The Post-Gazette surveyed every boys and girls basketball coach in the WPIAL and City League to ask if they thought a shot clock should be used in Pennsylvania high school basketball. A total of 117 coaches (64 boys and 53 girls) responded to the survey and 71 percent said they would like to see a shot clock instituted.

Here are some comments from coaches who are for and against a shot clock:

FOR A SHOT CLOCK

Daryn Freedman, Gateway boys coach: We used a shot clock when I was at Kiski [School] and it made games better. It forces teams to run offense and gives the players more chances to score. For the coaches that say there will be shot clock violations, we had less than 10 total per season and at least half of our games were shot clock. Plus it helps prepare the players for college.

Advertise with us

Todd Aiken, Eden Christian boys coach: So many of us as coaches run offensive sets that mirror college basketball and even some NBA sets. The shot clock would reinforce these offensive sets. Additionally, the use of a shot clock would mean that the skills at the high school to college level would be transferable.

Steve Lodovico, Blackhawk girls coach: I’m for anything to make the game faster and more entertaining for the players and fans. It will allow the players to become comfortable and have a better understanding of the importance of each possession at the next level. It will challenge coaches to prepare differently for each possession and force us to come up with different strategies as the possession ends.

Shea Fleenor, Albert Gallatin boys coach: We play fast so it wouldn’t affect us. I would like to see it. It is used at all levels above high school, so why not? I can’t imagine too many kids can enjoy playing in situations where a final score is 35-34 and there are limited shots for everyone. It also allows teams in close games to ensure they are getting the ball back without necessarily having to foul. It would make a lot of coaches have to learn how to manage end of the game situations differently which could also make it more fun for coaches.

Jordan Marks, Winchester Thurston boys coach: The WPIAL is getting better, but we need to prevent the best kids from leaving. We need to improve the level of play and amount of scoring, and a shot clock should help.

Mark John, Laurel Highlands girls coach: I think it would certainly speed the game’s tempo. As a collegiate men's coach for seven years, I enjoyed practicing with and using a shot clock.

Advertise with us

Joe Eisaman, Greensburg Central Catholic girls coach: Holding the ball in a playoff game takes the game out of the kids hands and is sometimes decided by coaches. Isn’t that why kids play the game, to compete? Let them compete.

Mark Maier, Butler girls coach: When the biggest objection to having a shot clock is the cost, I think the powers will figure out a way to make it happen. Maybe get a sponsorship from a company to donate them, and have their name on them.

William Tyler Johnson, Derry girls coach: We are not preparing the student athletes for college where there is a shot clock. We allow people to just hold the ball and waste time and it allows coaches to not teach kids how to score. Not having a shot clock makes high school basketball slow and hard to watch.

Jeff Ackerman, Pine-Richland boys coach: I think 35 seconds would be great. The game would be faster which is how the game is meant to be played.

Chuck Crummie, Central Catholic boys coach: Yes, I’d like to see it. I have been told cost and available space has been the holdup.

Advertise with us

AGAINST A SHOT CLOCK

Greg Hutcherson, Armstrong boys coach: I would not be for a shot clock. I get why people would want it to make the game more faster and uptempo. But for teams like us, it does not help us. We are a slowdown, grind-it-out team that strives to make teams play our style of ball.

Bill Swan, Hempfield boys coach: I like the strategy of “running clock” and the advantage no shot clock gives to the underdog.

Gary Kacsur, Fort Cherry girls coach: No shot clock. Keep smaller schools in the game.

Jeff Homziak, Hopewell girls coach: School districts are struggling to purchase textbooks and technology and some have already instituted pay-to-play, so adding additional costs for shot clocks that taxpayers have the burden of funding, would not be advantageous for any district.

Advertise with us

Frank Muccino, Southmoreland boys coach: I don’t think kids are skilled enough to play with a shot clock. If they implement one, I think a 40-second clock would be best.

Dave Wilson, South Side Beaver girls coach: If all playing fields were level I would definitely be for a shot clock. I believe a way of countering a more talented team is controlling the ball. Most public schools do not have the luxury of talented players lining up at the door.

Andy Hedrick, Connellsville boys coach: For the most part, the game is played faster than the shot clock. I think using more time is a strategy that takes skill, much like controlling time of possession in football.

Mark Walsh, Seton LaSalle: I would have to say no only because I like how the game is played now.

NOT FOR OR AGAINST A SHOT CLOCK

Zach Skrinjar, Fox Chapel boys coach: To me it wouldn’t matter either way, but I really see no reason for it due to the fact that the majority of the teams that I have seen play already shoot the ball within 20-25 seconds of their possessions.