Two defenses alike in both scheme and success will clash at noon Saturday at Cupples Stadium.
In a City League race as wide-open as any, the showdown between Brashear (6-1) and Oliver (5-1) will go a long way in clearing up the playoff picture.
The Bulls bring with them their traditional 33 stack defense that has been yielding only 6.1 points per game. The Bears switched to the 33 stack defense this season and it has been almost as successful, limiting opposing offenses to 7.3 points per game.
The defense consists of three down linemen, five linebackers and three defensive backs with the two outside linebackers playing more like safeties.
"We call it the 3-3 stack but I don't know what it looks like half the time," Oliver coach Tim Keefer said of the ever-changing defense. "It is pretty much the same defense that Brashear plays, but they sit back a little more. We move around a lot."
The defense, which has become more common among WPIAL schools since its implementation at West Virginia in 2002, often confuses offenses with the odd man front and allows teams to make up for a lack of size.
Oliver and Brashear are the only City League teams that used the defense.
"It should help because we practice against it every day," Brashear running back Bruce Patterson said.
In terms of points per game Brashear and Oliver are second and third respectively in the City League, behind Perry.
Saturday's game will not entirely clear up the logjam atop the league standings but it will help.
"I have been around [the City League] for 10 years and I have to say this is as wide open as it has been," Brashear coach Rick Murphy said.
"Who knows how the playoffs are going to play out. Teams match up well against each other. Each week there is a game that can change everything."
This week that game is Brashear and Oliver.
Entering the week Brashear, Oliver and Schenley (5-1) all have one loss with Perry (5-2) also in the mix. Oliver's loss came at the hands of Schenley while the Bulls were upset by Perry, 7-0, in the season opener.
Since that 7-0 opening week shutout at the hands of Perry, Brashear has won six consecutive games by an average of 30 points per game.
"It is hard to say you build momentum each week, but it is easier to get started coming off of a win rather than a loss," Murphy said.
"We got some pretty good seniors and they are kind of self-motivated with the success they have had. They approach each week the same way. They don't want to lose."
And -- since the opener -- they have not lost.
Most of the players on the Brashear roster had never experienced a City League loss until this season. The Bulls carried a 20-game league winning streak into the season. The last loss to a City League opponent was to Oliver, 12-2, in the 2006 City League Championship.
That title game three years ago was the last time Oliver was in the postseason. Since then it has gone a combined 5-15 and the Bears carried a seven-game losing streak into this season.
Even with the 5-1 start, Oliver still could miss the playoffs by losing its final two games. Keefer said his team is treating this game like a playoff game.
The difference this season for Oliver has been its ability to win close games. Last season it was 0-3 in games decided by six points or less. Heading into Saturday, the Bears have won two consecutive contests by single digits, 12-6 against Perry and 14-12 against Carrick.
"We lost games like that in the past," Keefer said. "Everyone was waiting for someone else to make a play. This year they're saying 'Hey, I want to make that play.'"
Brashear's games have lacked any such drama. The trio of quarterback Henri Chatman, Patterson at running back and wide receiver Manessah Garner is what has separated Brashear from every other City League school the past two seasons.
It was Patterson carrying the load last week with 100 yards on 24 carries. Two weeks ago it was Chatman and Garner putting on an aerial showcase at Cupples Stadium. Chatman tossed for an unheard of 398 yards and five touchdowns against Carrick two weeks ago. Garner, a Wisconsin recruit, was on the receiving end of 264 of those yards including three touchdowns.
"It would be difficult for us if those three were selfish," Murphy said. "It would be difficult to balance this offense but the three of them are close [friends]. They do a lot together.
"Being on the past two teams that won titles, they know what it takes. They are at the point in their careers where the team success is what drives them."
The game
• What: Oliver at Brashear.
• When: Noon, Saturday.
• Where: Cupples Stadium, South Side.
• The skinny: Brashear is a half-game ahead of Oliver in the City League Standings with a 6-1 record. Oliver and Schenley are tied at 5-1 with Perry at 5-2.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.