been at least six undefeated teams in the semifinals.
What could be a major factor in the increase of undefeated teams is a perceived widening of the gap between good teams and not-so-good teams. In the past few seasons, a number of coaches have remarked that the separation has grown between "haves" and "have nots" in high school football. It might not be so much that teams keep getting better. It might be the fact that there are more bad teams in recent years, which leads to easier games for the good teams.
"I think you hit the nail on the head there," said Central Catholic coach Terry Totten. "You never saw these blowout games like you see these days -- 85-0 and 76-0. I would say the competitive balance aspect in the WPIAL needs to be addressed. I don't know what the answer is, but I've heard of a lot more places where it's tough getting many kids out for football."
O'Malley believes there could be credence to the "haves" and "have nots" theory.
"I would venture to guess that this year is somewhat of a coincidence with all the undefeated teams," O'Malley said. "There have always been 'haves' and 'have nots,' but the fact that we have as many undefeated teams as we do is something to look at the next couple of years to see if there is a widening of the gap with teams."
There are three undefeated teams each left in the Class A, AA and AAA semifinals. Class AAAA has two:
NORTH ALLEGHENY (CLASS AAAA)
The defending WPIAL and PIAA champions have won 18 in a row. The Tigers are strong on the lines and have one of the best junior linemen in the state in Patrick Kugler. The addition of quarterback Mack Leftwich, a transfer from Oklahoma, has been a big key to the season.
CENTRAL CATHOLIC (AAAA)
The Vikings are in the top 25 in some national rankings and have five seniors who have committed to Division I-A colleges. Receiver-defensive back Anthony Nixon is one of the best two-way players in the state. The team's only loss the past two seasons was to North Allegheny in last year's WPIAL semifinals.
CENTRAL VALLEY (AAA)
This is only the second year of the school (merger of Center and Monaca) and the Warriors are the defending WPIAL champions. Their defense has been strong and they have a handful of offensive players capable of big plays such as wide receiver Robert Foster.
KNOCH (AAA)
The Knights finished the regular season undefeated for the first time in school history. Running back Andrew Rumburg-Goodlin and quarterback Ky Kenyon have helped make for a potent offense.
FRANKLIN REGIONAL (AAA)
The Panthers had never won their first 11 games of the season before this year. Dane Brown was the second-leading rusher in the WPIAL in the regular season, and the Panthers have allowed only 81 points.
ALIQUIPPA (AA)
Although the Quips have a strong running game, quarterback Mikal Hall is in his third season as a starter and he often finds receiver Kaylan Kenney. The Quips are trying to make the Class AA title game for the fourth year in a row and their 13 WPIAL championships are the most of any school.
JEANNETTE (AA)
The Jayhawks finished the regular season undefeated for the 16th time, the most in WPIAL history. This year's team features standout quarterback-defensive back Demetrious Cox, who is one of the most heavily recruited players in the WPIAL, and running back Shavonta Craft.
SETON-LaSALLE (AA)
Running back Kevin Hart has rushed for 1,723 yards, quarterback Luke Brumbaugh is a capable passer, and junior tight end Scott Orndoff already has made a verbal commitment to the University of Wisconsin. The Rebels allow only seven points a game on defense.
CLAIRTON (A)
The Bears don't appear to have a weakness and their winning streak is now at 42 games, second longest in WPIAL history. Junior running back-defensive back Tyler Boyd already has Division I scholarship offers; senior receiver-linebacker Trenton Coles is a Pitt recruit.
BISHOP CANEVIN (A)
Venerable coach Bob Jacoby has one of his best teams in 38 years at the helm. Speedy receiver-defensive back Bobby Gustine is a big-play specialist, and junior linebacker Mike Dunn is the team's top tackler for the second year in a row.
STO-ROX (A)
The Vikings finished the regular season undefeated and untied for the first time in school history. The offense is loaded with playmakers and the Vikings average 45.4 points per game. Receiver-linebacker Deaysean Rippy has a number of Division I scholarship offers.
UNBLEMISHED
Undefeated teams in the semifinals every year since 1980, when the WPIAL went to four classifications:
2010: 7
2009: 4
2008: 7
2007: 6
2006: 6
2005: 6
2004: 7
2003: 4
2002: 5
2001: 2
2000: 4
1999: 6
1998: 4
1997: 2
1996: 2
1995: 4
1994: 6
1993: 4
1992: 5
1991: 2
1990: 4
1989: 5
1988: 4
1987: 2
1986: 4
1985: 2
1984: 3
1982: 6
1981: 3
1980: 0




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.