Going into the game, the big story was Mars big man Michael Carmody sitting out with a toe injury he suffered in a win against Franklin Regional Monday night.
By the end of the night, the big story was Shaler senior Mekhi Reynolds playing through an injury of his own and stealing the show with a breathtaking fourth-quarter performance.
Reynolds, who suffered a minor injury to his patellar tendon in the Titans’ loss to North Allegheny last Friday, scored 18 of his 26 points in the final quarter to single-handedly put a stop to the Planets’ comeback bid.
Senior forward Nick Rispoli chipped in 16 points as WPIAL Class 5A No. 3 Shaler (4-1, 2-0) knocked No. 1 Mars (4-1, 2-1) from the ranks of the unbeaten with a 73-62 win at home.
“I felt good about the scoring, because the past two games, we weren’t putting the ball in the hole,” Titans coach Rob Niederberger said. “We still make a lot of mistakes out there, still a lot of dumb fouls, still have got to be smarter in end-of-game situations, but it’s a big win for us.”
Carmody’s father, Planets coach Rob Carmody, said the 6-6 senior’s toe injury isn’t serious, and he simply held him out for precautionary reasons. Junior Mihali Sfanos and sophomores Zach Schlegel and Chris Dvorak led the way in Carmody’s absence with 12 points apiece.
Read More
“I don’t think our guys ever pouted or looked for excuses. They just went out and played,” Rob Carmody said. “And then if we could have just maybe made one more play or two more plays — I’m excited about what we can become.”
The teams traded runs during an action-packed opening quarter, and Shaler used a suffocating full-court press on defense to force a couple of turnovers and pull ahead. The Titans took a 22-17 lead into the second quarter, and they extended their advantage to nine at the break.
Mars’ players walked to the locker room at halftime looking a bit dejected, but Carmody made sure they came out with a purpose to start the third quarter. Slowly but surely, Mars started to chip away at Shaler’s lead, which shrunk to five by the end of the third.
That’s when Reynolds caught fire.
“When the game got close, I was like, ‘Alright, I’ve got to do something about it. I’ve got to take over,’” Reynolds said.
The 6-3 shooting guard started off the final quarter with a pair of mid-range jumpers, then knocked down a 3-pointer that sent a jolt through the crowd — and sent a message to his father in the bleachers.
“I could see my dad getting mad at me from the stands, telling me to go sit down, so I was like, ‘I’ve got to pick it up a little bit,’” Reynolds said. “I just tried to forget about the knee.”
But Reynolds wasn’t done there. He added a driving layup to give Shaler a 60-52 lead with five minutes left, then tacked on another 3-pointer for good measure to make it 67-56 with 3:30 remaining. That would turn out to be the final dagger Reynolds would deliver to lift the Titans to a monumental early-season sectional victory.
“I didn’t think he was going to play today. He was hobbling,” Niederberger said. “He’s a special player.
“I’ve said it all year — he is without a doubt one of the top 10 players in the WPIAL.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.