For North Catholic and Knoch, four meetings this season apparently wasn’t enough. They just had to get some extra time with each other.
Not one overtime.
Not two.
But three OTs.
When the drama finally ended Tuesday night in front of a packed house at Plum, North Catholic had pulled out a 77-69 triple overtime win against WPIAL champ Knoch in a PIAA Class 4A second round game.
After his team celebrated on the court after the game, North Catholic coach Jim Rocco went to the bench and sat by himself with his head down. He was spent — physically and emotionally. That’s the toll this thriller took on some. It was the fourth game between the two. They split two close regular season games and Knoch (23-5) blew out North Catholic in the WPIAL semifinals.
Read More
“You put a lot into this and you’re in it with the players,” Rocco said of his post-game emotions. “You’re in it with them every shot and possession. When you care about the kids you’re with, whether coaching or teaching, we care. There’s so much more than just winning. I just appreciate their toughness and it’s emotional. And I’m glad it is because if it wasn’t emotional then what am I doing here?”
The game was tied at 48 after regulation, 54 after the first overtime and 59 after the second extra period. North Catholic (21-6) outscored Knoch, 18-10, in the third overtime.
Jason Fredericks, North Catholic’s standout senior guard, was the key in the third overtime. He hit a deep 3-pointer against Knoch’s zone to start the OT and give North Catholic a lead it wouldn’t relinquish. He then made 7 of 8 free throws for the rest of the overtime and finished with 29 points. Knoch committed some ill-advised fouls in the overtimes far away from the basket that allowed North Catholic to score without having to make plays. Knoch kept fouling Fredericks, who shot 12 free throws in the overtimes.
“I don’t know what to say,” Fredericks said. “That’s the longest game I ever played in. This is probably the latest I stayed up to play a game. This is definitely one of the top games I’ve ever been in. Obviously, playing in the WPIAL championship [last year] might be first, but making it to another elite eight [in the PIAA tournament], this is big.”
North Catholic won despite playing the third extra period without two starters. One was senior guard Jude Rottmann, who had 18 points. The other was sophomore guard Jake Olkowski, who had 11. So the Trojans just leaned on Fredericks.
“I looked at coach Rocco,” Fredericks said, “and we both said the same thing — I have to take it over. I just have to end it. So that’s what I tried to do.”
Knoch senior guard Teegan Finucan, the school’s all-time leading scorer, pumped in 26 points, but had a rough night shooting, going 7 of 26 from the field. Guard Vinnie DeFelice added 15 and forward Derek Lang 10.
In triple OT, North Catholic knocks off WPIAL champ Knoch 77-69 in second round of 4A states. pic.twitter.com/1FvrlxwEmu
— Mike White (@mwhiteburgh) March 11, 2026
Game flow
The game was close throughout. Both teams led by five in the first half and that was the biggest lead until overtime. Finucan’s two free throws tied the game, 48-48, with 22 seconds left in regulation and North Catholic never got off a final shot.
North Catholic freshman Brandon Pickett, who had 12 points, missed a 3-pointer at the buzzer in the first overtime.
DeFelice scored on a driving layup with nine seconds left in the second overtime and North Catholic could only get off a shot from beyond half court.
A gigantic play in the third overtime was made by reserve Tom Rottmann, Jude’s younger brother. With North Catholic ahead by 64-61, Rottmann snuck up behind a Knoch player and poked the ball away. He then fed Pickett for a breakaway dunk that put North Catholic ahead, 66-61, with 1:21 left. Knoch then committed a turnover on its next possession and Frederick made two free throws with 1:08 left. Knoch couldn’t recover.
Key stats
Breaking the game to its basics, the difference was North Catholic’s shooting in the fourth quarter and overtimes. Against a much bigger Knoch team, North Catholic knew it had to make some outside shots. But in the second and third quarters, North Catholic was 3 for 14 from 3-point range. But North Catholic made 3 of 5 in the fourth quarter, two by Jude Rottmann. Tom Rottmann had a big 3-pointer in the second overtime.
“I know defense wins championships, and I get all that,” Rocco said. “But you have to make shots and we made enough tonight.”
Quotable
“We weren’t North Catholic the last time we played them,” Rocco said of the 24-point loss. “So, like all coaches, we sort of challenged them. I scheduled a practice at 8 o’clock the next day. … These guys are just finding a way right now. They’re just resilient and I’m super proud of them.”
What it means
The win kept Knoch from making the PIAA quarterfinals for only the second time. The other time was 1981 when the team was coached by Terry Thompson.
North Catholic will play in the quarterfinals for the fourth consecutive season.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.