With his team trailing by two points in the closing seconds of regulation Tuesday, Gateway coach Vern Benson felt no need to get cute when drawing up a play in the timeout huddle.

“Give the ball to Kel and get out of his way,” were Benson’s instructions.

Gateway executed it to perfection, and a special drive by a special player helped drive the Gators into the WPIAL Class 5A quarterfinals.

Mykel Bruce-McCrommon forced overtime with some late heroics and No. 5-seeded Gateway dominated the extra period on its way to a thrilling 56-50 home win against No. 12 Indiana in a first-round game.

Advertise with us

The matchup between Bruce-McCrommon, a 6-foot-7 senior guard, and Indiana 6-8 junior guard Aaron Webb lived up to its billing. The two guarded one another for the majority of the game and both finished with 23 points. Bruce-McCrommon was 9 of 16 from the field and Webb was 6 of 14. Webb made four 3-pointers and Bruce-McCrommon one. An assistant coach from Marquette was in attendance to watch Webb, who scored a school-record 49 in a game two weeks ago.

Benson said he hoped to keep Webb from producing any splash plays, and Benson’s Gators didn’t allow any for much of the game. But with Indiana trailing by one in the final minute of regulation, Darius Webb forced a steal and Will Olsen threw an alley-oop to Aaron Webb, who tossed down a thunderous dunk to put Indiana ahead, 47-46, with 36 seconds left. Following a Bruce-McCrommon miss, Olsen went 1 of 2 from the free-throw line to extend the Indiana lead to 48-46 with nine seconds remaining.

Gateway (16-7), which now has won 10 of 12, inbounded and Jax Vovaris quickly got the ball to Bruce-McCrommon, who dribbled down the left side and around two defenders before making the acrobatic game-tying layup.

“I was just getting it and going as far as I could to the rim. I wanted to draw attention and just try to lay it up, which happened,” said Bruce-McCrommon, who battled cramps and a groin injury he has played with in recent games.

“We were trying to force Mykel to his left,” Indiana coach Andy Lansberry said. “We didn’t want to give up a 3. The kid made a great play to go to overtime. I kind of saw how we acted when he made it, and we just looked deflated.”

Advertise with us

Lansberry was right. After rallying from nine points down in the third quarter to get to overtime, Indiana (13-8), looking for its first playoff win since 2018, was gassed. The Indians committed six turnovers in overtime and had 23 in the game. Darius Webb’s layup a minute into overtime gave the Indians a 50-49 lead, but Gateway scored the final seven points to claim the win.

“Our energy was a little higher,” Benson said, “and we took care of the ball a little better.”

Game flow

The first half was tight and included seven lead changes. Bruce-McCrommon scored on a finger roll for the game’s first points and Aaron Webb punched right back with a 3-pointer despite Bruce-McCrommon guarding him closely.

Gateway was just 9 of 24 shooting in the opening half, but benefited from nine Indiana turnovers to go into the half with a 24-21 lead.

The Gators used a 9-0 run in the third quarter to take their largest lead, 36-27, following a leaner by Bruce-McCrommon with 3:45 left. Vovaris hit a 3-pointer during the run, one of three he had in the game. He finished with 16 points.

Advertise with us

“When I’m looking and driving to the paint and I see him wide open, I know he’s going to give us some 3s,” Bruce-McCrommon said.

But Indiana fought back with a 17-6 run to go up, 44-42, when Aaron Webb went 2 of 3 from the free-throw line with 4:56 left.

“We went to a triangle-and-two and we kind of stayed with it for the rest of the game,” Lansberry said. “I think that kind of threw them for a loop.”

Reserve guard Jonathan Ward put Gateway back ahead at 46-44 courtesy of a 3-pointer from the corner with 3:28 left. The Gators held that lead until Aaron Webb’s dunk with 36 seconds left.

Key stats

• Gateway shot 22 of 57 from the field (38%), while Indiana was 17 of 41 (41%). Indiana connected on seven 3-pointers and Gateway had five.

Advertise with us

• Indiana finished 9 of 16 from the free-throw line and Gateway was 7 of 14.

• Gateway has held six consecutive opponents to 51 or fewer points. The 50 points scored by Indiana were its third fewest of the season.

Quotable

“I’ve got a lot of respect for him as a player. He’s really good and we just went back and forth throughout the whole game. That was one of the funnest games I’ve had.” — Bruce-McCrommon on Aaron Webb.

What’s next

Gateway advances to take on No. 4 Moon (19-3) Friday in the quarterfinals. Moon was a 45-30 winner Tuesday against Penn-Trafford. Indiana should be strong again next season as the Indians lose only two starters and bring back the Webb twins.