And the survey says … many athletic directors at public high schools in Pennsylvania would like to see separate playoffs for public and private/Catholic/charter schools.
That’s what came out of a recent survey of ADs at some districts around Pennsylvania. A small group based in eastern Pa. that is trying to help in the push for separate playoffs sent the survey to public school athletic directors in the WPIAL (District 7), District 1 (suburban Philadelphia) and District 3 (Harrisburg and surrounding areas). The PIAA is made up of 12 districts and the survey was sent to ADs in two other districts (6 and 10) this week.
“A little more than 200 schools in those districts [7, 1 and 3] responded and about 95% of those ADs that responded would like to see separate playoffs,” Casey Scanlan said.
Scanlan is a resident of the Lehigh Valley in eastern Pa., a former athlete at Parkland High School who is the leader of the group that is calling itself “HB 41 Support Group.” HB 41 stands for House Bill 41, which was adopted last year by state Rep. Scott Conklin of Centre County. The bill would allow the PIAA to make separate playoffs for boundary and non-boundary schools. Boundary schools are public schools that can only take students from a certain geographic boundary. The non-boundary schools (private, Catholic and charter) can draw students from anywhere, even out of state.
The bill doesn’t mandate the PIAA to have separate playoffs, but would give the PIAA the authority to make the change. Last May, HB 41 was advanced out of committee to the state House, where it is currently tabled.
“Our hope is that within the next three months, maybe by May, the bill will be on the House floor for consideration and voted on by the House,” Scanlan said. “The hope is that through school district unity and forming of a statewide coalition, we can finally address through our legislators the issue of competitive equity and fairness in the PIAA championships with boundary and non-boundary schools.”
Read More
The public vs. private/Catholic/charter schools has long been debated, but even more so in the past 15-20 years after the Philadelphia Catholic and Public League schools joined the PIAA. The Public League includes charter schools, which have no geographic boundaries. The debate became hot again a few weeks ago when Alabama’s governing body for high school sports voted to have separate playoffs for boundary and non-boundary schools, starting with fall sports in 2026. Scanlan said eight other states have separate playoffs.
Conklin has said the non-boundary schools have an unfair advantage in high school sports and coaches, school administrators and fans have complained about the advantage for years. Scanlan said he speaks with Conklin about the issue “regularly.”
But the PIAA has never really expressed interest in having separate playoffs. The PIAA stance on the issue has always been that it can’t have separate playoffs because of a 1972 bill that authorized the PIAA to take in private and Catholic schools to participate with public schools. But there is some gray area in that bill because it said nothing about playoffs.
“Our group feels very strongly about the language of the bill. We’re not advocating kicking the non-boundary schools out of the PIAA,” Scanlan said. “We’re advocating everyone can still be under the PIAA umbrella, but separate for the PIAA playoffs.
“There is anecdotal, but also real data evidence of non-boundary schools having an advantage. We know who we’re talking about. I don’t have to name them. But there are religious schools taking kids and recruiting kids 50 miles away from them and even out of state. We have recruitment letters from these schools.
“Some public schools might do some of this recruiting behind the scenes, too, and get away with it. That’s not right, either. But the large scope and scale of this recruiting from non-boundary schools has exploded over the past 20 years. With the rise of more charter schools, you’re going to see the competitive imbalance growing and not shrinking.”
Part of the survey to athletic directors asked whether separate playoffs should exist in all sports, or just some.
“This is not an issue for all sports,” Scanlan said. “For example, boys volleyball is dominated by boundary schools. But the recruiting happens and the non-boundaries dominate the most in basketball and football and now we’re seeing it more in wrestling.”
Scanlan points out that in a number of sports, only 25% to 30% of the schools in Pennsylvania are non-boundary, but they win the majority of the state championships in football and basketball. He has plenty of data to prove his points. For example, eight of the past 10 state champions in Class 6A football have been either St. Joseph’s Prep or La Salle College, both Philadelphia Catholic League schools. La Salle beat Pittsburgh Central Catholic for the 2025 Class 6A title. Six of the past 10 football champions in Class 5A have been non-boundary schools.
In 2024, four of the six state champions in football were non-boundary schools.
On the district level, Central Catholic has won seven titles since 2013 in the WPIAL’s largest classification.
Scanlan said the purpose of the survey to schools was to make sure they know that HB 41 exists. Athletic directors who filled out the survey were purposely kept anonymous. Scanlan said the next step is to get athletic directors and school superintendents to sign a petition with their names. There will also be a petition for the general public to sign.
“We need the schools to be vocal now and sign the petition,” Scanlan said.
Where all this goes is anybody’s guess, but Scanlan, his group and others seem intent on getting HB 41 to a vote in the House and then the Senate.
Bill Cherpak is the legendary football coach at Thomas Jefferson High School in the WPIAL and also the school’s athletic director. He said he supports separate playoffs for boundary and non-boundary, but did not fill out Scanlan’s survey.
“I emailed him back and said there are some public school recruiting kids, too. He said that’s a subject for another day and time,” Cherpak said. “This has been an issue for so many years. I just don’t foresee it changing, as much as some people might want it. I know the PIAA always refers back to that 1970s bill. I don’t know if that’s a crutch for them to lean on or what. But they haven’t shown any willingness to even discuss this.
“This [public vs. private] has been brought up many times before, but it seems like this group is more organized and more determined to get something done than anyone in the past.”

JUST SAYIN’
• Since 2000, 13 girls basketball teams and 10 boys squads have won WPIAL championships with perfect records. This year, only one team on either side has a chance at perfection. The Blackhawk girls are the only team headed into the playoffs with a perfect record. The Sewickley Academy boys were undefeated until losing to Roselle Catholic (N.J.) Monday night.
• More and more major colleges are starting to notice and become interested in Indiana’s Aaron Webb. A 6-foot-8 junior guard, Webb already had scholarship offers from Virginia Tech and Penn State, plus a few mid-major schools. Louisville also has been very interested. Then Marquette assistant coach Neill Berry came to watch Webb scored 35 against Shaler last week and Webb recently took an unofficial visit to Duquesne. Look for more offers to come Webb’s way in the future. Incidentally, Webb heads into the WPIAL playoffs averaging 24.1 points. That is the highest regular-season average for an Indiana player since the Post-Gazette began keeping WPIAL leading scorers in the 1979-80 season.
• Geibel Catholic’s Emma Larkin and Mallory Clemmer are one of the best one-two scoring punches in the WPIAL in the past 40-plus years. Statistics say that’s not an overstatement. Larkin, a senior, finished the regular season averaging 24.8 points while Clemmer, a sophomore, averaged 22.2. Since the 1982-83 season, it is only the sixth time two players from the same team both averaged 20 or more in the regular season. By the way, Aliquippa’s Carrie Bordas and Mona Gaffney both averaged 20 or more in back-to-back seasons (1988-89 and 1989-90). The other duos to average 20 or more since 1982-83 are Ellwood City’s Anne Malkowiak and Doneen Aloi (1987-88), Monessen’s Gina Naccarato and Angie Scirotto (1992-93) and Central Valley’s Seairra Barrett and Kiana Law (2013-14).

• Terry Smith is an assistant football coach at Penn State and was the interim head coach for the Nittany Lions this past season after James Franklin was fired. But Smith will be honored in May for his high school coaching. Smith is one of seven coaches who will be inducted into the Pennsylvania Scholastic Football Coaches Association Hall of Fame. Smith coached Gateway for 11 seasons from 2002-12 and had a record of 101-30 with seven conference titles. One other WPIAL coach also will be inducted into the PSFCA Hall of Fame – Tom Loughran, who coached 40 seasons at South Park and Fox Chapel and won 210 games.
IT’S BEEN A WHILE
The Derry boys basketball team won a section championship for the first time since 1957. But breaking a long drought for a section championship was a popular theme in WPIAL basketball this season – boys and girls. The Plum girls won a section title for the first time since the WPIAL started girls basketball in the early 1970s. The Belle Vernon girls won their first section title since 1999. On the boys side, South Park won a section championship for the first time since 1998 and Jefferson-Morgan its first since 2001.
DATA WAY
25
Football players from the WPIAL and City League senior class of 2026 who ended up signing with FBS colleges. That is the most from the district since 33 signed in 2014. Three of the last six classes had fewer than 20 FBS recruits, including only 13 in 2022.

REMEMBERING WHEN
Thirty years ago this month, Mt. Lebanon center Kim Seaver scored 40 points in a 72-67 loss to Woodland Hills in a WPIAL Class 4A girls basketball first-round game. Seaver’s point total is still tied for the most ever in a WPIAL 4A postseason game. She made 14 of 23 shots and also pulled down 23 rebounds. Seaver was a Post-Gazette Fabulous 5 selection and went on to a nice career at the University of Virginia. She is now Kim Robbins and the mother of some big, talented Upper St. Clair players. Tyler Robbins was a 6-foot-10 forward for Upper St. Clair who now plays at Miami (Ohio), the only undefeated team in Division I men’s college basketball. Ryan Robbins is a 6-7 junior center currently for Upper St. Clair and also an offensive lineman in football who has a few major college scholarship offers for football.
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and @mwhiteburgh on X.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.