In his first playoff game, South Fayette freshman quarterback Brett Brumbaugh wasn't perfect. Fortunately, his teammates made sure he didn't have to be.
Brumbaugh completed 12 of 23 passes for two touchdowns with four interceptions as the defending champion Lions took down Beaver Falls, 24-14, Friday a first-round game in the WPIAL Class AA playoffs at Geneva College's Reeves Field.
"A freshman quarterback, he's going to make mistakes," South Fayette coach Joe Rossi said. "But he did a nice job, made some throws that were tremendous."
Brumbaugh made his first start last week when South Fayette's regular quarterback, senior John Lerda, was injured. Brumbaugh's older brother, Christian, graduated from South Fayette last year as the WPIAL's all-time leading passer.
Brumbaugh looked shaky early in the game, completing just one of his first five passes and overthrowing open receivers. He bounced back to complete his next five in a row on two consecutive touchdown drives. Brumbaugh capped the streak with an 8-yard touchdown pass to Zach Challingsworth that put the Lions up 17-6 with 1:03 left in the first quarter.
PG VIDEO
Brumbaugh couldn't maintain the momentum in the second quarter. The Lions had a chance to put the game out of reach in the first half, but Brumbaugh threw two interceptions that brought potential scoring drives to a halt.
At the end of the half, Beaver Falls drove the ball 74 yards, relying on a steady dose of runs from Damian Rawl and Trey Hall. The Tigers came up empty, though, as the Lions defense stuffed Rawl for no gain on 4th-and-2 from the South Fayette 10.
"We had the momentum and just figured we wanted to punch it in," Beaver Falls coach Ryan Matsook said.
A 70-yard touchdown on a kickoff return by Rawl was Beaver Falls' only scoring of the first half. The Tigers earned just four first downs in the opening 24 minutes.
Things didn't get much better for Beaver Falls after the break, as the Tigers fumbled the opening kickoff on their own 22. Six plays later, Brumbaugh connected with Mike Fetchet on a touchdown pass to put the Lions up, 24-6. The Lions' win sets up a second-round rematch with Century Conference rival Seton-LaSalle. The Rebels beat South Fayette, 33-10, Oct. 21.
The pairing could lead to an interesting week at the Brumbaugh dinner table.
Brett's other older brother, Luke, is undefeated as Seton-LaSalle's starting quarterback. Rossi said he and his staff would consult with doctors and evaluate Brett Brumbaugh and Lerda during the week before deciding which one will start.
If Brumbaugh does get the nod to go against his brother, he said he'd be ready.
"It'll be awesome," he said.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.