In a WPIAL championship, you expect star players to dominate.

When stars can’t dominate, though, good teams still find a way to win, and that’s what Mars did last year when Robby Carmody, 2017’s Pennsylvania Gatorade Player of the Year who finished his career at No. 7 on the WPIAL all-time scoring list (2,390 points), was sick and had one of his worst games of the season on one of the biggest stages.

Carmody, now at Notre Dame, scored 11 points (22 below his average) in Mars’ WPIAL Class 5A title win against Franklin Regional, but the Planets got contributions from a handful of other players and pulled away for the program’s first WPIAL championship.

Losing Carmody is no doubt a hit, but the Planets return three starters this year and are joined by Khori Fusco, who transferred from Clairton, and are off to a 4-0 start after beating Franklin Regional in a rematch of last year’s WPIAL championship. They may have lost a Carmody, but they’ve still got two more (dad and coach Rob and 6-6 junior forward Michael) and have a committee of weapons paving the way for another strong season.

Advertise with us

“If you watch the arc of our team last year, early in the season, I think Robby had three 40-point games in the first five or six basketball games, and as the season went along, not that he still wasn’t scoring, but it was other guys,” Rob Carmody said. “I look back to the WPIAL championship game.”

Mars plays with four guards moving on the floor with a big guy to base it around, and Fusco has fit into that well, starting his Mars career off strong by leading the team with 18.5 points per game and 4.8 assists per game, to go with 6.5 rebounds per game through Tuesday.

Senior guard Andrew Recchia, a Shippensburg recruit, averages 18.3 points with 4 assists per game, senior guard Brandon Caruso adds 7.5 points and 4.3 assists and Michael Carmody (who has football scholarship offers from Pitt and Penn State, among others, as an offensive tackle) is averaging a double-double with 11.8 points and 12.3 rebounds.

To Recchia, the Planets have more of a balanced attack this year. It’s also harder for teams to know exactly what their plan is in a tight game.

“[Robby] was averaging what, 31 a game?” Recchia said. “So you definitely have to change the way you play, but myself, Brandon [Caruso], Mike [Carmody], Joey [Craska], and then the new kid Khori, we’re all capable of doing those things. It was just a lot easier with Robby, because, you get in trouble, you throw it to Robby and he’ll do something great. But the pressure falls more on us as a team. It gives us a more balanced attack. If I’m not having a good game, Brandon’s going to step up or Khori’s going to step up.”

Advertise with us

Of course, while Mars is off to a great start, it’s a small sample size. As the season continues, Rob Carmody will look for the experience of last year’s long season to pay off — the Planets played games from early December until late March, losing in the PIAA Class 5A final to Abington Heights.

The Planets also lost Cade Hetzler, who combined with Robby to give Mars a physical edge. Hetzler took four charges to help Mars win a PIAA semifinal last year, and even when Robby wasn’t at his best in the WPIAL championship, he pulled in 14 rebounds and blocked a few shots.

The Planets are a skilled team, but that’s an area they could improve on, per Rob Carmody.

“Last year, every time we walked on the floor, those two guys gave us such good toughness,” Rob Carmody said.

Sarah K. Spencer: sspencer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @sarah_k_spence.