The guys who work the scoreboards at high school football games might be in line for a raise. Heck, they are busier than ever.
Scoring is on the rise. That short statement has been uttered countless times in recent years, even without facts to back up the claim. But an examination of scoring archives in the WPIAL and City League all the way back to the 1950s reveals some staggering scoring statistics.
Consider:
• From the 1950s through the 1980s, it was rare for more than five teams in the entire WPIAL and City League to average more than 30 points a game for a season, including playoffs. In some seasons, including 1980 and 1985, not one team averaged 30 points a game.
• This year alone, 34 teams in the WPIAL are averaging more than 30 points a game heading into the start of the playoffs tonight. Last year, 27 teams averaged more than 30.
• Since 2003, at least 15 teams every year in the WPIAL and City League averaged more than 30 points a game.
• From 1955 through the 1990s, only five teams averaged better than 40 points a game for the entire season, including playoffs. Over the past five seasons, at least one WPIAL or City League team averaged better than 40 points a game. The 2007 Jeannette team that featured quarterback Terrelle Pryor set a state record for points in a season and averaged 53.6 points over 16 games.
• This season, 61 WPIAL teams and four City League teams have already scored 200 points. Go back 30 years ago and only 26 teams scored 200 points, including playoffs.
So when the WPIAL playoffs begin tonight with 32 games in four different classifications, don't be surprised if some games are filled with points-counterpoints.
"It used to be that almost all playoff games were, like, 14-7. They were all low-scoring games," said Upper St. Clair's Jim Render, the winningest coach in WPIAL history with 351 victories. "You don't see that as much any more."
The three highest scoring playoff games in WPIAL history have all been in the past seven years, topped by Jeannette's 70-48 victory against Aliquippa in 2007.
"I think it's just that creative offensive minds keep pressing the limit," said Gateway coach Terry Smith, whose team has averaged at least 30 points a game in six of the past eight seasons.
But what really is the reason for so much more offense in high school football? Some coaches believe it is simply a trickle-down effect from the NFL and colleges. Some believe more complicated offenses -- like the spread -- is the main reason for the increased scoring. Some believe faster and stronger players are the reason for more offense.
And a few coaches believe field surfaces actually have something to do with high-octane offenses. About half of the teams in the WPIAL have a synthetic turf surface at their stadium.
"There are not nearly as many mud games as there were years ago," said Render, whose team plays and practices on a synthetic turf surface. "So, teams are able to practice faster and play faster. I remember going way back, we used to have to search for a small spot of decent grass to practice on in the outfield of a baseball field at Boyce Middle School."
Springdale's Chuck Wagner is in his 47th season as a high school head coach and he believes a lack of competition has something to do with the high scoring over the past few decades.
"I think there are a lot of mismatches now in all the classifications," said Wagner.
In other words, the gap between the "haves" and "have nots" keeps getting bigger.
"It's not like there is bad coaching," Wagner said. "It's just that teams don't have the material. I'm not saying anyone is trying to run up the score on teams, but sometimes it's just impossible to keep the score down. There just isn't the competition that there used to be years ago."
Coaches will tell you high school offensive players are unquestionably bigger and faster than they were 30 years ago or more. But that leads to the question: Aren't the players on defense bigger and stronger, too?
"Yeah, but the best offenses can beat the best defenses," said Gateway's Smith. "It's been proven that a good skill player can score from anywhere on the field. With spread offenses these days, the opportunities are greater to score. In a confined offense like a pro style or winged-T, there aren't the same opportunities to score. Those offenses were more built for nickel and dime."
Smith was a quarterback on Gateway's 1986 WPIAL championship team. He said the team, coached by legendary Pete Antimarino, had only three offensive formations. Smith said this year's Gateway team has about 30 offensive formations.
"We don't use all of those formations every week," Smith said. "Nowadays, it's not how many plays you have, but you run them out of a lot of formations that make a defense think about what you're doing."
Even the veteran coaches such as Render and Wagner are using versions of new-fangled offenses.
"We used to run the winged-T and in 2003 we changed," Wagner said. "Now we run this shotgun zone fly. Even though we still don't pass a lot, we play much more wide open."
Dave Havern is a former quarterback at Montour and Pitt who is now the head coach at Shady Side Academy.
"I think people are just throwing the ball more, spreading people out in space more and that gives you an opportunity to put more points on the board," said Havern, who also believes artificial turf has played a role in the increased scoring.
But a big question is whether all the passing and wide-open offenses are conducive to winning championships. Consider that over the past 27 seasons, including 2011, the leading passer in the WPIAL has missed the playoffs 15 times, and the leading passer has won only six playoff games in that time. Meanwhile, the leading rusher has been on a playoff team 21 of those 27 seasons and been to the championship game seven times.
"Everything always comes back around, and I think it's already starting to on the college level," Smith said. "Look at LSU and Alabama. They're two of the best teams out there and they play a pro style where they come at you and try to kick your teeth in."
Render uses spread offense tendencies, but it's more to create running lanes, especially for quarterback Dakota Conwell.
"Winning high school teams usually play great defense, have a great appreciation of the kicking game, and they run the ball," Render said. "I'm still a big proponent of the run. You can talk all you want about shootouts, wildcat formations and spread offenses. But to me, blocking and tackling are still the main ingredients of a good football team.
"I just like to win and it doesn't matter how you do it."
30 SOMETHING CROWD
Here are the number of teams in the WPIAL/City League that averaged more than 30 points a game the past 10 seasons, compared to other years going back to the 1950s:
Year/Teams
1955/2
1960/5
1965/5
1970/2
1975/3
1980/0
1985/0
1990/9
1995/5
2002/11
2003/19
2004/18
2005/17
2006/16
2007/15
2008/24
2009/17
2010/27
2011/34
SCORING LEADERS
Year School/PPG
1955 Clairton/30.7
1956 Ambridge/40.8
1957 Clairton/27.3
1966 Altoona/37.6
1967 New Castle/39.6
1971 Chartiers-Houston/44.7
1973 Springdale/28.7
1977 Duquesne/32.8
1979 Aliquippa/29.3
1980 German/28.0
1986 Perry/39.7
1987 North Hills/33.5
1990 Farrell/39.9
1991 Penn-Trafford/40.1
1992 Serra/38.4
1997 Perry/42.3
2000 Washington/46.1
2002 Perry/49.4
2005 McKeesport/39.1
2006 Yough/41.3
2007 Jeannette/53.8
2010 Clairton/46.6




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.