The quarterback shootout between the Brumbaugh brothers that some expected Friday night in the WPIAL Class AA quarterfinals never materialized because Seton-LaSalle running back Kevin Hart had other plans.
Seton-LaSalle junior quarterback Luke Brumbaugh handed the ball off to Hart 41 times and the bruising running back did his job, keeping South Fayette freshman quarterback Brett Brumbaugh and the rest of the Lions offense off the field.
Behind 269 yards from Hart, No. 3 seeded Seton-LaSalle (11-0) held off No. 11 seeded South Fayette (7-4), 21-13, in the game at Peters Township.
Luke Brumbaugh made throws when he had to and his younger brother, Brett, showed poise in rallying his team from a 21-7 deficit in the fourth quarter.
"He is a great quarterback and he was very impressive, but it was weird playing against him," Luke Brumbaugh said.
Luke Brumbaugh finished 7-of-15 passing for 54 yards while Brett was 18 of 34 for 150 yards and two scores. After throwing three early interceptions, Brett led his team down the field on a 68-yard scoring drive that featured a fourth-down conversion and a 7-yard touchdown pass to Nathan Smith on third-and-goal from the 7 to pull the Lions within 21-13 with 2:22 remaining.
South Fayette recovered the ensuing onside kick but the Seton-LaSalle defense came up with a fourth interception, effectively ending the game and dethroning the reigning WPIAL Class AA champions.
Seton-LaSalle is in the WPIAL semifinals for the first time since 2005 and the Rebels can thank one scoring drive in particular for that.
Holding onto a 13-7 lead in the third quarter, Seton-LaSalle was pinned back on its 1-yard line. Seton-LaSalle coach Greg Perry called Hart's number seven times on the eight-play drive and Hart gashed the South Fayette defense, leading the Rebels on a 99-yard scoring drive.
"We can't allow them to go 99 yards on us," South Fayette coach Joe Rossi said. "They just ran the ball; they're big and senior-oriented. We knew Hart was going to get the ball and he got it done."
Because of a 15-yard personal foul penalty against his team, Hart actually gained 110 yards on the drive, including a back-breaking 26-yard rush on second and 20 and a 45-yard touchdown rush on the next play.
"We wanted to set the tempo whether it was running or passing," Hart said after the game. "I love carrying the ball but I was definitely getting tired."
The Rebels were able to hold the ball for 17 of 24 minutes in the first half.
"It was hard because we couldn't get into a rhythm," Brett Brumbaugh said, after starting his third consecutive game since taking over in Week 9.
"I made some mistakes but we fought hard."
South Fayette got a big game from Zach Challingsworth in a losing effort. Challingsworth caught seven passes for 46 yards. On the first South Fayette scoring drive, he raced for 40 yards on a sweep and later caught a 12-yard touchdown pass. Challingsworth also averaged 44 yards on four punts.
Seton-LaSalle won the regular season meeting between the Century Conference rivals, 33-10, but before that five of the last six meetings were decided by one score, and Friday night was no different.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.