One night after his team lost its first game of the season to its neighboring rival, Upper St. Clair coach Danny Holzer was worried about his team’s spirits. He had concerns about his players having tired legs.

But Upper St. Clair didn’t just bounce back impressively. They did it shockingly.

Upper St. Clair pulled off one of the bigger surprises of the season, knocking off City League power Allderdice, 58-51, in a non-league game Wednesday night at Upper St. Clair. And get this: The Panthers won with their leading scorer being held to five points.

Now will someone please pinch Holzer so he knows this was for real. Upper St. Clair (14-1) lost to Mt. Lebanon Tuesday night in an emotionally charged game in front of a packed house.

Advertise with us

“This is hard to believe after the Mt. Lebanon game. But we actually had a hop in our step,” said Holzer. “I’m so proud of my kids and the character they showed after that Mt. Lebanon game. For us to have a hop in our step after that game, it’s amazing to me. But that’s why basketball, regardless of the level, can be a crazy game. But that’s also what makes it so fun.”

Holzer has been Upper St. Clair’s coach for 24 seasons, has 396 wins and two WPIAL titles. He classified beating Allderdice as “maybe the biggest non-section win since I’ve been here. Just because of who Allderdice is.”

Allderdice (11-3) is the five-time City League champion and many thought they might be the best team in the WPIAL or City League this season. Their previous two losses were to Lower Merion near Philadelphia and Christian Brothers (N.J.). Allderdice has talent, size and swagger. The Dragons had already proven to be well above some top WPIAL teams by beating Latrobe by 29 points and Butler by 32 earlier this season. Latrobe is the Post-Gazette’s No. 1 WPIAL 6A team and Butler No. 5.

“Think about it. They beat Latrobe and Butler by about 30, and we beat them,” said Holzer.

Upper St. Clair’s Tanner Gensler, a 6-foot-4 senior forward who averages 21 points, was held to five. But Upper St. Clair got 28 points from senior guard Chris Pantelis, who also made five 3-pointers. Upper St. Clair made nine 3-pointers one night after making only 3 of 12 against Mt. Lebanon.

Advertise with us

Jackson Blaufeld, a senior guard and a Dartmouth recruit, led Allderdice with 19 points. Senior guard Bobby Clifford, the team’s second-leading scorer, was held to seven.

“We met early before the game, earlier than we usually do,” said Holzer. “We talked about how this game will show us what we’re made of. We just said we had to compete at a high level and believe in one another.”

Allderdice had a size advantage against Upper St. Clair, but it didn’t matter much. Holzer said Upper St. Clair played well against Allderdice’s 1-2-2 and 1-3-1 zones.

“We didn’t slow it down or anything,” said Holzer. “We just played half court man to man and kept people in front of us. They struggled to make shots and we rebounded. I think as the game went on we continued to get more confident.”

Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh