HERSHEY, Pa. — This year’s Allderdice team was only the ninth from the City League to make a PIAA title game since 1980. After a loss to Roman Catholic in the Class AAAA championship Saturday, a natural question is where does this 28-2 Allderdice team belong among the City League’s all-time best squads?
Allderdice coach Buddy Valinsky believes the Dragons aren’t as good as some of the all-time great teams, like 1971 Schenley, 1976 Fifth Avenue or the 2007 Schenley team. But Allderdice should still live in City League lore.
Valinsky knows a thing or two about top City League teams. He played at Allderdice in the late 1970s.
“I never said we could play with that 2007 Schenley [state championship] team with DeJuan Blair,” said Valinsky. “We’re not as good as some of those other great City League teams because of their size. We were more of a small, quick team. A big, athletic team we would have had problems with. Anyone who didn’t have a 6-7 kid, we’d be OK.”
Besides losing only twice, Allderdice had three 1,000 point scorers in the senior class — James Jackson, Tim Jackson and Ramon Creighton. That is highly unusual.
“When you look back at this year, we beat the WPIAL [AAAA] champ, Pine-Richland,” said Valinsky. “We beat the [AAA] champ Beaver Falls. We beat the [AA] runner-up. That’s pretty good. So this really a good team.”
Stevens a difference
Many wondered how good Roman Catholic would have been if Lamar Stevens hadn’t transferred from Haverford School to Roman for this season. Stevens, a 6-foot-7 forward, had 27 points and seven rebounds. When he decided to transfer, Stevens was quoted in articles saying he would like to play with Tony Carr and Nazeer Bostick for their senior years. Stevens, Carr and Bostick all played on the same AAU team.
Stevens’ comments could certainly be construed as a player transferring for athletic reasons. But Stevens was allowed to play without any problems from District 12 (Philadelphia) officials.
Allderdice’s Creighton tweeted after the game, “If Lamar doesn’t transfer there we win by 20 and everybody know that.”
Attendance
Attendance for the eight title games at Giant Center was 17,091. That’s better than the final year at Penn State in 2012, when only 14,421 attended. But attendance is still not anywhere near what it used to be when the games were played in Hershey up until a decade ago.
From 2004-06, the crowds at Giant Center were between 33,000 and 34,000. The games moved to Penn State in 2007, but returned to Hershey in 2012. The 2013 games drew 24,582.
What has severely hurt attendance is the addition of the Philadelphia Public and Catholic schools. The Public schools joined the PIAA in 2004 and the Catholic schools in 2009. Some of those schools that come from those two leagues don’t bring 100 fans to the final games.
Allderdice undoubtedly had the most fans. Allderdice sold its allotted 900 tickets by Thursday afternoon.
Weekend of blowouts
If blowouts mean bad games, then this was the worst group of championship games since the PIAA started four classifications in 1984.
The winning margin in all eight of the boys and girls games was at least 11 points. It was the first time since 1984 that all of the games were decided by double digits. Overall, the average winning margin was 21.2 points.
Louisville offers Carmody
Saturday morning, less than 12 hours after his team lost in the Class AAA championship, Mars sophomore guard Robby Carmody was offered a scholarship by Louisville. Carmody now has offers from more than a half dozen major colleges. Pitt, Duquesne, Penn State, Xavier and Purdue are among the other schools that offered.
Two days after Mars lost, Carmody was on a plane to Amsterdam. He was invited to play for Team Ohio in the Junior International Tournament. Carmody left Sunday for Amsterdam. Team Ohio will play against some other club teams from overseas.
While Carmody was leaving for another country, two other teammates were playing in an all-star game one night after the Planets lost to Neumann-Goretti in the PIAA final. Mars’ John Castello scored 21 points and was named the West team MVP in the Cager Classic at Highlands High School. Teammate Christian Schmitt scored 22.
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1975 and Twitter @mwhiteburgh.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.