Trinity guard Vittoria Emerich had a lot of time to think when she headed to the bench with her fourth personal foul just 45 seconds into the fourth quarter.

She also got to watch her team take and blow a 10-point lead to West Allegheny before she finally made her return in the closing seconds.

But despite watching so much of the game from the sideline, the junior was more than prepared to step into the spotlight for the Hillers at the most critical time.

Emerich was sent to the free-throw line for a three-shot foul with 0.5 seconds remaining in regulation when she was hacked trying to fire up a desperation shot. Instead, she calmly made the first and third shots as No. 9-seededTrinity (17-6) escaped with a 50-48 upset of host No. 8 West Allegheny (18-5) Friday night in the opening round of the WPIAL Class 5A girls basketball playoffs.

Advertise with us

“Time was ticking down and the girl was all over me, so I was like, ‘I’ve got to shoot it,’ so I put it up there and she fouled me,” Emerich said. “I’m pretty confident in my free-throw shooting ability, so the feeling of having three was like a good number.”

Though she made 2 of 3 — she made the first and last and missed the one in the middle — West Allegheny still was able to call a timeout after she made the third, set a play up on the inbounds and got a look at a desperation halfcourt 3-pointer. Unfortunately for the Indians, the shot never really had a chance and caromed harmlessly away.

“We’re led by a great group of girls. The energy was there, the hustle was there,” West Allegheny coach Maura Castelluci said. “We said win-or-go-home and they really fought to the very end.”

Emerich hitting the two free throws was the culmination of a frenetic fourth quarter which saw both teams put together double-digit runs before they headed down to the wire as the game was tied twice in the final 1:08.

“This was playoff basketball. West Allegheny is a really good team, well-coached, they never quit and that’s the game we expected,” Trinity coach Bill Poletti said. “Our girls, they didn’t quit, they never waver and I was really, really proud of the way they stuck in there.”

Advertise with us

West Allegheny took its final lead, 35-32, with 7:15 remaining as Alexis Santucci converted an old-fashioned three-point play when she was fouled on a made basket by Emerich. Even though the team lost the player who was, at the time, its leading scorer with 12 points, Trinity immediately rallied. After a Bently Layhue basket, Sutton Williamson, who later fouled out with 15 points, scored the next eight points, which keyed a 13-0 run to give the Hillers a 45-35 lead with 3:54 left.

But just when it looked as if West Allegheny was about to be left for dead, the team arose from the ashes. Emma Ruperto drilled a 3-pointer that started a 10-0 run for the Indians as the junior netted six of her 11 in the game during the tear to knot it up, 45-45, with 1:18 remaining.

Trinity took a 48-45 lead when junior Gabby Rieg hit her second 3-pointer of the quarter with 54.7 seconds left, but West Allegheny answered when sophomore Skylar Gubba connected from long range to tie it at 48-48 with 46.5 seconds to play.

In the final seconds, though, the plan in a late timeout was for West Allegheny to foul because the team still had one foul to give before it put Trinity in the double-bonus. Junior Leila Marchinsky did exactly what she was supposed to do, to grab whoever had the ball off the inbounds, but she caught Emerich on the arm while she was trying to take the shot.

“We told them, when the ball comes in, foul, because it takes time off the clock,” Castelluci said. “She fouled her once they didn’t call it, she fouled her again and she was shooting. That one play didn’t cost us the game.”

Advertise with us

What it means

With the win, Trinity now will take on top-seeded South Fayette (22-1) Wednesday at a site and time to be determined. The Lions, who are the reigning state champions, have not lost to a team from Pennsylvania this year and defeated Kiski Area, 78-19, in their playoff opener.

Trinity and South Fayette previously met in the postseason in the 2024 quarterfinals when the sixth-seeded Lions upset the No. 3 Hillers, 53-39, at Peters Township on their way to the WPIAL title.

“I think what we’ve to to do is be who we are, trust what got us there,” Poletti said. “Obviously South Fayette is a really good team, extremely well-coached, Bryan Bennett does an amazing job with that group, but we’re going to do our best to prepare, get ready to go out there Wednesday night.”

Key stats

• Trinity was only 7 for 16 from the free-throw line in the game, while West Allegheny was 11 of 15.

• The Hillers opened the game with a 7-0 run, but West Allegheny still led, 13-10, at the end of the first quarter.

Advertise with us

• Trinity was 6 for 26 (23.1%) from the floor in the first half.

Quotable

“We’ve been preparing for games like this all season. Ever since the summer we’ve been working day in and day out to prepare for games like this. I have so much confidence in our team and I believe we can show up to any team and win.” — Emerich on South Fayette.