There were a lot of differences between the first and second times the Oakland Catholic and North Catholic girls basketball teams met this year.

Most notably the Trojanettes actually held the lead at one point. Granted, it was only by two after Sam Weir scored the opening basket of the game, but it was still one more lead than they held the first time around.

But at the end of the day, the Eagles did exactly what they did in their first go-round on Dec. 11. They found a way to shut North Catholic down at the most critical time and came away with an important section victory.

Oakland Catholic senior forward Josie Fontana scored 18 points and crushed North Catholic’s hopes with a critical 3-pointer midway through the fourth quarter as the Class 4A No. 2 Eagles (11-2, 7-0) all but officially clinched the outright Section 1 title with a 50-36 road win Thursday against No. 3 North Catholic (9-4, 5-2).

Advertise with us

“I was super proud of them the way we played. It’s a hostile environment, you’re playing at their place and they’re excited,” Oakland Catholic coach Henry Schechter said. “There’s a lot of ebb and flow when you’re in the middle of the year and it’s tough. But we practiced pretty well these last couple of days and they were excited about playing a rival.”

Even though Oakland Catholic won by 14, it took an impressive defensive performance down the stretch to bring home the win.

Trailing 35-28 entering the fourth quarter, North Catholic made its run. Brady Wehner, who led the team with 18 points, hit a shot to open the period and started an 8-2 run, capped off by a 3-pointer from Lauren Reitz – who didn’t play in the first game – to get the Trojanettes back within a point, 37-36, with 6:22 remaining in regulation.

Then – nothing.

North Catholic had two possessions to take the lead but could not convert. Reitz missed two opportunities from close to the basket on the first, then the team turned the ball over at midcourt on the second.

Advertise with us

When the Trojanettes failed on their two chances, Oakland Catholic put the hammer down. Fontana drained a 3-pointer with 4:54 left in regulation, then extended the advantage to 42-36 with a basket with 3:16 left.

Fontana’s 3-pointer started a 13-0 Eagles run to close out the game.

“I think absolutely it would have changed things. We had clawed our way back and, if you take that lead, it’s going to re-energize you a little bit,” North Catholic coach Molly Rottmann said. “When you don’t get the lead, that’s the game.”

Game flow

Considering that North Catholic was outscored, 10-0, in the first quarter the first time the two matched up, Weir scoring to give the Trojanettes an early lead 42 seconds in was something of a relief.

Neither team played all that well in the first quarter as they combined for 10 turnovers and were 8 of 25 (32%) from the floor, but Oakland Catholic, behind four points from senior guard Savanna Daye, took a 10-9 lead into the second quarter.

Advertise with us

Daye, who is often overshadowed by Fontana and Zephaniah Troxler-Scott, the latter of whom was in foul trouble in the first half, finished with 15 points and four rebounds.

“I just want to be the backbone of my team,” Daye said. “I wanna be there for them. They know if things aren’t going well for our star players, I want to be someone who can step up.”

Oakland Catholic was able to extend its lead to six on two occasions in the second quarter, but a 3-pointer and another late hoop by Wehner got the Trojanettes back to within 21-18 at the intermission.

Key stats

• Oakland Catholic was 2 for 7 from the free-throw line in the first half, including an 0 for 5 showing in the second quarter.

• North Catholic made its first two baskets of the game then missed its next eight in the first quarter.

Advertise with us

Quotable

“When we play our style and we’re patient good things are going to happen. It was certainly important for us to take their best shot and then finish it out.” – Schechter

What it means

With five section games remaining it is mathematically possible for North Catholic to come back to tie Oakland Catholic for the section title but it is highly unlikely. The Eagles defeated their five remaining opponents by an average of 39.2 points the first time around and only Burrell was within 15. The others were all mercy-rule victories. Take out the game against the Bucs and that margin goes up to 45.3.