As a high school football head coach, Todd Fuller had turned around Cornell's program in only a few years and felt like he was on the verge of doing the same at Chartiers Valley.
He was young and spry, ready to win. Then, all of a sudden, he walked away from being a head coach. After two seasons at Cornell and two at Chartiers Valley, he had enough.
That was nearly 10 years ago. Although Fuller has been an assistant coach at two schools since then, coached his children in youth sports leagues and is now the freshman football coach at North Allegheny, he has not been a high school head coach since the 2000 season. And he likes it this way.
But Fuller's story is not unique. It is becoming more and more common in WPIAL football. For various reasons, coaches do not last as long as they did decades ago -- or at least not at the same school. Statistics prove it.
Of the 126 head coaches in WPIAL football, more than half (68) have been head coach at their school for five years or fewer. Seven years ago, that number was 57.
Coaches, athletic directors and WPIAL administrators all say you will not see many Joe Hamiltons (Blackhawk), Bob Jacobys (Bishop Canevin), Jim Renders (Upper St. Clair) or Jack McCurrys (North Hills) much any more. Those four have been head coaches at their schools for more than 30 years.
In the WPIAL this season, only seven coaches have been at their schools for 20 years or more. But 20 coaches are in their first year.
And the turnover of coaches in other sports seems to be even greater.
"I think there are an awful lot of good, young coaches around," said Hamilton, in his 35th year at Blackhawk. "But it's a tougher job than when I started."
Veteran coaches point to four factors that turn away coaches nowadays -- school boards that meddle too much, parental interference, time demands in the offseason and too much importance placed on winning.
The time issue is what drove away Fuller. He was 33 in 2001 when his wife was pregnant with the couple's first child.
"I knew I would still coach in some capacity someday," said Fuller, now the father of three. "But it was just one of those things that was right to do at the time. People don't understand about a head-coaching job. It consumes your life, if you're doing it the right way. Ask any coach, and they will tell you that.
"The time was the biggest thing for me, especially in the offseason."
Many coaches, young or experienced, say one of the most important things in coaching longevity is a supportive and understanding wife.
"The wife is a big ingredient," McCurry said. "She has to be willing to pick up the slack when you're not around much."
Nowadays, football teams lift weights year-round and have workouts starting in the spring. For example, Penn-Trafford, under first-year coach John Ruane, worked out four days a week in the summer, from 8-11:30 a.m. Such a summer schedule is common for high school football teams.
"I've talked with other people about this [coaching longevity]," said Ruane, 32. "I think one of the big things is that, years ago, just about every coach was a teacher, and he taught in the district he coached. That doesn't seem to be the case as much any more, and so it's not like someone is locked into one school district."
Ruane coaches at Penn-Trafford and teaches in the Gateway School District.
At age 25, first-year Ringgold coach Matt Humbert is a pup in this profession. Ringgold is a great example of the coaching turnover problem. Humbert is Ringgold's eighth coach since 1999. The others have left for various reasons.
Humbert, who has Ringgold off to a 3-0 start, said he would like to coach a long time, but also said, "I'm just trying to live in the moment right now. I can't predict what the future is going to bring. ... I think the biggest thing you need to bring coaching stability is support -- and from everybody. From the school board, to the administration, to the community."
But what happens to the support after a few losing seasons?
"In some places, you'll still have some coaches last a while, but the overriding factor in all of this is the ability to win and win on a consistent basis," McCurry said.
But even winners have problems. McCurry, Hamilton and Render all have won multiple WPIAL titles, but all three had to survive at least one attempt at firing them. In fact, McCurry was once fired for a few days by the North Hills school board before the board reconsidered and rehired him.
"If you're not in with the top [teams] just about every year, there are going to be things that occur outside your control, whether it be a school board, administration or in the community," McCurry said. "They'll try to oust you. ... It's just different nowadays.
"There is much more pressure from parents than ever before. Maybe not so much with a coach who has been there a long time, like me. But I'm kind of aloof anyway, and I do establish early on that playing time is not something we discuss.
"A lot of young coaches, though, try to please everyone and want to say and do all the right things."
Hamilton said he has endured more parental problems in the past two years than his other years combined.
"I think we've always had to deal with school boards, and we've always had to deal with parents, although parents are bolder than ever before," Hamilton said. "If you survive a long time as a coach now, you're fortunate. I consider myself fortunate."
Hamilton said he always has remembered what a coach told him in the 1960s.
"He said, 'Joe, no matter what you do, stay five years at a school and get out,'" Hamilton said. "He said, 'Because no matter what, your first year you're going to make some enemies. Then, those enemies have friends in the second, third and fourth years. So, by the fifth year, you have so many enemies it's time to move on.'
"So, if I use that philosophy, can you imagine how many enemies I have now?"





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.