Butler Area is likely still at least a few weeks away from naming a new head football coach, but don't be surprised if the new hire has at least one major difference from the man he succeeds.

Expect the Golden Tornado's new coach to have prior head coaching experience.

"It depends on the pool of applicants and who ends up applying, but it really is going to be important that somebody has head coaching experience in order to take over a Quad-A program," said Jerry Slamecka, district assistant superintendent for personnel, technology and federal and state programs.

"How much experience that is and what level, it's too early to say at this point, but certainly it would be a priority to have someone who has coached at some level before and has a proven track record."

Advertise with us

Slamecka said the school district has given a Jan. 22 deadline to applicants for the position, which became open after the school board voted Dec. 14 to decline to retain Jeff McAnallen.

Slamecka said the district heavily advertised the opening and wanted to make sure sufficient time was given to allow as much response as possible.

The tentative timeline needs to allow the administration and board to review the applications, meaning it likely will be well into February at the earliest before a hiring would be formally announced.

McAnallen was disappointed in being let go from his alma mater -- he is a 1990 Butler alumnus, a standout lineman who later played at Division I Tulsa University -- because he said it was unexpected and because he didn't believe that three years was a fair chance to turn around a program that has struggled for more than a decade.

Butler has not had a winning season since 1997 and has qualified for the playoffs only once since 1993. The Golden Tornado went 3-24 under McAnallen, including 0-9 in his first and final seasons.

Advertise with us

"When the school board informed me of its decision, I was very surprised and I told them that when I first came to take this job, if I had known I'd only be a head coach three years -- really, I was only the head coach for two years and eight months -- I wouldn't have done it and I would have stayed at North Hills as an assistant," McAnallen said.

"There's no bitterness or anything like that, but I think anyone should deserve more time. I don't know what's going to happen with the next people, but for someone to come up there you'd have to sign a five-year deal or something."

Said Slamecka, "There's never been any expectation that it's going to happen in a year or two, but there needs to be some growth."

McAnallen was adamant he still very much wants to be involved in coaching, and preferably at a school in the area, particularly a Northern Six Conference member, where he has coached for the past 15 years (including for a decade at North Hills). He is seeking a coaching and teaching job at a district in the area.

But McAnallen also said he wants to be an assistant. After his experience, he, too, apparently agrees that prior head-coaching experience is a necessity in taking over at a school as large as Butler.

Advertise with us

Whoever ends up taking the job might be burdened with some expectations to win fast, but he also might be able to take over at the time of the awakening of a sleeping giant. For sure, a quantity of athletes will never be a problem -- Butler currently has the largest male enrollment of any WPIAL school.

"From an athletic standpoint, our student body has been successful in probably virtually every other sport other than football," Slamecka said. "That's in terms of at least being very competitive, if not in winning section titles. Football is probably the only exception.

"We know we have the athletes. They're good kids and this is a good community from which we get great support for football and all the other sports. It's just a matter of trying to get the program back on track."

Whoever is hired will be Butler's seventh coach in 19 seasons.

"We've had several coaches, and all have been very good people," Slamecka said. "But for whatever reason, it just hasn't worked out with any of the prior coaches that we've had here.

"And it's not that they haven't made the effort. It's going to take somebody who will take a look at what the potential is here and bring in whatever they need to bring in to do what they can to get the program back on track."