SHARON, Pa. -- Shaler had triumphed in its past two PIAA playoff games despite the absence of standout center J.P. Holtz, who had a season-ending foot injury in the team's preliminary-round win.
On Saturday, the Titans played the majority of a game without star guard Geno Thorpe.
Playing with Thorpe on the bench most of the time was too tough to overcome.
Thorpe was saddled with foul trouble throughout and, despite a gutsy comeback effort, Shaler was defeated by District 10 champion Erie Cathedral Prep, 52-49, in a PIAA Class AAAA quarterfinal game at Sharon High School.
Shaler, playing in the quarterfinals for the first time, finished 25-4. Cathedral Prep (21-5) advanced to play District 1 runner-up Lower Merion in the PIAA semifinals.
Thorpe, a junior averaging 22 points per game, scored 31, 20 and 24 in Shaler's three playoff wins. Against Cathedral Prep, he played roughly 12 minutes and finished with a season-low three points.
"[Missing Thorpe] hurt us, but you know what, it hurt us when we lost John Holtz. But we somehow managed to adjust and get the job done," Shaler coach Paul Holzshu said. "When we lost Geno today I thought some kids stepped up big and tried to make the plays necessary to give us a chance to win. Cathedral Prep just made more plays than we did."
Despite playing extensively without Thorpe, Shaler stayed within striking distance throughout, never falling behind by more than nine points.
Shaler trailed, 41-35, after three quarters but pulled within 41-40 a minute into the fourth quarter after Mike Titterington's 3-pointer and Ryan Mincher's layup. In a game the Titans never led, it marked the closest they would get since being tied in the opening minutes.
The Titans fell behind again by six, but Zack Taylor made a 3-pointer from the right wing to make the score 49-46 with 45 seconds left. Seconds later, Cathedral Prep's Chris Francis missed the front end of a one-and-one, giving the Titans a chance to tie. However, Sean Gavin's 3-point attempt from the right corner with 30 seconds left missed. Cathedral Prep responded with a fastbreak layup and eventually took a five-point lead before Mincher scored the game's final points as time expired.
"We got some good looks, but we didn't make the plays at the end of the game," Holzshu said.
Not helping Shaler's cause was a 2 of 6 effort from the free-throw line in the final quarter. Thorpe accounted for three of those misses. The Titans finished the game 19 of 28 from the line.
Thorpe's foul trouble began early. He was whistled for his second foul with 5:15 left in the first quarter. Thorpe exited the game and did not return until the opening minute of the second quarter, then picked up his third foul with 5:02 left, forcing him to sit the remainder of the half.
"When Geno picked up some fouls, we tried to take advantage of him being out of the game," Cathedral Prep coach Mark Majewski said. "We came in at halftime and said, 'Look, when he gets back into the game, he's going to want to attack. Let's try to draw a charge.' "
Cathedral Prep did just that, as Thorpe was called for his fourth foul with 4:17 left in the third quarter. He exited and did not return until midway through the fourth quarter.
"But I'll tell you what, their other kids really stepped up their game," Majewski said.
Taylor was huge, making three 3-pointers on his way to a game-high 19 points. Brian Bittner added nine.
Cathedral Prep, which won its 12th consecutive game, got an outstanding effort from junior guard Sheldon Zablotney, who led the Ramblers with 17 points.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.