High school seniors ... past their prime?

Sounds laughable, but in the new world of college football recruiting, players who are seniors might as well be senior citizens in the eyes of college coaches and recruiting services.

National signing day for Division I football players is Wednesday, but you wouldn't know it for the lack of hoopla and suspense around the WPIAL. And one of the biggest reasons is that players are making verbal commitments to colleges earlier than they used to.

While in the past, the recruiting process might just be getting under way by the start of a top player's senior year, now it's becoming commonplace for players to make verbal commitments once schools offer scholarships in their junior year.

Advertise with us

"You see it every year," Greensburg Central Catholic coach Muzzy Colosimo said. "You have seniors who are good enough to go [Division I] but don't have any offers. It's not like they don't have the talent, it's not that they don't have the size. It's just that if it doesn't happen for you in your junior year, then it isn't happening for you."

In what used to be a frenzied last-minute push by college coaches to convince seniors to sign with their schools during the winter contact period has now become the time when colleges are turning their attention to top juniors.

"Right now, schools are coming in looking at the juniors and making offers to underclassmen," Gateway coach Terry Smith said. "It's a lot different than it was 10 or 15 years ago. Kids are getting opportunities earlier and expected to make their decisions a little sooner."

Fox Chapel coach Bryan Deal is a former Pitt assistant coach and recruiting coordinator. He has a handful of underclassmen who are Division I-A prospects and said he has been told by some colleges that their next year's class is already full.

That means current high school juniors are already feeling the crunch.

Advertise with us

"It's changed significantly even in the last three or four years," Deal said. "With these early commitments, the colleges are focusing on kids younger and younger and just kind of baby-sitting the seniors."

One of Deal's seniors, offensive lineman Miles Dieffenbach, made a verbal commitment to Penn State last spring.

Dieffenbach said this week that he was happy he did so because he could relax and enjoy his senior year and be able to focus on academics.

He also pointed out another indirect benefit to committing early.

"College coaches don't really like kids who wait, because then they have to reserve roster spots for kids and hold off on other kids and tell them they'd like to have them on the team but they can't commit because they don't have the spots," he said. "[Committing early] is good for the coaches and good for you because it allows them to get better recruiting classes, and it's best for you to be coming in with a better recruiting class."

Advertise with us

Dieffenbach is one of 23 high school seniors from the WPIAL (plus Brashear's Manasseh Garner of the City League) who have made verbal commitments to Division I. They, along with Beaver Falls alumnus Todd Thomas, a wide receiver/defensive back who graduated in June and is attending prep school this year, are expected to sign letters of intent Wednesday.

Counting Thomas, six made verbal commitments to Pitt, and Dieffenbach is one of five who chose Penn State.

Just about all of them made their choices known anywhere from months to more than a year ago.

"I just felt like I knew what school was the best fit for me, so I was ready to commit to it," said Pitt recruit Aaron Donald, a lineman from Penn Hills. "I let my coaches know, and that was about it."

Also taking some of the luster off signing day is the fact that a new trend is for some players to graduate high school early and enroll in college in January. Sto-Rox's Paul Jones, one of the top quarterback recruits in the country, is already at Penn State.

Advertise with us

"It used to be that everybody was being recruited around this time," Colosimo said. "Now, they're not even letting kids finish their senior year."

Another reason for the lack of any pizzazz is that this is a down year for talent in Western Pennsylvania.

Jones and fellow Penn State recruit Mike Hull, a linebacker from Canon-McMillan, are among those considered top college prospects, but the WPIAL and City League overall lack the depth and star power they have had in the past.

Still, many coaches believe that is not a trend so much as an aberration. The Class of 2012 (the current sophomore class), for example, is loaded enough it is expected to be one of the WPIAL's best in quite a while.

"It's all cyclical," Deal said. "Look at the NFL draft -- some are heavier than others and so forth. It's the same thing with the WPIAL. This year is one thing, but two years from now, this sophomore class is going to be a great class."

Advertise with us

Staying close to home

11 local recruits gave early commitments to Penn State and Pitt:

Penn State Nittany Lions

Player Pos. School

Miles Dieffenbach OL Fox Chapel

Advertise with us

Mike Hull LBCanon-McMillan

Paul Jones QB Sto Rox

Thomas Ricketts OLNorth Allegheny

Luke Graham OL Penn-Trafford

Pitt Panthers

Advertise with us

Player Pos. School

Andrew Carswell WR Sto-Rox

Aaron Donald DT Penn Hills

Brandon Ifill WR Penn Hills

Khaynin Mosley-SmithDT Woodlnd Hills

Advertise with us

Todd Thomas WR Beaver Falls•

Kevin Weatherspoon WR Clairton

• Thomas is attending a prep school, Milford Academy, in New Berlin, N.Y.