Mike White: How goes it, everyone? Welcome. WPIAL basketball playoffs first round finish tomorrow night. Quarterfinals start Thursday. Some other happenings in high school. If you have any questions, we are now open for business.
Guest: Mike is there a schedule for the games next weekend at Peterson Events Center ? Where can it be found ?
Mike White: No it has not been decided exactly who will play what day. But there are three games Thursday, four Friday and five Saturday. Semifinals are Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday. Obviously, people who play Wednesday won’t play until Saturday. Semifinalists playing Monday will likely play Thursday and one Friday.
Mike White: First round of playoffs continue tonight. Tomorrow night, pretty decent doubleheader for boys at N. Allegheny. Baldwin vs. Butler at 6:30 and North Hills-Upper St. Clair at 8.
Mike White: What else is going on? A little bit of basketball recruiting, as far as visits. Mars’ Robby Carmody visited Purdue Saturday for game and Butler Sunday for a game. Purdue has already offered. I think they have a decent shot. I think they will be one of his five or six finalists.
Guest: How good is the big kids from Moon ?
Read More
Mike White: You mean the big “kid.” Only one. Jarrod Simmons, about 6-7. Committed to Penn of Ivy League. Definitely good. Kind of floats around at times and isn’t dominant. Then other times, he can take over. See him maybe as a “4” or “3” at Penn. Has made a huge difference in Moon. Team didn’t make playoffs last year. They are No. 2 seed in 5A this year.
Guest: Mike How are the kids from the big 33 Game selected ? Is this All Seniors ? Congrats to Greg Botta coach of Franklin Regional well deserved choice for coach
Mike White: Big 33 is now controlled by the Pa. Football Coaches Association. The Big 33 organization and foundation recently folded. The coaches association pick the players and yes only seniors are eligible.
The game has lost a lot of its luster the past 7-8 years. With freshmen players starting college most times in June now, many good players over the years have chosen not to participate. This year, some good players again are not participating, for various reasons. Like Lamont Wade. He is not participating.
This game certainly not what it used to be, but I give coaches association credit for trying to keep it going. I think the fear of injury is also a factor.
Guest from the City: What do you think was the biggest upset over the weekend, boys or girls?
Mike White: Oh, I don’t know. I didn’t really see anything major.
Guest from the City: Gotcha.... Will Allderdice play a WPIAL squad in the state playoffs next or another part of the state next? Does anyone else qualify for the states from the city league?
Mike White: Allderdice plays McDowell Friday at Carrick in a PIAA play in game. Westinghouse and Obama boys also will be in play in games but don’t play until next week.
Guest: Mike did you get to see the Boys City League Final between Obama and Dice Great Game ?
Mike White: I did not. Great finish. 3 OTs. I heard first three quarters were ragged, but the finishes were terrific.
JLG: You see anyone from the WPIAL competing with Kennedy Catholic boys?
Mike White: They are very, very good again. They beat Sewickley by seven and Lincoln Park by 11. Obviously, they will be tough to beat. Latrobe beat them but Latrobe is 6A. Kennedy will be tough to beat.
Bob: Mike, just an FYI, the brackets on the WPIAL Site do have the dates and times for championships. Ex 5A Boys Fri March 3 at 9pm, 5A Girls Sat March 4 at 3pm
Mike White: Yep you are right. And three games Thursday, four Friday and five Saturday.
Guest: Who do you like in 5A??
Mike White: 5A field is really good. Or should I say really balanced. Mars No. 1 seed, Moon No. 2, Char Valley 3 and McKeesport 4. Heck, Highlands was highly thought of at beginning of year and they are down around 8-9 seed.
I picked Mars at start of playoffs. They certainly are not overwhelming choice. I think it helps in playoffs to have a stud guard and they have that in Robby Carmody.
But I really don’t see any 5A WPIAL team having much of a chance at a state title.
guest: What do you think will happen in the Wpial decision regarding Tomlin and Porters kids?
Mike White: Tough call. Would be curious to know what reasons they are giving for transferring. They have to be saying academics. I think if WPIAL really wants to be fair, they need to bring them all in for hearings. I mean what does it say when all of them transfer after Gildon is fired and new coach is hired??? WPIAL is in a tough spot here. But to me, they need to do right thing and at least have hearings. It irks me these people who say all kids should be eligible to play if they transfer. Please. That’s ridiculous. It’s not open enrollment. There are rules. You can debate the rules, but that’s another whole matter. I love the people who say kids have a right to go to school wherever they want. They most certainly do. But you do not have the “right” to play sports. That is a privilege and if a governing body feels you are breaking the rules, then they have the right to make you ineligible.
Guest: Much has been made about Tomlin, porter transferring from CWNC but nothing about Will Gipson who started the year on the CWnC team and now starts for Aliquippa. Any thoughts on why that was approved so quickly?
Mike White: I don’t know the reasons he went back to Aliquippa. That was never made public. That is the thing. Most of these hearings and eligibility decisions are not open to the media. Maybe Gipson claimed some kind of problems at North??? I don’t know. But the whole thing has been strange. His father is the Aliquippa principal. Just odd when you’re father is the principal, but you leave the school and then return. His father also is on WPIAL board. I’m just sayin. I don’t know reasons he went back to Aliquippa.
Guest: you said Highlands has dropped, I see they could match up with Mars in the next round, what are your thoughts on them?
Mike White: On Highlands? Dangerous team. Obviously they have talent. Just had some rough times this year. They were in 3A finals last year.
Fan22: Mike do you think anyone can beat New Castle in 4A
Mike White: Of course someone can. Quaker Valley already has beaten New Castle. Beaver Falls gave them a game. Yes, New Castle is good and might win it, but certainly not unbeatable
JLG: Was there anything more written about the behavior, etc from Mike Tomlin & Joey Porter at the CWNC football games? Any retraction or denial?
Mike White: Nothing more than story I did few weeks ago. Don’t think you’ll ever hear anything from Steeler coaches.
Guest from the City: who does new castle play the winner of? can anyone outside sect 2 compete with them for the 4A title?
Mike White: New Castle got a bye and plays winner of McGuffey and Valley.
guest: Do you think there will be much basketball coaching turnover after the season. Some of the new sections were not kind to coaches and teams this year.
Mike White: There is always some turnover. I kind of disagree on the new sections. They were very kind to a number of other teams. Gave more teams a chance to be competitive.
guest: WPIAL isn’t blind. They left cause gildon got fired. That’s there boy. They shouldn’t be allowed to play but just cause its the steelers.. WPIAL will allow them to play
Mike White: I think this is one of the most interesting eligibility cases in a while. Will be interesting to see what happens in next month. WPIAL is in interesting spot. Remember, they have good working relationship with Steelers and Heinz Field.
6A Fan: Mike, will the 4 teams with bye’s get a game close to home? Or will they meet in the middle? It’s the least they can do for making them sit for 2 weeks...
Mike White: Don’t know. WPIAL tries to work with gyms available. Doesn’t always make sense but it’s not perfect science.
Guest: Mike If an athlete physically changes residences they should be immediately eligible and if they just change schools they should be ineligible for one year ....how hard is that rule ? That was a rule at some point in time and then people sued .....the whole Transfer Situation is a mess and always has been .......people like to have rules that suit them ? Governing Body (WPIAL or PIHL or PIAA) should stand up to these people and let them sue and not back down
Mike White: If an athlete physically moves there is presumptive eligibility. But you can’t say they should always be eligible. What if they were recruited?? What if they moved just to play for a coach??? For your other point, I think you are talking about private/parochial schools. Well what if a kid goes to a Catholic school and is an athlete, but not a great athlete? What if he doesn’t like the Catholic school for legitimate reasons? What if his family doesn’t feel like shelling out thousands of dollars any more? I would think it would be OK for the kid to go back to the public school where he resides. It’s hard to make blanket statements with this subject. It’s really a case by case basis. But I agree, the transfer thing is a mess. One of the biggest problems is the PIAA really doesn’t seem like it wants to change anything and it’s a totally different world in the Philadelphia area. At least the WPIAL tries to take a stand in some cases.
6A Fan: Which of the 4 top teams in 6A is sitting pretty? And which better be careful? Seems to be nothing easy!
Mike White: You said it. Nothing easy in 6A. I don’t think any of the top four seeds in 6A has it easy.
Mike White: Hey that’s about it for now. See you next week -- Tuesday at 11. We’ll be in the thick of the semifinals by then.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.