Move a freshman up to the varsity team and put that athlete into the varsity starting lineup? Sure. When pigs fly.

That used to be the thinking for generations of high school sports. Heck, legendary former Blackhawk High boys basketball coach John Miller remembers wanting to move this freshman stud, Dante Calabria, up to the varsity team in the late 1980s, but the school actually had a rule against putting freshmen on varsity.

But high school sports have changed in a lot of ways over the past couple decades and one of the biggest changes is the proliferation of freshman athletes who are showing up as starters on varsity teams and sometimes having a big effect — in many different sports.

It’s not Generation X that is impacting high school sports more. It’s Generation Fresh.

Advertise with us

“Kids in school today laugh when I talk to them about this,” said Miller, who now coaches girls high school AAU basketball and also the freshman boys team at North Allegheny. “I tell them that it used to be a lot of kids, even if they were pretty good, didn’t start varsity until maybe their senior year. That’s just the way it was.”

Not now. Ninth-graders having impacts is not just a Western Pa. thing. It’s across the country and it’s evident in many sports. But freshmen seem to have bigger impacts in sports such as basketball (especially girls), soccer, baseball and softball. It seems everywhere you turn this basketball season in the WPIAL — at bigger and smaller schools — there are fresh faces having big effects on court proceedings.

Coaches, from high school to college, believe the onslaught of freshmen athletes is due to a few reasons. One of them is that some pre-teenagers specialize in a sport at a young age and play it so much — sometimes year-round — that they are more prepared and more skilled to have an impact as a freshman.

More on that later, but consider this “fresh produce” on the WPIAL girls basketball side:

• Indiana’s Eve Fiala is averaging 17.3 points a game and has a scholarship offer already from Ohio State.

Advertise with us

• Jasmine Timmerson is in the starting lineup at North Allegheny, a large school and one of the best teams in the WPIAL. She is averaging 7 points, 4.4 rebounds, 3.2 assists and 2.6 steals a game. Duquesne and Michigan State offered her scholarships before she played a game as a freshman.

• Oakland Catholic is 8-2 and freshman Rachel Haver averages 14.6 points while fellow ninth-grader Alexa Washington also is having an impact.

• Freedom is 8-1 and Julia Mohrbacher averages 15.3 points.

• Pine-Richland’s Kaili Doctor, also an excellent volleyball player, averages 12 points and 8 rebounds.

• Upper St. Clair starts three freshmen and started four in one game. The Panthers have a 6-3 record.

Advertise with us

• Laurel starts three freshmen. The Spartans are 4-1 in Class 2A section play and ninth-grader Regan Atkins averages 13.5 points.

Calabria, by the way, became a star at Blackhawk as a sophomore and went on to play on two Final Four teams at the University of North Carolina. As for now, among some prominent freshmen in WPIAL boys basketball:

• Laurel Highlands’ Rodney Gallagher is averaging more than 20 points a game and is being called a freshman phenom. He already has scholarship offers from Illinois and Rhode Island.

• Aquinas Academy is a small school that is 2-7 in WPIAL Class 1A, but Vince Cugeni is having a terrific season, averaging 30 points a game.

Jonna Burke has been a girls basketball head coach for 25 years at Butler and Bethel Park and has noticed the freshmen fad. She estimates that she has had around 10 freshmen start for her in her career, including a few in recent years. Burke also was a standout player at Bethel Park (1990 graduate and the school’s all-time leading scorer) who went on to have a fine career at Pitt.

Advertise with us

“Something that is funny — and I don’t bring it up — is that I did not play even JV basketball when I was a freshman (at Bethel Park). I was on the freshman team,” Burke said with a laugh. “I feel like I was kind of part of the last generation that was that way. Now, we don’t even have freshman girls teams in the WPIAL. None. They’re all with the JV and varsity.

“Over the years, I’ve been fortunate to have skilled kids who have made impacts as freshmen. I’ve always kind of been of the mindset that if you’re good enough to play, I don’t care what year you are.”

But it’s not just WPIAL basketball where freshmen are having impacts. Just consider some of these ninth-graders in the past year or so who have done rather noteworthy things:

• This past football season, East Allegheny’s Johnny DiNapoli set a WPIAL freshman passing record with 1,728 yards.

• Last May, Seton LaSalle’s Drew Lafferty was the winning pitcher in a WPIAL baseball championship and finished the season with an 8-1 record. Seton LaSalle started four freshmen in the title game. Lafferty committed to the University of Kentucky before he played as a freshman.

Advertise with us

• Cole Young was the starting shortstop and leading hitter for a North Allegheny team that made the WPIAL and PIAA Class 6A semifinals. Young committed to Duke in October of his freshman year.

• In the 2018 soccer season, Jayden Sharpless was a freshman on the Freedom girls soccer team and led the WPIAL in goals with 64.

• In the 2018-19 basketball season, freshmen Journey Thompson of Peters Township and Aislin Malcolm were starters and played key roles in their teams finishing with undefeated records and winning WPIAL and PIAA titles.

Those are just recent examples of freshman influences. In the olden days of high school sports, all these freshmen playing would’ve seemed far-fetched. Two of the first freshmen to have big impacts in WPIAL sports were Dwight Collins at Beaver Falls as a freshman football and basketball player in 1976-77 and Bill Fralic as a football player and wrestler at Penn Hills in 1977-78. Both went on to play football at Pitt and in the NFL. But they were considered freaks of nature back then. Now, freshman athletes on varsity teams is almost commonplace.

“You see it more across the board,” said Laurel girls basketball coach Matt Stebbins, who uses five freshmen in his rotation. “We have seven freshmen overall and they’ve played together since AAU. This group has been successful all the way through and it just seems like kids play a lot younger nowadays because they are ready to play.”

Advertise with us

With the specialization of sports becoming so popular, some pre-teenagers regularly play a sport year-round, whether it’s AAU basketball, travel baseball or Cup soccer. By the time they get to high school, freshmen are more skilled because of the added experience.

Dan Burt has had much success as the women’s basketball coach at Duquesne University and he has sometimes offered scholarships to seventh- and eighth-graders.

“High school freshmen today are more sophisticated in their basketball knowledge and skills because of the youth sports industry,” Burt said. “Personal trainers, shooting coaches, AAU/club basketball, nutritionists and parents who are willing to invest financially and time-wise, allows for young people to have more options.

“Nothing beats playing pick-up against older players on the playground but the specialized training of today allows for great growth for kids at much younger ages.”

Burke has a daughter and son who have been playing in some basketball league since they were in first grade, playing on eight-foot baskets.

Advertise with us

“I didn’t play until I was in sixth grade in a rec league. We just didn’t have the opportunities to start at a young age,” Burke said.

But Burke questioned whether specializing in a sport and playing year-round at a young age is a good thing. Other coaches echoed her sentiments.

“I’m not saying it’s good or bad,” Burke said. “I just know I’ve had so many kids, and seen so many others, get ACL injuries to their knees. I don’t know what the reason is but they don’t stop playing basketball ever. When I played, I only knew one player ever who had an ACL injury.”

Get this: Pine-Richland girls basketball coach Tom Reighard has lost five players to knee injuries in the past seven months. One of the players was his daughter, Gianna, who was hurt in an AAU game last May. Another was hurt in a fall league game.

Reighard coaches AAU basketball and said, “Kids definitely get better by playing AAU, but I don’t know what it is with all these injuries.”

Advertise with us

Miller believes one of the reasons that more freshmen are getting varsity playing time in girls basketball is that fewer girls are playing basketball these days, at least in Western Pennsylvania. Some schools, even in the larger classifications, are having trouble having enough players to field a JV team. That allows more of a chance for a ninth-grader to play.

Burt also believes a societal “thing” with teenagers opens the door for more freshmen.

“Juniors and seniors are rarely three-sport athletes any more,” Burt said. “Most have specialized in one sport for at least a couple years and by the time they are juniors, if they are not getting playing time, a lot of them will call it a career and move on to other areas of life.”

In other words, freshmen on varsity teams is not a fad that will go away.

Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh