HERSHEY, Pa. — If you’re a high school athlete thinking about transferring schools after your junior year, you might want to think again. The PIAA is thinking about passing a rule that would make you ineligible for playoff competitions.
The PIAA is considering taking a step, however small it might be, that would deter some students from transferring schools for athletic reasons. In May, the PIAA board of directors will vote on a proposal that any student who transfers schools at any time after their junior year will automatically be ineligible for postseason games at their new school during their senior year. They can play during the regular season, but not in district or PIAA playoffs. The WPIAL is District 7 in the PIAA.
The proposed rule comes from the PIAA competition committee that was formed a year ago to look at competitive imbalances in Pennsylvania high school sports and also to look at possibly coming up with a new transfer rule. The competition committee, made up of one representative from all 12 districts in the state, met Tuesday in Hershey and came up with the proposal.
A proposal must pass three readings to become part of the PIAA by-laws. But PIAA executive director Bob Lombardi said the PIAA board could suspend protocol and pass the rule after one or two readings. That way, it would go into effect for the 2018-19 school year. The PIAA board of directors often passes recommendations from the competition committee.
“There was a feeling around the competition committee that there are a lot of senior transfers and that is an issue they wanted to look at first,” Lombardi said.
It was suggested to Lombardi that loads of student-athletes transfer for athletic reasons after their freshman and sophomore years, and this is simply a Band-Aid on a much bigger problem. For example, Kennedy Catholic in Hermitage has a powerhouse basketball team that easily won the PIAA Class 1A basketball title Monday. Kennedy has players who transferred there before their senior years. This new rule would not have stopped those transfers.
Read More
Lombardi said he actually favors a rule that would anyone make ineligible for postseason competitions if they transfer any time after their sophomore year.
“But the competition committee felt it’s more of a senior problem, so let’s at least start there,” Lombardi said. “The [PIAA] board is aware of the critics. I think this has been in the pipeline since the committee was formed last year. The committee is trying to get the transfer rule to address the competitive fairness and inequity.”
Another big issue is that the PIAA’s transfer rule is enforced differently in districts around the state. Transferring is rampant at Philadelphia Public and Catholic League schools (District 12), and those schools are starting to dominate the PIAA basketball championships. While District 12 officials make the transfers eligible, the WPIAL tries to take a stand against transfers for athletic intent.
But the biggest issue surrounding transfers these days in high school sports around Pennsylvania is the public vs. private/Catholic/charter school debate. Public schools have geographic boundaries for students. But private/Catholic/charter schools have no geographic boundaries. The issue seems to get bigger by the year.
“If your question is are you looking at separating public and private schools? The answer is no,” Lombardi said. “The Pennsylvania General Assembly has told us that schools of choice are important to them. We are not going to take on the General Assembly. We’ll follow the law. If they want to change it, we’ll follow it.
“There is not a simple fix to all of this because there are so many tentacles to it. … I talk to other states about their transfer rule and they don’t have an answer, either. It’s not a simple fix, but I think we can eventually fix it. The thing is, nobody cares about any transfers until their team wins.”
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.