SHARON, Pa. — On Erie Cathedral Prep’s first possession of the game, the Ramblers missed a shot and got the offensive rebound. Missed another shot and got the rebound. Missed another shot and got the rebound.

It was a sign of things to come.

Mars couldn’t keep Cathedral Prep off the boards, couldn’t keep Cathedral Prep from penetrating into the lane and couldn’t keep the Ramblers from a date in the PIAA semifinals.

The best season in Mars history came to an end Friday night at Sharon High School when Cathedral Prep beat the Planets, 62-56, in a PIAA Class AAA quarterfinal.

Advertise with us

The win moves Cathedral Prep (22-6) into the semifinals Tuesday against Archbishop Carroll, which defeated New Castle, 77-48, in another quarterfinal. Mars (26-3) had the most wins in school history and had never won a PIAA playoff game before this season.

But the journey ended against a Cathedral Prep team that wasn’t overly big, but was awfully efficient.

“The big issue for us was rebounding,” Mars coach Rob Carmody said.

And also keeping Cathedral Prep from getting into the lane with drives. The Ramblers had only one 3-pointer, but sliced up the Mars defense with penetrating moves from a few different players. Cathedral Prep shot 68 percent (15 of 22) from the field in the second half, but almost every shot was close to the basket after a drive, a pass for a layup or a put-back.

“What’s funny is our M.O. has kind of been different game by game,” Cathedral Prep coach Mark Majewski said. “Some teams have slowed it down, so we’ve been more patient and tried to work our game. This game, we were able to get to the rim a little more and were able to break down guys and get to the basket. Rebounding was big, too.”

Advertise with us

John Castello, a 6-foot-5 junior, led Mars with 16 points and junior forward Alex Gruber added 14. But Mars shot only 35 percent from the field in the first three quarters.

The score was tied, 22-22, at halftime and Rob Carmody, son of the coach, hit a 3-pointer to start the third quarter. But Cathedral Prep went on a 19-6 run to grab a 41-31 lead with 2:04 left in the third quarter.

Guard Matt Colpoys scored 12 of his game-high 18 points in the second half for Cathedral Prep. Forward Charlie Fessler, a Northwestern University football recruit, scored 11 of his 14 in the second half. Senior forward Joe Fustine scored 17.

“If you had to pick one guy that really swung the game in their favor, it was Colpoys,” coach Rob Carmody said.

Mars closed to 56-52 with 57 seconds left, but could get no closer.

Advertise with us

“These games at this level, it’s about execution,” Carmody said. “Good skill is there with everybody. This was a very competitive game, but it boiled down to execution and they out-executed us.”

Mars will have every starter back next season.

“This is the best year Mars ever had,” Carmody said. “There has been so much community support. At one point, I had to turn around and wonder if this many people were cheering for Mars?”

“There is no question we didn’t play a perfect game, but there is no question about whether we put in the effort.”

Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1975 and Twitter @mwhiteburgh.