The Shaler boys basketball team, owners of six consecutive losing seasons, have the words “Our Time” printed on the back of their warmups. And early in the third quarter Wednesday night, it looked it might indeed Shaler’s time to rumble the world of WPIAL Class 5A basketball.

On the road and leading a defending WPIAL champ by a few baskets, Shaler seemed in good position for that statement win. Then Mars turned to a young one, who handed the baton to an old one. Next thing you know, the kings of Class 5A had another win, thanks to freshman Zac Schlegel and senior Andrew Recchia.

Mars defeated Shaler, 68-62, in a 5A Section 3 game that stretched the Planets’ WPIAL winning streak to 13 games, dating back to last season. Mars, the Post-Gazette’s No. 1 WPIAL 5A team, is now 8-1 overall and 3-0 in section play.

Shaler, off to its best start since the 2011-12 season, dropped to 7-3 and 2-1. The Titans, who played previously in Class 6A, proved it can play toe-to-toe against the best in Class 5A. But beating the best and getting over the hump can be the hardest part.

Advertise with us

“We have to learn how to close out games better,” said Shaler coach Rob Niedeberger. “I think we really believed we should’ve beaten them. We’re used to playing teams like Pine-Richland with Phil Jurkovec the past couple years. So no one is intimidating to us. We’ve been grinding for three years now. We feel like it’s our time.”

But it turned out to be Schlegel and Recchia’s time on Wednesday. Schelegel, a ninth-grade guard who averages five points, came off the bench to score 12, including 10 in the third quarter when Mars forged ahead. He hit two 3-pointers and had a steal for a basket that gave Mars a 47-43 lead.

Recchia, a starting guard since his sophomore year, took care of things the rest of the way. He scored 21 of his game-high 27 points in the second half and made 7 of 11 shots in the final two quarters.

“It’s like when your phone goes dead and you have to plug it back in,” said Mars coach Rob Carmody. “Andrew had to plug his phone back in so he could get going in the second half.”

Shaler trailed by only 63-62 when junior guard Mekhi Reynolds, who scored a team-high 19 points, missed a 3-pointer. On its next two possessions, Shaler missed a short shot and turned the ball over. Recchia made 5 of 6 free throws in the final 1:02 to clinch the game.

Advertise with us

Mars also got 15 points from senior guard Khori Fusco and 6-foot-7, 295-pound junior center Michael Carmody, son of the coach, added 11 points and 11 rebounds.

Last year’s team featured Robby Carmody, oldest son of the coach. Robby is now a freshman player at Notre Dame, but his season ended recently after shoulder surgery. Robby Carmody was in the stands for the Shaler game.

“We have a different dynamic than last year,” said Rob Carmody, the coach. “We did a lot of gritty, tough, hard-nosed things in this game, which is great. But we have to be a lot smarter if we want to continue going far this year.”

Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh