No Penn Hills player had ever been in a WPIAL playoff game and coach Dan DeRose’s worries about his team were coming true, as the Indians trailed Butler by nine points midway through the second quarter.
“I thought we were a little tight, and that’s OK because I expected that,” DeRose said. “But I was still banking on we would get loose.”
But Penn Hills’ playoff fortunes didn’t turn on just getting loose. They hinged on getting loose balls.
Penn Hills’ defensive traps and quick hands caused almost two-dozen turnovers and the Indians eventually broke loose for a 64-46 victory in a WPIAL Class AAAA first-round playoff game at North Allegheny.
It was Penn Hills’ first playoff win since 2009, and getting those loose balls were key. Butler had 23 turnovers. Penn Hills (18-5), the No. 3 seed, used those turnovers to turn a nine-point deficit into a one-point lead at halftime. Penn Hills led, 44-31, after three quarters.
“I told people I thought Butler was the best shooting team in the tournament, and I told our guys that,” said DeRose, in his first season as Penn Hills coach. “But I thought they didn’t handle the ball very well, which would play to our strength.
Read More
“I told the guys we would probably have to get to the mid- to upper-20s in turnovers to beat them. … We didn’t trap well early on and didn’t force turnovers like we needed to. If you don’t trap well, you can give up open 3s.”
Butler (15-8), the fourth-place team from Section 3, made 4 of 8 3-pointers in the first quarter. Over the next two quarters, it wasn’t so much that Butler did not make many 3-pointers. It was simply the Golden Tornado had trouble even getting shots because of the turnovers.
After getting 13 shots in the first quarter, Butler got only 19 in the next two quarters and made four. Butler was bothered by some foul trouble in the first half, but was bothered by Penn Hills’ defense after that. Forwards Connor Ollio and Tyler Frederick, the team’s two leading scorers, combined for only 15 points. Guard Luke Michalek came off the bench to score 10.
Senior guard Jeremiah Ligon led Penn Hills with 17 points and junior guard Sherron Schifino added 14.
“I don’t think the first half was bad with turnovers,” Butler coach Matt Clement said. “I think we just lost trust in the process in the second half. We panicked with the ball. We dribbled too far into [the press], weren’t active enough on the sidelines. … It looked really pretty when we did it right. But it looked really bad at times, too.”
From the five-minute mark of the second quarter through the end of the third, Penn Hills outscored Butler, 31-9. Butler took a 31-28 lead in the third quarter, but Penn Hills went on a 16-0 run to end the quarter, and eventually end Butler’s season.
“I think this was a very important win to help restore basketball back to where it once was [at Penn Hills],” DeRose said. “None of the kids in that school had any basketball to cheer about since they were in high school. Now they have that and we want to take it as far as we can.”
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1975 and Twitter @mwhiteburgh.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.