South Fayette lost two fumbles, allowed 194 yards rushing and committed six penalties totaling 70 yards. But with a quarterback like Christian Brumbaugh, mistakes that might spell defeat for other high school teams are afterthoughts in double-digit wins.

Brumbaugh threw for 155 yards and three touchdowns to lift mistake-prone South Fayette to a 31-21 victory Friday night against Steel Valley at Campbell Field in the Class AA Century Conference opener for both teams.

"This was a good test of character for us," Brumbaugh said.

Brumbaugh, a senior who was fourth in passing yards in the WPIAL last season, completed 16 of 24 passes Friday, connecting with seven receivers.

Advertise with us

He did most of his damage on fourth down, where he completed three passes -- two for touchdowns and one to set up a field goal as time expired in the first half.

"I don't know what it is," Brumbaugh said of his fourth-down success. "We want to convert. We think we can. We have the concepts and the routes. We game-plan all week for those types of things."

But the errors nearly caught up to South Fayette (3-0, 1-0), the Post-Gazette's third-ranked WPIAL Class AA team.

With the Lions leading, 23-14, and time winding down in the third quarter, Steel Valley drove inside South Fayette's 5-yard line and was poised to cut the Lions' lead to three points or less.

But Ironmen quarterback Jared Juristy's pass on third-and-goal from the 4-yard line was intercepted by South Fayette linebacker Tanner Courtad, who ran 97 yards for a touchdown.

Advertise with us

"I don't know if the ball was behind him or not, but he made the play and we didn't," Steel Valley coach Rodney Steele said. "That's what it came down to -- they made a play down there and we didn't."

Courtad's score was a two-touchdown swing that sealed the game for the Lions.

"That was a game-changer there. They were going to cut it to three points, and he made a great play," South Fayette coach Joe Rossi said of Courtad.

But, Rossi cautioned his team, without Courtad's big play, the Lions might have been undone by fumbles and penalties.

"If we don't clean those up, we'll be sitting at home come playoff time," he said. "We're too good of a team and we prepare too much to have that happen to us."

Advertise with us

The Ironmen were sunk by their inability to pass the ball -- and their inability to stop Brumbaugh from passing on them. Steel Valley (2-1, 0-1) did not complete a pass in the second half after Juristy went 6 for 8 for 63 yards in the first half.

South Fayette never trailed in the game.

Lions wide receiver Zach Challingsworth got South Fayette on the scoreboard in the first quarter when he hauled in a 12-yard jump-ball pass on fourth-and-8.

Steel Valley responded on its next drive when Juristy connected with Gilbert Carswell for a 13-yard touchdown early in the second quarter.

Carswell caught four of Juristy's six passes.

Advertise with us

Brumbaugh completed his second touchdown pass of the game in the second quarter -- a 24-yard strike to tight end Eric Myers, also on fourth down.

The Ironmen tied the score later in the second when James Caldwell plowed into the end zone from the 1-yard line with less than one minute remaining in the half.

But Brumbaugh got his team into position to kick a field goal, and the Lions took a 17-14 halftime lead.

South Fayette separated itself in the third quarter, where Brumbaugh threw another touchdown and Courtad returned Juristy's interception for a score.

Steel Valley running back Delrece Williams, who rushed for 122 yards on 29 carries, added to Steel Valley's final score in the fourth quarter.