Where should Fox Chapel be seeded after losing only one game?

Should Butler be the No. 1 seed in Class 6A?

Where do you put three-time defending Class 4A champ New Castle?

Highlands and Knoch tied for a section title, and should be one them be seeded No. 1 in Class 4A?

Advertise with us

How high should South Allegheny be seeded?

Those are some of the questions the WPIAL basketball committee will face when it meets tomorrow to decide playoff brackets. Pairings and seedings will be announced Tuesday night.

Class 6A, 5A and 4A all have 12 playoff teams, so four teams in each classification will receive a first-round bye. Class 2A and 1A have 13 teams, so three teams will receive a bye. Class 3A has 16 teams, so no one will get a bye.

But we’re here to save the WPIAL committee some time. Here is how the brackets should be set up, and here are the predicted seedings for all teams:

WPIAL CLASS 6A

Advertise with us

Byes: Butler, Mt. Lebanon, Upper St. Clair, Fox Chapel.

Matchups: Hempfield (8) vs. Peters Township (9), winner to play Butler (1); Central Catholic (6) vs. Penn-Trafford (11), winner to play Upper St. Clair (3); Bethel Park (7) vs. North Allegheny (10), winner to play Mt. Lebanon (2); Pine-Richland (5) vs. Connellsville (12), winner to play Fox Chapel (4).

The scoop: The biggest question with this class is what to do with Fox Chapel? The Foxes were 20-0 until losing to Upper St. Clair in a non-section game Friday. Fox Chapel is undoubtedly good, but everyone wondered how good? The Foxes played in Section 3, which was unquestionably the weakest of the three Class 6A sections. Fox Chapel owns a win against Penn Hills, but Penn Hills was missing a starter and top reserve in the game. Losing to Upper St. Clair certainly hurt the Foxes’ seeding, but losing by 15 points at home was even more damaging. … Upper St. Clair is unquestionably one of the top three teams in Class 6A, owning wins against Mt. Lebanon, Fox Chapel, Allderdice and Mars. The Panthers are capable of winning it all, but you still can’t put Upper St. Clair ahead of Mt. Lebanon because they split two games and Mt. Lebanon beat out Upper St. Clair for a section title. Then when you consider Mt. Lebanon lost to Butler, the No. 1 seed goes to Butler. True, Butler has four losses, but Butler was undefeated against WPIAL teams when star point guard Ethan Morton played. He missed a few games with an injured ankle and the WPIAL committee should definitely consider that. … It says here that any of the top five seeded teams have a chance to win the title. A possible quarterfinal game between Pine-Richland and Fox Chapel looks like a good one.

WPIAL CLASS 5A

Byes: Penn Hills, Mars, Chartiers Valley, Thomas Jefferson.

Advertise with us

Matchups: South Fayette (8) vs. Hampton (9), winner to play Penn Hills (1); Laurel Highlands (7) vs. Franklin Regional (10), winner to play Mars (2); McKeesport (6) vs. West Allegheny (11), winner to play Chartiers Valley (3); Shaler (5) vs. Gateway (12), winner to play Thomas Jefferson (4).

The scoop: This classification isn’t as strong as it was the past couple years, at least in terms of depth of quality teams. Finding the top three seeds was pretty easy — Penn Hills, Mars and Chartiers Valley. But choosing seeds 4-6 was hard. … Shaler might have been worthy of the No. 4 seed a week or so ago, but the Titans lost three of their final four section games. … McKeesport’s loss to No. 12 seed Gateway on Saturday didn’t help the Tigers’ cause. … Thomas Jefferson gets the nod at the No. 4 seed. Not for any real solid reason, but the Jaguars did win three of their final four. Plus, if Gateway gets the No. 12 seed, you don’t want to put McKeesport at No. 5 because that would mean a first-round matchup between McKeesport and Gateway, who are section foes. … Laurel Highlands is an intriguing team at No. 7. The Mustangs, which feature freshman Rodney Gallagher, beat Penn Hills, Uniontown (a top Class 4A team) and Gateway in the final two weeks of the season.

WPIAL CLASS 4A

Byes: Highlands, Quaker Valley, Knoch, Uniontown.

Matchups: Belle Vernon (8) vs. Mount Pleasant (9), winner to play Highlands (1); Ambridge (7) vs. Ringgold (10), winner to play Quaker Valley (2); New Castle (6) vs. Elizabeth Forward (11), winner to play Knoch (3); Blackhawk (5) vs. Derry (12), winner to play Uniontown (4).

Advertise with us

The scoop: Who should be the No. 1 seed? Highlands and Knoch tied for the section title. Quaker Valley has been in the championship the past three seasons and is a formidable team again. Should Uniontown be considered? The vote here went to Highlands. The Rams are 19-3 and their overall resume is the most impressive. Highlands has wins against Allderdice, the No. 1 City League team, as well as WPIAL playoff teams Lincoln Park, Shaler, McKeesport, Gateway and Beaver Falls. … Section 2 is by far the best section in this classification and Quaker Valley and Blackhawk tied for the section title. Blackhawk is capable of a playoff run, but the Cougars’ non-section record of 2-8 has to drop them to the No. 5 seed. Really, there isn’t much difference between the No. 4 and 5 seeds, except the No. 4 seed gets a bye. … The team to watch in this classification is New Castle. No, this isn’t one of coach Ralph Blundo’s best teams, but that has been said before and he keeps winning championships. He’s won three in a row in Class 4A. A possible quarterfinal matchup between New Castle and Knoch would be one of the best in any classification, as well as a possible quarterfinal between Blackhawk and Uniontown. … Ambridge was tied for the section lead a few weeks ago, but four losses in the final five section games dropped the Bridgers all the way down to the No. 7 seed.

WPIAL CLASS 3A

Byes: None.

Matchups: Lincoln Park (1) vs. Avonworth (16); Seton LaSalle (8) vs. McGuffey (9); South Allegheny (4) vs. Neshannock (13); Charleroi (5) vs. Deer Lakes (12) North Catholic (2) vs. Southmoreland (15); Beaver Falls (7) vs. Steel Valley (10); Washington (3) vs. Shady Side Academy (14); Aliquippa (6) vs. Carlynton (11).

The scoop: We could debate the No. 1 seed between Lincoln Park and North Catholic. Both have impressive resumes, with some impressive wins outside of section. But maybe the tiebreaker is that Lincoln Park is the defending WPIAL and PIAA champion and has a number of players back from that team. … A problem was what to do with Washington and Charleroi, who tied for a section title? They have the same overall record also. You could flip a coin to decide the higher seed, but the choice was Washington because Washington defeated McGuffey by 21 points on Thursday, while Charleroi lost to McGuffey by 12 points on Tuesday. … How good is South Allegheny, which won a section title for only the second time in school history? The Gladiators are slotted into the No. 4 seed. The quarterfinals could have a matchup of section champs between South Allegheny and Charleroi.

Advertise with us

WPIAL CLASS 2A

Byes: Our Lady of the Sacred Heart, Sto-Rox, Jeannette.

Matchups: Brentwood (8) vs. Apollo-Ridge (9), winner to play OLSH (1); Serra (7) vs. South Side Beaver (10), winner to play Sto-Rox (2); Shenango (6) vs Winchester Thurston (11), winner to play Jeannette (3); Springdale (4) vs. Sewickley Academy (13); California (12) vs. Laurel (5).

The scoop: Three teams from Section 2 – OLSH, Shenango and Laurel – are among the top six seeds. … Sto-Rox tied Springdale for a section title and Jeannette also is a section champ. But the choice for the No. 2 seed went to Sto-Rox, which has won 11 in a row. Sto-Rox and Springdale split two games this season. Springdale won the first, 86-85, in overtime, but Sto-Rox clobbered Springdale the second meeting, 72-49. … You might think South Side Beaver and Sewickley Academy should be next to each other in seeds because they tied for fourth place in the section. But South Side Beaver gets No. 10, for the simple reason that Laurel and Shenango get seeds No. 5 and 6. South Side Beaver is in the same section as those two and the WPIAL won’t match section foes against each other in the first round.

WPIAL CLASS 1A

Advertise with us

Byes: Vincentian, Cornell, Bishop Canevin.

Matchups: Clairton (8) vs. Eden Christian (9), winner to play Vincentian (1); Monessen (7) vs. Union (10), winner to play Cornell (2); Imani Christian (6) vs. Geibel (11), winner to play Bishop Canevin (3); West Greene (13) vs. Greensburg Central Catholic (4); Nazareth Prep (5) vs. Leechburg (12).

The scoop: Cornell is a second-place team in Section 1, but most definitely worthy of the No. 2 seed, especially after beating Vincentian, 66-57, on Friday. … Three teams from Section 1 are in the top five seeds – Vincentian, Cornell and Nazareth Prep. A good quarterfinal matchup would be Nazareth Prep vs. Greensburg Central Catholic, and also Imani Christian vs. Bishop Canevin.

Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh