There has been a lot of talk in recent years about how many teams get into the WPIAL basketball playoffs.

Heck, there has been talk of the abundance of playoff berths in just about every sport, but for the sake of thisdiscussion, we are going to limit the topic to basketball.

So often, when the topic comes up, people like to quantify their "too many teams make the playoffs" argument with the number of teams that get in with sub-.500 records and, furthermore, simply the number of teams that, well, get in.

This year, with the top four finishers in each section earning spots in the playoffs, there are a combined 157 boys' and girls' teams that earned berths in the postseason -- some 59 percent of all 266 teams that took the floor this season in the WPIAL.

Advertise with us

The teams with bad records getting in really don't seem to be the story here because, quite honestly, most of them get knocked out in a preliminary-round game or in the first round.

No, the concern here is for how this affects the WPIAL's elite teams, or at least the teams that proved to be the best throughout the regular season.

With the expanded field, so often these very good teams have to spend an exorbitant amount of time -- more than a week in some cases -- stagnant, without a playoff game scheduled as other teams fight it out.

Look at the Jeannette boys' team and what the Jordan Hall-led, reigning PIAA champions have had to endure by getting the top seed in the WPIAL Class AA bracket for these playoffs. The Jayhawks played their final regular season game on Feb. 6, then had to wait all the way until last night to tipoff against Rochester in a first-round playoff game.

That is 12 days.

Advertise with us

That is too long to go without a game this time of year.

Same with the Beaver Falls boys' team. Coach Doug Biega's Tigers played their final regular-season game on Feb. 6, but also had to wait until yesterday to play in their first postseason game -- also a 12-day layoff.

It isn't just indigenous to the boys' game, either. All you need to do is look at the best team in the highest class of the girls' game -- Mt. Lebanon. All the Blue Devils did this regular season was go a perfect 22-0. And what did they get? Sure, they got an opponent that had to play in a preliminary game -- McKeesport in this case -- but the Blue Devils had to wait from the end of their regular season on Feb. 9 until Tuesday to play a game. That eight-day layoff is just too much.

And then there is the case of the Sto-Rox girls' team. The Vikings' regular season ended on Feb. 2 and they didn't play again until last night -- a 16-day break!

So while, in some cases, these top teams get byes, they also get layoffs that could lead to them getting rusty, and get sneaked up on in playoff action.

Advertise with us

The thought here is that having too many teams in the field forces this problem and, yes, it is a problem.

At a girls' game?

Sure, if you've been to enough high school boys' basketball games, you've undoubtedly seen the tempers get a little out of hand and some fists start flying. It is the nature of the beast(s) when you are dealing with teenage kids who lace up a pair of sneakers in a crowded gym to lay it on the line for personal and school pride.

But, how about what happened last Wednesday at the District 10 girls' game between Meadville and Sharon.

This from Lisa Byers of the Meadville Tribune about the incident:

Advertise with us

What is clear is Meadville freshman DeQueisha Epps and Sharon sophomore Brittany Benedetto -- who were involved in a fight at center court that cleared both benches -- were ejected from the contest and according to PIAA rules are not eligible to play in their teams' next games, which for both teams would be the 1st round of the District 10 playoffs.

The players who left the bench during the fight have also been disqualified, according to [PIAA associate executive director Dr. Robert] Lombardi, who would not list those individuals, leaving it up to school officials from both teams to release that information. But he said he believed there were a total of eight players involved.

And here is the follow-up from Byers that was published -- quite unfittingly -- on Valentine's Day:

The PIAA ruled Thursday [Feb. 12] that a total of eight players were ejected following an altercation in the final 14 seconds of Meadville's 68-58 overtime loss to Sharon Wednesday.

On Friday [Feb. 13], Meadville officials announced that four of those players were from Meadville, including freshman DaQueisha Epps, who was involved in the skirmish. An additional three players were ejected for leaving the bench, which is a violation of PIAA rules. Meadville officials confirmed through videotape of the game that these three players were not involved in the incident.

Review of the video also prompted school officials to impose a one-game suspension on a fifth Meadville player, who they determined to have left the bench as well during the scuffle.