One came from the City League and was given little chance of winning a PIAA championship against a team ranked among the best in the country.
One was a WPIAL team that was undefeated, but had to deal with an opponent that had a future NFL quarterback.
But on that December Saturday 20 years ago, Perry and Upper St. Clair converged in Hershey and within a nine-hour period, on the same field, they gave district football its greatest day on the state level.
Dec. 7, 1989 was a day-night doubleheader that always will be remembered as the day -- the only day -- the WPIAL and City League won PIAA titles.
That bitter cold Saturday at Hersheypark Stadium started with Perry pulling off a gigantic upset, knocking off Berwick, 20-8, in the Class AAA final.
Perry, under coach Gus Catanese, is still the only City League team to win a PIAA title. It was a game that ended with a 5-foot-9, 190-pound linebacker nicknamed "Pepsi" returning an interception 100 yards for a touchdown.
Afterward, Berwick coach George Curry accused the game officials of cheating and said, "I think the officials were bought."
At night in the Class AAAA championship, with temperatures in the low teens, Upper St. Clair knocked off Wilson of West Lawn, 12-7, to become the first WPIAL school to win a PIAA championship with a perfect record (15-0). Upper St. Clair, under coach Jim Render, had a tremendous defensive effort in the title game against Wilson quarterback Kerry Collins, who is still in the NFL these days with the Tennessee Titans.
The stars of those teams were Perry's Rahmon Hart and Upper St. Clair's Doug Whaley. They were running backs on offense and linebackers on defense. They were both later honored by the Post-Gazette as City League Player of the Year and WPIAL Class AAAA Player of the Year.
Hart and Whaley went on to play college football -- Whaley at Pitt and Hart at Slippery Rock. Today, they are enjoying successful careers -- Whaley is the pro personnel coordinator for the Steelers while Hart is the director of multicultural affairs at Duquesne University.
But no matter where their jobs take them, or how their lives change, they still look at that 1989 season, that December Saturday, with a sense of reverence.
"I've won two Super Bowls with the Steelers [organization]," Whaley said. "But to this day, nothing raises the hair on the back of my neck like thinking of that year, winning that state championship and what it felt like coming off that field."
Hart said, "I remember that whole state championship game like it was yesterday. That's amazing, too, because I played in a lot of big games in college and I don't remember any game in college like I do that state championship game. I remember every aspect of it."
Here is a look at those state title games through the eyes of Whaley and Hart.
Perry 20, Berwick 8
Practically no one gave Perry a chance.
Berwick was the defending champion, beating Aliquippa the previous year. Berwick was 14-0 and ranked No. 4 in the country by USA Today.
Perry was just the team from the City League.
"A lot of what motivated us was the lack of respect we thought we were getting," Hart said. "Upper St. Clair and some of the other WPIAL teams were getting over-recognized, we thought. In our eyes, we were going under the radar.
"So we went into the championship with a chip on our shoulders, and I think that's what positioned us to win the game."
Perry had a tremendous defense, nicknamed "Blue Steel." The Commodores gave up only 33 points all season.
After winning the City League championship, Perry shut out Greensburg Salem, 23-0, in the PIAA semifinals. Due to a strange point system the PIAA used back then, Greensburg Salem lost in the first round of the WPIAL playoffs, but still got to represent the WPIAL in the PIAA Class AAA playoffs.
"I was just watching a documentary on the University of Miami football team," Hart said. "In many ways, it reminded me of our team that year. We had that City swagger. We weren't getting into trouble off the field, but we had a certain type of confidence.
"In fact, before the Berwick game I remember being nervous because I thought we had too much confidence."
The PIAA final was a defensive struggle. Perry held Berwick to 123 total yards and intercepted four passes by Berwick quarterback Joe Kelchner. Perry had minus-26 yards rushing, but quarterback Kevin Amin completed 10 of 24 passes for 172 yards, and Lewis Clark had four receptions for 75 yards and intercepted two passes.
Berwick led, 8-0, at halftime, and by 8-6 after three quarters. But with 2:50 left in the game, Perry's Mike Coates recovered a fumble at the Berwick 7, and Hart scored on a 2-yard run two plays later. Amin hit Kevin Woods with the 2-point conversion pass.
From here, things got crazy. Kelchner threw an interception at the Perry 25 with 1:42 left and it looked like the game was over. But on first down, Berwick lineman Tom Robsock literally stole the ball from Amin's hands and Berwick had the ball at the Perry 25 with 1:07 left.
Berwick got to the 3 with 27 seconds left. Kelchner then threw an apparent touchdown pass, but it was called back by an ineligible man downfield penalty.
Perry was called for pass interference on the next play, which put the ball at the 3 again. Kelchner ran to his left and threw for another apparent touchdown, but was clearly past the line of scrimmage and the score was again nullified.
A pass was broken up with 2 seconds left. Then, on the final play of the game, Kelchner rolled to his right and was hit as he threw. Linebacker Darnell Farrow intercepted and waddled 100 yards down the sideline for a touchdown.
When asked afterward why Farrow was nicknamed "Pepsi," a few Perry players said, "Cause he's built like a Pepsi can."
"Man, I cried after that last play," Hart said. "I didn't run down onto the pile in the end zone. I remember taking off my helmet, looking into the stands and crying. I knew it would be something I would never forget."
Upper St. Clair 12, Wilson 7
It was like a two-year championship for Upper St. Clair. The Panthers won the WPIAL title a year earlier, but the Upper St. Clair school board had voted not to participate in the PIAA playoffs.
Many starters were back for 1989, and the Panthers had a staunch defense with a tremendous running game, led by Whaley and Pete Habib. The team had other outstanding players such as lineman Phil Dunn. Kevin Orie, who went on to play Major League Baseball, was a defensive back.
Whaley was superb in the postseason, and had back-to-back 300-yard rushing games in the first two rounds of the WPIAL playoffs against Butler and Hempfield. Upper St. Clair crushed North Hills, 38-14, in the WPIAL title game at Three Rivers Stadium.
After pummeling Hollidaysburg, 51-12, in the PIAA semifinals, the Panthers were facing their biggest challenge in Wilson and Collins, who would go on to play at Penn State.
"What I remember about him was his size, athleticism and his tremendous arm strength," Whaley said. "We wanted to keep him from getting to the edge."
Whaley also remembers how hard Collins threw the ball.
"They were frozen ropes," Whaley said.
In order to get the Panthers ready for Collins, Render brought former strong-armed Baldwin quarterback Brian Gelzheiser to practice that week. He would throw balls at the Upper St. Clair defensive backs.
"We knew if were going to get our hands on one of Collins' passes, it was not going to be a lollipop," Whaley said.
In the game, Upper St. Clair limited Collins to 115 yards passing and Wilson had only 218 total yards.
Upper St. Clair relied heavily on its ground game again as Habib rushed for 151 yards on 16 carries and Whaley added 85 on 13 attempts.
"I remember how cold it was that night and not wanting to be tackled because when you hit the ground, it was like hitting cement," Whaley said.
Upper St. Clair led at halftime, 6-0, and scored on its first drive of the second half when Mike Quealy ran 8 yards for a score.
Orie made a big interception in the fourth quarter when Wilson had driven to the Upper St. Clair 6. Wilson scored later in the fourth quarter, but never got past the 48 the rest of the game.
"To this day, I communicate a lot with the players on that team," Whaley said. "I think one of the reasons we were so successful was we had great chemistry as a team. ... I played in [games in] college at Nebraska and Notre Dame and I have vivid memories of those games. But nothing sparks that memory bank like that year and that state championship."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.