The WPIAL sent an email survey to all of its member schools Monday morning, seeking thoughts on possible separate playoff tournaments for public and private/Catholic/charter schools.
In case you wanted to know what was asked, we’ve got the six-pack of questions.
The WPIAL “strongly recommended” that the school superintendent, principal and athletic director all be involved in formulating opinions for the survey. The WPIAL decided recently to send out the survey after increasing complaints of competitive advantages for schools that don’t have geographic boundaries. Private/Catholic/charter schools can draw students from anywhere while public schools can only take students that reside in their geographical boundaries.
The PIAA is receiving more complaints about the public vs. private school issue. More and more coaches, athletic directors and superintendents are calling for the PIAA to address the issue and possibly make separate playoff tournaments for boundary and non-boundary schools.
A group of 27 superintendents (Intermediate Unit IV) from school districts in Butler, Lawrence and Mercer Counties recently met and expressed a desire for the PIAA to examine separate tournaments, and that was the impetus for the WPIAL to send the survey to its schools. The WPIAL, which is part of the PIAA, asked all surveys to be returned by Friday.
Here are the questions:
Read More
- As a school district, we believe schools without geographical boundaries have a competitive advantage over schools with established geographical boundaries (Yes or No):
- Do you feel the competitive advantage is related to both team and individual sports, or simply to team sports?
- Do you feel the existing PIAA Transfer Rule, PIAA By-Law Article VI, Transfer, Residence, and Recruiting, is functionally effective in controlling transfers that might result in a competitive advantage (Why or Why Not)?
- Attempting to create competitive balance, would you be in favor of separate tournaments for schools that have established geographical boundaries and for schools without geographical boundaries?
- Would you favor a separated tournament for only team sports or both team and individual sports offerings?
- Does your district favor an expanded classification approach for ALL SPORTS, to include those with an individual component, or are you satisfied with the expanded classification approach being applied to team sports only?






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.