More than 400 AAU boys basketball teams and more than 4,000 high school-age players ascended on the David L. Lawrence Convention Center last weekend for the Pittsburgh JamFest tournament. It was an event during a live recruiting period, meaning college coaches were allowed to attend and they came from all levels, including some from NCAA Division I.
Events like these are designed to help high school players in recruiting. But the buzz around the JamFest with many of the college coaches was what’s hurting high school basketball recruiting.
That would be the NCAA transfer portal.
Relaxed conversations with some of the college coaches in attendance — and even some AAU coaches — would often turn to how the transfer portal has cost high school basketball players scholarships, and especially those who are mid to low Division I prospects. But also for players who would normally be a solid Division II college prospect.
The big-time prospects in high school still are getting loads of offers, no matter their year. But college coaches feel plenty of seniors are out there who might have had a handful of offers from mid to low Division I schools, but don’t have any now.
Also, some Division II colleges aren’t recruiting high school kids as much because they want to possibly get a Division I player who enters the transfer portal.
Read More
“It’s hurting high school kids because they just aren’t being looked at,” said Jim Ferry, former coach at Duquesne University and now the coach at the University of Maryland, Baltimore County.
As of earlier this week, reports had the transfer portal with more than 1,400 players, all looking to leave their school and go somewhere else for myriad reasons. And college coaches from coast to coast are recruiting the transfer portal, looking to fill holes on their teams. Many of those coaches feel taking a player with possibly two or more years experience at the college level is better than taking a high school player who might be a year or two away from helping a college team.
Heck, even Ferry put himself among the coaches using the transfer portal.
“We’re all part of the problem because we’re all trying to stay old — just because you can,” Ferry said. “Everyone is looking in the transfer portal to get kids with experience who are going to fill holes instead of taking a high school kid and ultimately that hurts the high school kid. But I think it might be hurting the development of college programs, too.
“A college can get high school kids to kind of build a program. But a lot of people are concerned that if you take a high school kid and he plays well, he’s going to leave the next year anyway. On the other hand, do you beat older college teams with younger kids? Normally not.”
I’ve seen the transfer portal affect WPIAL players. Fox Chapel senior guard Eli Yofan might be a good example. He’s a two-time member of the Post-Gazette Fabulous Five. Is he a low Division I college player? I’d say maybe. In past years, he would at least be looked at by a number of Division II colleges and maybe even offered scholarships. But Yofan’s interest from Division I colleges has been minimal at best and Division II colleges aren’t exactly chasing him, either.
Another top WPIAL senior, who did not want his name used, recently said Division III colleges told him earlier this season that they are not going to bother recruiting him because they feel he is above their level. But Division II colleges haven’t touched him because they want to look in the transfer portal first for players.
Hoop Group is a longtime New Jersey-based company that ran Jam Fest and has run camps and AAU tournaments for years. Rob Kennedy is Hoop Group’s longtime president and has been involved with college coaches and recruiting for more than three decades. He is adamant about how the transfer portal is hurting high school kids.
“This might be the biggest effect on recruiting since Prop 48 [in the 1980s],” Kennedy said. “It’s hurting mostly seniors, but you’re seeing fewer colleges recruiting the younger kids now, except the high major colleges. The mid to low majors that would have been recruiting sophomores and juniors aren’t even worrying about them for now.”
Kennedy is quite knowledgeable about the basketball recruiting world and had some other interesting thoughts and points about other subjects concerning the transfer portal and how it has made things more difficult on college coaches.
“Right now everyone is in a rush to win tomorrow. Why? Part of it is because if you don’t win tomorrow, coaches are getting fired after two or three years and everyone is trying to get older players quicker,” Kennedy said. “The established mid-majors and high majors that don’t have a ton of kids in the transfer portal, they’re getting high schools to develop and keep. That’s why they might have success, but there’s a smaller group of them. I’ve seen some schools have immediate success because they’ve gone into the transfer portal and got players. They can fix things, but I’m not sure if the fix is long term. It’s got to be hard to do that using the transfer portal every year.”
“The joke among coaches at the Final Four was, ‘Hey, how’d you do in the transfer portal? Did the kids you wanted to go in actually go in? And did the kids you didn’t want to go in actually end up going in?
“College coaching is a harder job than it used to be. Now don’t get me wrong. They’re compensated a lot more. So if you have a 10-year run at a high major, you’re set for life with money. But at some point, it might wear on you now because it’s non-stop. There’s no re-set for coaches.”
Maybe Ferry said it best about the transfer portal.
“Personally, I don’t like how the whole thing is going. Maybe in a couple years we’ll see how the process worked out. There are positives and negatives with it.”
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.