Two WPIAL basketball players who made all-section last season as sophomores are changing schools.

Isaiah Smith and Isaac DeGregorio both recently decided to leave teams where they enjoyed individual success. But whether they will be eligible at their new schools is a matter yet to be decided by the WPIAL.

Smith, a 6-foot guard who will be a junior, has left Sewickley Academy and will attend Lincoln Park, a charter school in Midland. Smith’s transfer has been rumored for a while, and he announced his change of schools Saturday on Twitter. Smith has been a contributor to two WPIAL Class 2A championship teams and last season averaged 16 points a game. Sewickley Academy also won the PIAA when he was a freshman.

DeGregorio, a 5-foot-10 guard, will transfer from Hampton to Cardinal Wuerl North Catholic in Cranberry, where his father, Dave, will be in his first year as coach. Dave DeGregorio, former coach at North Allegheny, had been an assistant at Hampton the past two seasons. Isaac DeGregorio averaged 14.2 points a game last season for a team that made the WPIAL and PIAA playoffs. His brother, Owen, a sophomore, also is transferring to North Catholic.

Advertise with us

Their reasons for the transfers are different. Smith said on Twitter that he is leaving Sewickley Academy because of “financial hardship and educational struggles” at the private school. Win Palmer, Sewickley Academy’s coach and athletic director, said he couldn’t comment on whether Sewickley Academy will “sign off” on Smith’s transfer because he has to speak with school administrators.

It’s hard to fathom the DeGregorios going to North Catholic if their father wasn’t named coach and it’s hard to predict their eligibility. In previous cases where a son follows his father who coaches at a different school, the WPIAL has ruled the son sometimes eligible — and sometimes ineligible. A key will be whether Hampton “signs off” on the transfer. Hampton athletic director Bill Cardone declined comment until the school reviews transfer paper work.

The transfers of Smith and DeGregorio come at an interesting time because of a possible new PIAA rule concerning transfers, and because of the current debate over athletics at public and private/Catholic/charter schools.

The PIAA is considering a new rule that will make all student-athletes ineligible for postseason play if they transfer schools any time after the start of ninth grade. The PIAA, however, won’t decide on whether to pass the new rule until next month. PIAA executive director Bob Lombardi said the new rule won’t affect transfers made before the rule is passed. Plus, there will be exceptions made for some transfers to be eligible.

As for the public-private debate, many superintendents in Pennsylvania are calling for the PIAA to establish separate postseason tournaments for public schools and private/Catholic/charter schools. They claim private/Catholic/charter schools have a competitive advantage because they have no geographic boundaries for students, while public schools can only take students who live in their districts.

Advertise with us

The Smith and DeGregorio cases are examples of what irks the public schools who feel the transfers are for athletic reasons. Their transfers are also coincidental in timing. The Pennsylvania Athletic Oversight Committee, which oversees the PIAA, held a public hearing Monday in Harrisburg to discuss the idea of separate championships for public and private schools, as well as the PIAA’s proposed new transfer rule.

Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh.