During a meeting of the McGuffey boys basketball booster club in the fall, members asked coach Mike Fatigante for any ideas on increasing attendance at home games. Fatigante’s answer was simple: Win more.
At McGuffey, this was pretty much a novel idea.
But strange things are going on at McGuffey these days. Go to a basketball home game and the gym is filled. Shockingly, McGuffey has suddenly turned into a big winner.
Under Fatigante, the novel idea has turned into reality. McGuffey has gone about one of the most impressive turnarounds in the WPIAL in decades. After beating Uniontown Tuesday, McGuffey is 15-2 and just about assure of going to the WPIAL playoffs. The Highlanders are no longer the Lowlanders.
McGuffey might not be a threat to win a WPIAL Class 4A title and the Highlanders certainly are not playing in a super section. But these Highlanders deserve major props. This is a program that did not win a section game a year ago, had made the WPIAL playoffs only twice in school history and had won three or fewer games 12 times in the previous 32 seasons.
McGuffey has been a major surprise, even to its fourth-year coach.
“Coming into this year, I knew we had a group that would be competitive,” said Fatigante, whose team won 16 games in the previous three seasons. “But back at Thanksgiving, if you would’ve said that we would be 15-2, I don’t think many people would’ve believed you, including myself. It’s just remarkable. This is really a special group, maybe not in terms of talent, but with high-character kids.”
McGuffey is one of the feel-good stories of this WPIAL season. Heck, when Fatigante interviewed for a teaching job at McGuffey nine years ago, he didn’t even know the school existed, despite playing basketball and baseball at WPIAL member Avonworth in the early 2000s.
“When I got out of college, this was the first place that I got an interview with a teaching position,” said Fatigante, a health and physical education teacher at McGuffey. “I ended up getting the job and I’ve been teaching here ever since.”
But Fatigante didn’t become the basketball coach until the 2013-14 season. He was an assistant at Waynesburg University for three years before taking the McGuffey job. Friends and some coaching colleagues thought he had lost his mind.
“They said McGuffey never wins in anything,” said Fatigante. “But to be able to teach and coach at the same school is a great opportunity. Plus, I knew the type of kids we had and I thought if we could get them to buy in to doing things the right way, we could turn it around. It would take time and the first couple years were very challenging. I can’t tell you how many times we were on the wrong end of the mercy rule.”
Fatigante will acknowledge this team will not “wow” anyone with size, speed or athleticism. But there is a certain chemistry that is special with this squad. Colin Chapman, a 6-2 senior, averages 17 points a game, and Trent Belleville, a 6-0 junior, averages 14.
“A lot of people have asked what are we doing different this year?” said Fatigante. “The truth is nothing. The effort is the same, the expectations are the same and we haven’t changed a whole lot of schemes. The difference is now we have a group of guys who trust each other, trust what the coaches say, don’t care who scores points and work hard every day. Over time, a group like that is naturally going to get better.”
Uniontown’s struggles
While McGuffey is a surprise winner this year, another team in its section is surprisingly losing again. Uniontown is 6-8 and in danger of not making the playoffs for the second consecutive season. Considering Uniontown’s history, that is shocking.
Uniontown has made the playoffs 60 times, which ties Washington for the most in WPIAL history. Uniontown also has 47 section titles, the most in WPIAL history.
The last time Uniontown went two consecutive seasons without making the playoffs was 1989-90.
Hall calls George Karl
The annual Pittsburgh High School Classic is staged by the Pittsburgh Basketball Club and will be this weekend with nine games over Saturday and Sunday at Montour High School. Some of the best teams and players in the WPIAL and City League will participate.
But part of the weekend is induction ceremonies Saturday for the eighth Pittsburgh Basketball Club Hall of Fame. One of the inductees will be George Karl, who gained fame as a long-time NBA coach. But Karl was a former WPIAL star player at Penn Hills High School. As a senior in 1969, Karl led Penn Hills to its first WPIAL title game.
Penn Hills played Farrell in front of 8,924 at the Civic Arena. But Karl was held to 14 points and Penn Hills lost, 70-59.
Some other former stars from the WPIAL and City League who went on to big things in college also will be inducted. Among them are twins Barry and Garry Nelson, who played at Fox Chapel before playing on some terrific teams at Duquesne; Ricky Coleman, a City League great at Schenley who played at Jacksonville; Laurel Highlands’ Will Robinson, a West Virginia University star who averaged 24.3 points for the Moutaineers in the 1970-71 season; and Central Catholic’s Jim McCoy, one of the all-time leading scorers at Massachusetts who played on coach John Calipari’s first team at UMass.
Hall of Fame ceremonies will be at noon Saturday at the DoubleTree by Hilton Pittsburgh, near the Airport.
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.