Maybe it's not a full-blown quarterback controversy, but South Fayette coach Joe Rossi might have a quarterback quandary on his hands this week.

John Lerda started the first eight games this season for South Fayette and did well, throwing for 1,003 yards. But an injury in the eighth game kept Lerda from playing the past two weeks.

Brett Brumbaugh, a freshman, started in place of Lerda and was impressive, completing 30 of 42 passes for 456 yards and five touchdowns. He helped South Fayette beat Beaver Falls in the first round of the WPIAL Class AA playoffs.

South Fayette isn't revealing Lerda's injury, but Rossi acknowledges Lerda might be ready to play Friday night in a quarterfinal game against Seton-LaSalle at Peters Township. But even if Lerda is ready to go, the Lions still might start Brumbaugh.

Advertise with us

"John is still getting evaluated by doctors and he did a great job when he was in there. But the young kid has done a great job," Rossi said. "Both of the kids are so different in styles. John uses his legs a little bit more, but Brumbaugh throws the ball extremely well. As a coaching staff, we'll have to sit down and discuss who gives us the best opportunity to win Friday night."

If Brumbaugh gets the start, it will mean a Brumbaugh vs. Brumbaugh duel. Seton-LaSalle's starting quarterback is Luke Brumbaugh, a junior and the older brother of Brett. Luke left South Fayette and transferred to Seton-LaSalle after his freshman year.

You have to wonder what it is like in the Brumbaugh house this week.

"I would assume it's pretty hard for the family," Rossi said. "I know for us, you try to ponder why Luke left. But there are different reasons for different kids leaving."

The Brumbaugh's older brother, Christian, led South Fayette to the WPIAL Class AA title last season. He is a freshman at William & Mary.

Advertise with us

"All three of them just have that quarterback nature to them," Rossi said.

This is the second meeting this season between South Fayette (7-3) and Seton-LaSalle (10-0). Seton-LaSalle won the first, 33-10, although South Fayette led at halftime, 7-6.

Seton-LaSalle running back Kevin Hart rushed for 205 yards in the win and has more than 1,450 yards for the season.

"We over-pursued him the last time," Rossi said. "He's the most patient running back I have ever seen. He uses cutback lanes as well as anyone I've ever seen."

Other Class AA quarterfinals

Advertise with us

• Washington (8-2) is undoubtedly an underdog against No. 1-ranked Aliquippa (10-0) Friday at Chartiers Valley. But Washington has an offense that has been impressive at times this season. Washington's Shai McKenzie has rushed for more than 1,000 yards.

• Sixteen teams that finished fourth in their conferences made the WPIAL playoffs. The only one to win was Ellwood City, which defeated Freeport in a first-round game. Now Ellwood City (7-3) takes on Greensburg Central Catholic (9-1) Friday at Valley.

Ellwood City is trying to make it to the semifinals for the first time since 1987.

• Jeannette (10-0) takes on Shady Side Academy (8-2) in the other quarterfinal Friday at Norwin. The game features two quarterbacks who don't throw much, but have torched defenses with their running ability. Jeannette's Demetrious Cox has rushed for 936 yards and Shady Side Academy's Reggie Mitchell, a Wisconsin recruit, has 1,240.