Guest: Rate in order these 5 sports towns/programs. Claritin, beaver falls, new castle, Farrell, aliquippa
Mike White: Hard to do that without more qualifiers. The best in football and basketball??? Best in sports overall, including baseball, etc.??? Best in the past 25 years?? Best ever. I mean Beaver Falls baseball used to be very good and is still is decent. Was in WPIAL final a few years ago. If you just go football and basketball - and in school history I think Aliquippa obviously one. Farrell No. 2. Beaver Falls three. New Castle four. Clairton five.
T OShea: I hear you have a good relationship with the Miller Family. Do you think there's any mutual interest between Pitt and either Sean or Archie?
Mike White: Absolutely not with Sean. No way. No way. No way.
I'd say unlikely with Archie also. Although Archie might at least listen. Even have talked with their father about this.
What you have to understand is this. At Dayton, basketball is "the" thing. They just renovated their arena. Archie has gotten bumps in salary. They take care of him. He and his family love it there. He is happy and he has it rolling there. Team is young.
Read More
I think highly of both of them. Would be tremendous if they came to Pitt. Should never say never, but not with Sean. Only a little chance with Archie. Only thing with Archie is might be a considerable bump in pay.
Will: 07 Schenley is obviously the best team since 05, but who are your others?
Mike White: Just since 2005?? I'd have to think fast. But New Castle in 2014. Heck, they finished undefeated in Quad-A. They didn't have to play a team like Roman Catholic, but still. They did not a Division I basketball player but were ultimate "team." And they finished undefeated. How can argue with that.
This year's Allderdice team might be second best behind Schenley team. Would be great game between Allderdice and New Castle 2014 team. This Allderdice team was really, really good.
Joe: What is your position with the Catholic (Private schools) and their ability to recruit? No one ever mentions the lack of facilities. Saw a photo of the Pine Richland work out room. Central Catholic would love to have 1/4 of that space. No one complained about Central in the 90's when they were a whipping boy fro the WPIAL.
Mike White: Those schools don't necessarily recruit. I think what bothers most people is they have no geographic boundaries. Players can go there from anywhere and not have to move.
But this area is not even in the same world as Philly. It's ridiculous over there, mostly with just basketball. It seems policing transfers for athletic intent is not a concern of District 12 officials. If kids in this area would make comments about transfers like some do in Philly, they would fast be in a hearing with the WPIAL and probably be made ineligible.
I don't see a team from WPIAL largest classes in boys winning another state title for a while. It will not happen often because of the Philly schools.
But thing we have to face over here. There is so much more basketball talent in Philly area. They have to go to school somewhere. Then again, many more people in Philly and many more schools in the city.
Guest 789: Any rumors or thoughts on some strong candidates of the vacant "big school" coaching positions? I.E. West A and South Fayette boys basketball or a school with a good history of hoops like Sto-Rox boys bball..
Mike White: Not really. I know South Fayette job interests lot of people. Growing district. Rich Bonnaure did a great job there. Brentwood coach Dave Mislan is one to watch out for.
Believe me, Sto-Rox is not a coveted job, no matter the history. Not an easy place to coach, for a number of reasons.
Hulk Hogan: Someone tweeted a few weeks ago that the WPIAL junior class has three juniors with Olympic potential. Franklin Regional wrestler and two track and field throwers. What are your thoughts on that?
Mike White: They're talking about Spencer Lee of FRegional. A junior who might be best high school wrestler in country and is one of best ever from Western Pa. You would think he would have a shot.
Other two are Jordan Geist, shot put and discus thrower from Knoch. And Madison Wiltrout javeline thrower from Connellsville. Geist marks in indoor in shot are among best ever in the country for high schools. Yeah, you would think if he keeps improving he has a shot.
Wiltrout set national record in javelin last year but had elbow surgery in summer. You set national high school record in javelin, you'd think she has a shot someday. Don't know how she is after surgery. Have to check on that.
But yeah, I think there is a possibility of Olympics. But it's hard to say with athletes like that. Have they peaked yet??? Will they keep getting better???
WPIAL Joey: Hi Mike, thanks for the chat. Was Dice simply outclassed in Hershey? Bad match-up?
Mike White: I wouldn't say outclassed. Heck, they didn't lose by 30. They lost by 11. Roman was just bigger -- and better. I talked to coach Buddy Valinsky shortly before game and his biggest worry was getting beat up inside. That's what happened. Allderdice has some size, but not wide bodies.
Lamar Stevens of Roman (PSU recruit) is a man. He transferred to Roman this year. Honestly, if he doesn't transfer this year, the game is close. He made a HUGE difference. And was just thinking. If he transferred to Allderdice, Dragons undoubtedly win.
Jamie Dixons Plane: I don't understand how someone like Castello from Mars doesn't get more looks in basketball. I get that he's undersized at 6'5", but he's been one of the best in the state. Thoughts?
Mike White: Just not big enough. He's a "5" guy at 6-5. Where do you see them on the Division I level. I love the kid. No. 1 really good player. And I don't know him as a good friend, but I had a lot of dealings with him. Seems like a great kid.
Just not big enough. Even his coach said if he was 6-8, would've been number of Division I schools in to look at him. Think of it. Where do you see 6-5 guys playing the "5" on Division I level.
But he was excellent high school player. Love his footwork, post moves, and could step out and make outside shot sometimes.
Bill Holtz: Is Duquesne mens basketball recruiting any Local seniors? Thanks
Mike White: No seniors. I hate to say this, but as far as Division I talent, this senior class in Western Pa. was one of worst ever. Doesn't mean there weren't good players. A number of them. Just not Division I kids. Only one who signed Div. 1 is James Edwards of Plum with Air Force.
That being said, I have a hard time believing James Jackson of Allderdice couldn't play at low D-1 school. But he has some issues, like grades. He would have to get much stronger also. But the kid has talent.
I think Creighton could play somewhere also, low D-1. Our players around here are better college prospects than people think. Not saying for Duke or UNC, but lower level D-1s. Look at what some of them have done lately who have done D-1.
Guest 123: Guys you would go after if you were the Pitt AD? (Realistic chances also)
Mike White: I'd call Archie most definitely. Hard to say who else because I don't know who is "realistic." People, and even media, always throw these names out there, but they're not realistic.
WPIAL Joey: Aside from the Millers, is there anybody else from this area that is a viable candidate for the Pitt vacancy?
Mike White: Can't think of anyone. Why does the next Pitt coach have to have ties to the area???? But if you insist, isn't Andy Toole kind of from this area??? I mean he is coaching at a school here and has done a pretty darn good job there. But I don't think he would be considered.
If you insist on guys from area, how about Matt Driscoll at North Florida?? Was in NCAA last year.
Guest: I just wonder now that the PIAA has taken aim at the WPIAL will they go the same to the philly schools for transfers.
Mike White: Nope. Transfers, private and charter schools are hottest topic in this state. But PIAA doesn't seem concerned about it at all. And the districts are divided on what they think about transfers.
What people also don't understand is there is no way private/Catholic/charter schools will ever be separated. PIAA would be in court being sued faster than they could blink.
wpial fan: Aliquippa vs Clairton FINALLY, with who each team has coming back, early prediction? Sellout? And who wins?
Mike White: I don't know about a sellout. Lot of room to stand at Clairton. Aliquippa lost a lot of skill but has linemen back and some up and coming players. Clairton has some people back also.
Wow. That's hard to pick right now. OK, tie me up and make me and I would probably pick Clairton right now. That could change though when you see who exactly is back.
Major Harris: When will the Fab 5 teams be in the paper? And can you drop a name or two of kids who will be on there?
Mike White: The Fab 5 teams for boys and girls will be in Sunday's paper. And no I can NOT give away any names. C'mon, man. LOL. But you can figure out who some of them will be.
Photoshoot with Fab 5 players tomorrow night. Look for it in Sunday along with the all section teams, which also generate a lot of interest.
OK let me ask you, who should boys player of the year be??? Any thoughts.
And girls???
Major Harris: And is the PG still going to be doing the zone Fab 5 teams?
Mike White: Whassup Major (ha ha)
Unfortunately no PG North, South, East and West Fab 5 teams this year. Unfortunately, those editions of our paper will no longer exist after this week. It's been a long run for them.
We will have a big "Local" edition starting Friday and appearing every Friday. Big part of that will be our "Varsity Xtra" pages. A lot high school sports in there, to kind of take the place of zones.
Mike White: No questions about Notre Dame coming in and getting two Central Catholic players. I thought there might be some questions on that.
Mike White: We'll have baseball rankings coming out later this week. Biggest story this spring might be Plum baseball player Alex Kirilloff. Lot of people might not know about him or heard about him, but check this out . His stock has soared over past year and is being projected as a possible first-round draft pick. Outfielder.
WPIAL Joey: I can see the appeal of ND for these Central kids, but a little surprised they committed so early. Do you think it's a big blow for Pitt? Do they commit early to avoid losing the offer?
Mike White: No it wasn't because they might lose offer. They are best friends and decided they wanted to go somewhere together and both loved Notre Dame. So they decided to get it over with. They checked out other schools.
I wouldn't say it's a "blow" to Pitt. Sure you want to get the best local kids, but it's not going to kill Pitt. There are still some other top notch kids left in local area that Pitt is involved with.
One thing I would say that it is yet another example that there isn't now - there wasn't in the past - and there won't be in the future -- the so-called "fence around Western Pennsylvania." Meaning, no matter who the coach is at Pitt or Penn State, they won't keep all the local kids. I laugh when coaches say that. It's just not realistic to get all the local kids. It has never been that way.
Besides, you can't live off Western Pa. kids any more. There simply aren't enough big timers any more from here. Sure, there are still a number of good ones. Try to get the best ones, but I've said for a while now that the key for Pitt is also getting top kids in other places.
123: What are your thoughts on Romeo Langford? He looks pretty legit.
Mike White: I have never seen him except couple highlights. For those who don't know, he's a stud sophomore from Indiana. Obviously must be pretty good. Had 46 in state game recently.
Guest: Should High School athletes be paid?
Mike White: No. That's ridiculous.
Guest: What if kids want to play HS sports to get scholarships, but they can't because they have to work a job after school to help out family? Paying the kids even a minimum amount to play sports would help out.
Mike White: Ridiculous.
Then work at night after practice or weekends. What, should 6th graders get paid, too.???
Guest: Are young people around Pittsburgh more likely to try marijuana now that they know Martavis Bryant does it?
Mike White: I'm not a drug counselor.
Guest: Will Jamie Dixon possibly consider returning to coach in the High School ranks if things don't work out at TCU?
Mike White: Sto-Rox job is open.
Guest: Are tattoos allowed for HS athletes in Pennsylvania?
Mike White: You serious??
Yes.
Kevin: Do you think the PIAA will ever take aim at the philly schools like it did to the WPIAL
Mike White: Answered this question earlier.
Guest: 6th graders getting paid seems insane, Mike. You can't seriously condone that!
Mike White: Yes, I do. And the 3 and 4 year olds whose parents are so naive and wacky that they sign them up for a sport should get paid also.
Guest: Lebron couldn't have tattoos visible when he play HS ball in OHio
Mike White: Well tattoos are on many high school players.
Mike White: Well, that's about it for now. Thanks for participating.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.