HERSHEY, Pa. — Robby Carmody sat on the bench, trying to console other Mars players in the final minute of the game after fouling out. But he couldn’t hold back the tears, either.

He was done for the night. His fabulous career was over. So was Mars’ hopes of a state championship.

Mars lost to Abington Heights, 67-55, in the PIAA Class 5A title game Tuesday night at Giant Center, giving a sad ending to a great performance by Carmody — and a superb career.

Mars (25-5) had a one-point halftime lead and Carmody was tremendous in the second half, scoring Mars’ first 24 points of the half. He scored 27 of the Planets’ 30 points in the second half. Carmody, a senior guard headed to Notre Dame, finished with 34.

Advertise with us

Carmody and his brother, Mike, a sophomore forward who also fouled out, had a long, emotional embrace on the bench late in the game. Their father, Rob, is Mars’ coach.

“This remains a paperback book,” Coach Carmody said. “Had we won a state championship, they might have turned it into a movie.”

Abington Heights beat Mars 67-55 in the PIAA class 5A championship

Instead, one of the winningest coaches in state history finally won a PIAA title at Abington Heights. For Ken Bianchi, it was win No. 774. Abington Heights (26-4), a District 2 school located near Scranton, got a big performance from 6-foot-5 junior forward George Tinsley, who scored 29 points and went over 1,000 for his career. Tinsley made 11 of 14 shots from the field.

Tinsley led four players in double figures. Junior guard Jack Nealon had 13 while 6-6 senior forward Jackson Danzig and 6-1 sophomore guard Corey Perkins had 11 each. Carmody was the only Mars player in double figures. He made 10 of 17 shots, 12 of 15 free throws and grabbed eight rebounds.

“I think in the third quarter only one guy scored for us and that’s not good. That’s not going to win you a state championship,” Rob Carmody said.

Advertise with us

Mars led at halftime, 25-24. Mars had some balance against Abington Heights’ matchup zone defense as Carmody had only seven points in the first two quarters. Mars junior guard Andrew Recchia hit three 3-pointers and scored all nine of his points in the first half.

But Abington Heights took the lead for good early in the third quarter and never gave it back. Mars pulled within 39-38 in the fourth quarter, but Abington Heights went ahead, 46-38, early in the fourth. Carmody put Mars on his back, but the Planets couldn’t overtake the more balanced Comets.

“I think Robby sensed that I better go now,” the elder Carmody said. “You’ve poured your heart and soul into this program and now this is it. This is the last time you’re putting on that uniform and I think he just said, ‘I’m going to go and try to will this thing. Hopefully, someone can knock a shot down and get everyone going.’ Unfortunately, that didn’t happen.”

Carmody’s 34 points gave him 2,390 points, good for seventh place on the WPIAL all-time scoring list. In the game, Carmody passed legendary former Wampum player Don Hennon, who played in the 1950s before going to be an All-American at Pitt.

Carmody had only one 3-pointer in the second half. Carmody, who stands 6-4, used his strength to get to the basket numerous times and had three, three-point plays in the final two quarters. He consistently beat double-teams to score.

Advertise with us

“The first half, they kind of keyed on me a little more and our guys were stepping up and making shots,” the younger Carmody said. “In the second half, I had more room to drive and make plays. I just took the plays that were there.”

Carmody didn’t place any blame on his teammates. After the game, he went to the bottom of the stands and hugged numerous family members and fans.

“We just didn’t get enough shots to fall as a team and that’s all it was,” Robby Carmody said. “I’ve grown up with all these guys. It’s been a special ride. It’s just sad to see it over.”

Notre Dame assistant coach Ryan Ayers was one of the people who hugged Carmody.

“I’m not going to say I never saw a guy like that, but Notre Dame knew what they were doing,” Bianchi said. “They made a good move and they’re going to be happy about it. He’s strong and that’s what makes him above everybody else. We’ve played outstanding shooters and really, really quick guards who got by us. But the combination of the two is what’s tough to handle.”

Advertise with us

Carmody also had more than 1,000 rebounds in his career. The Planets won 91 games in his four years as a starter.

His father was philosophical after the game.

“All eight of our seniors have gone to school together since kindergarten,” Coach Carmody said. “They have a 3.825 grade-point average between them. How could I not be proud? At Mars? Think about it. Two state championship games in three years. A WPIAL championship. Don’t tell me this can’t be done in a small town.”

Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh.